Happy Groundhog's Day Hubbers! Did you know that PETA wants to replace Punxsutawney Phil, Groundhog Day's beloved mascot, with a ROBOT claiming that the star of the February 2nd tradition is being exploited! What do you think?!!
I think we should BBQ Punxsutawney Phil and serve him up with some cole slaw and potato salad!
Typical Texan, thinking with their stomach!
Is that good or bad? Now that I think about it you're right, probably should add a Bearnaise sauce!
as long as it never sees its damn shadow, I dont care if they use a stuffed animal. But...I also think peta is going overboard. maybe theyll do some sort of naked protest?
Justine I think Phil did see his shadow today meaning six more weeks of winter). I like winter in Georgia so no complaints here! How about a naked Peta protest using a naked robot?
that would be like getting rid of or replacing "Buckeye Chuck"
Its kind of our Ohio-Pennsylvania rivalry , in a way, just like a Browns Steelers game.
Let Tradition be tradition, the animals are not harmed and are very well taken care of, they are quite the local celebrities!
i think those PETA people are going a little overboard. maybe Phil likes his gig...
a robot? good grief.
PETA is trying to make headlines every which way. One of their last campaigns was to replace the UGA mascot with a robot. That campaign failed because they didn't do their homework. "Ugga" the official mascot, lives better than most humans on earth and is well cared for and seemingly loves his life. Good grief, in the 50's and 60's the boy (an earlier "ugga" obviously) had his own hotel suite, his own groomer and his own handler. PETA needs a reality check.
Am I the only who hears creepy echoes of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep (the book that became Blade Runner) in this whole animal robot deal?
Weird stuff. That groundhog (whose name I can't spell) is an enormous, lazy old fuzzball who's cared for better than his poor wild counterparts. I assure PETA that he gets fed and watered and medical care and probably luvin's and all that crap, and all he has to do is get held up in front of a crowd once a year. He's a happy hog. I'm all for animal rights, don't get me wrong...but the PETA people are just out there. They complain and make a fuss about weird fringe stuff and fail to do anything (that I can see) about the really terrible common abuses that even moderates can agree on. Strange.
I agree totally. If they keep it up, I just might start wearing my Mom's mink coat when I visit the north in winter, as a PETA protest.
i know this sounds terrible, especially since i have a little furry creature of my own (a rabbit), but sometimes i see fur coats like white mink and think 'ahh'...i would love to wear one just once. mmm i bet they are soft and silky.
but i do think it is wrong to slaughter defenseless creatures like baby seals and whatnot just to take their skins.
I think there's a fine line between what's politically correct and what's not when it comes to the fur industry. If it's about inhumane treatment to animals (PETA's main "pet peeve") something can be done to correct it. If it's about using animals for our own purposes, well that opens up a whole different kettle of fish (or lamb stew if you please).
Recently the figure skater Johnny Weir was ruthlessly attacked by PETA and other animal activists for having a bit of fox trim on his costume. His reply was one of disgust saying "“You’re protecting animals (while) we have soldiers dying all around the world.” He also asked why they didn't pick on those who wear leather and other hides. Interesting point.
Everything/everyone could be exploited and still reap huge benefits. The question is in that exploitation is there any real, damaging abuse. That would be the problem, not exploitation. The word is too broad, and to use as solely a negative form is just narrow minded and slightly stupid.
Hence, leave Phil alone. He's luckier than most Americans.
I am a huge animal lover, and PETA has done a lot of good for animals over the years, but they've gone off the deep end more than once, and this is one of those times.
They lose credibility when they push issues like this.
I've heard that Phil is well taken care of!
Peta is saying that Phil is being abused because he's on display all year and is subjected to screaming crowds, excited children, ect, ect. I say, if Phil is happily eating his 3 square meals and shows no sign of aggresssion or illness, he's better off entertaining the crowds than fending for himself in the wild.
with that logic, it would carry over into a lot of things.
animals adapt to their environment.
mabye they should have robo teachers in the classrooms!
Ummm...in some cases, from what I remember of my school days...they already DO have robo teachers in the classrooms!
Of course, we can expect to hear about the radical new RATS orgazation any day now.... (That would be the "Robo-Abused Teacher Surrogates".)
Why don't we replace Phil with Al Gore? He's about as accurate.
Just for the record..According to the Groundhog Inner Circle, Phil is extremely accurate with a spot on prediction of 100%. Although it's also been said that it is practically impossible to have an early spring. Depends on where you live too
The little fellow is a STAR and has STAR POWER, how could any idiot even think about replacing him.
Not that I agree with an animal giving prediction about how long winter season is going to be. It's simply foolish. But, again, it's a star after so many years and that star power is going to keep him in charge, per se.
I could not care any less with whether or not it saw it's own shadow.
#1 Phil has it better than most groundhogs do.
#2 What would happen to him if they started using a robot instead?
-He would have to be put in a zoo because he has been in human civilization for so long that he'd never make it in the wild. A zoo would be the exact same environment.
#3 Dogs and cats are subjected to screaming children and large crowds of people all the time. Is PETA going to try to take away my cats next? That's not gonna happen!
I think PETA does some good things, but some things they do are RIDICULOUS. Phil is happy, healthy, and an icon. If anything, Phil shows people that animals are useful and should be treated with respect.
Remember when PETA trashed the President for swatting a fly? It's unbelievable what they'll do for publicity. (hey don't pick up on Obama on this thread puhleeze :lol
Yes, that was insane considering the average fly only lives 24-72 hours anyway. And, if they know so much about animals, they would also know that, because of over-population, flies spread disease among human beings and other animals, as do mosquitoes. PETA is crazy.
Oh, PETA...making us vegetarians, vegans an animal activists often look silly. I appreciate their conviction, but this is overboard...how they go about things does not encourage or educate people about animal problems, rather pushes them away sometimes!
People do far worse things to animals than have a groundhog as a mascot...they should be focusing their energies elsewhere like on cruelty in puppy mills, seal clubbing and fur trades.
EVIRIBODY THIS BEST OF TIME TAKE CARE MY FRIONS BY THE WAY ,YOU SHOUID SPREAD DON T MISS YOU GOOD LUCK AKBAR INDIA KERALA MEENANGADI 54
I believe the issue with Phil, which has not been noted even once, is that groundhogs normally hibernate....the conditions Phil lives in do not allow for him to live his natural rhythms
groundhogs hibernate between october and march/april so naturally phil shouldnt be awake to perform groundhogs day activities.
what keeps being cited as conditins better than many humans seems to suggest that a groundhog would prefer human conditions which it probably doesnt.
essentially a gilded cage situation
..its a retarded custom anyway, everyone seems to be stuck on the animatronics aspect ...who cares, why not just stop it completely...Bill Murray didnt seem happy when he was stuck in Punxsutawney
Very insightful comment sunforged; however, Phil is not on display all year as PETA suggests. Those who live in Punxsutawney have responded by saying that Phil is allowed to hibernate. I don't exactly know whether they "wake him up" for groundhog's day.
Ive done some light research since reading this thread, according to what ive seen so far, Phil lives in a "habitat" in their library and is on display year round
I have not read any of the other postings because I don't want to be influenced by anyone else's opinions. I think that Phil is an institution that should be kept going. No robot is ever going to replace the sensationalism that one little ground hog has created over the years. I thoroughly enjoyed the movie Groundhog Day with Bill Murray and I am of the opinion if it had been a robot the movie would never have made the silver screen. I have never been present for one of the events but my son lived in Dubois for 18 months and took the trip down. He reported that the event was every bit as fun as it appears to be on TV.
by flashmakeit 7 years ago
Will the internet replace the television or will the TV soon replace the internet?
by Victoria Lynn 5 years ago
After how many miles should tires on a vehicle be replaced?
by Donnacha C 8 years ago
the latest canditate mentioned is pint sized Chelsea-legend Gianfranco Zola....who do you think would be the best replacement for the ever so polite and gracious Ancelotti? Should he be even replaced in the first place?
by YvetteParker 8 years ago
How many things can you think of that the internet has replaced?Remember those huge 26 volume Britannica Encyclopedias of the days of old?
by Danielle H 4 years ago
Should technology replace human labor???
by IDONO 6 years ago
Do you think Fallon will replace Leno as well as Leno replaced Carson?Leno had one hard pair of shoes to fill and did a good job of it. But I'm not so sure if Jimmy Fallon can do the same. What do you think?
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|