Should people write when they are depressed? Or, should sadness be described in the retrospect?
When a person is depressed, s/he is sometimes biased towards negativity. Do you think writing in such state of mind can spread negativity/sadness/depression in readers? And even for the author himself/herself when s/he reads own writing at a later stage? What would you choose from the trade off? Channelizing sadness through expression in writing or not letting the negativity spread - waiting till you've achieved better poised state and then write in the retrospect?
I think writing from either state of mind carries value. If a person writes when in a state of depression, it can be cathartic. Likewise, if that same person is feeling sad. I think it's productive to write as a method of expression in either state as a way of release and since I view it as productive, I don't necessarily feel it's negatively perceived. I think perception and the effects of same vary between individuals. If the reader is empathetic, any sad language is going to be "felt." I think if the person who is performing the writing revisits what was written, oftentimes, that person can either think, "Wow, I wrote that?" or can see how much self-growth took place since the time that person was sad, etc. I say write all the time.
Just write. Look at it this way: Do you only wait to write on sunny days? Write when you can--no matter what. It's the EDITING that counts.
Most world famous poets are depressed from any ways. I mean read so many poets whether he is Eliot, Yeats, Keats, Shelley, Tennyson or any other great poet... They suffered from some problems and these problem inspired them to write. Actually writing is a therapy. So it really helps a lot to express sad views.
I agree with ytsenoh, writing carries value whether the writer is depressed or not. However, I tend to believe that negativity begets negativity and vice versa. If I were a poet, I might write while depressed, but, I'd likely regret it later. I would be worrying that I may have spread the depression elsewhere, which is something I would never want to do, bring another down with me.
Thankfully, my depressive states are short lived. I think that is mostly because I decide it has to go away.
I've written many poems whilst feeling a bit depressed. I agree that it's cathartic and not only you, but your readers see the progress too. I don't think you can actually spread negativity. It's not about being negative, but rather just expressing the feelings you have, whatever they may be. Others will recognize those feelings and you'll have a mutual understanding of them. It shows in the writing if someone is just lashing out negative thoughts or sincerely voicing their emotions and opinions. The first will often be met with disapproval (& yes, it might fuel negativity too) but the later is what I try to do.
If you write about feelings in retrospect, it's not quite the same and as genuine as within the moment because you have to think back. Hence the writing won't be as passionate.
A writer should write in all his moods. The manuscript produced when he is depressed may not be his final edition, but it will be an invaluable resource for authenticity in later work.
Yes, great works always come when people are depressed. I think when we are happy, we are content. So a few of us start writing their happy experience, while when we are sad we want to be alone and then only our real thoughts come in the forms of words.
I write whenever I feel like writing, and that may be during depressing times. Sometimes I write when I'm depressed to find out why I'm depressed; my muse is my best sounding board. I also write about anything and everything (editing is done later, and that includes the choice of whether to publish or not).
I don't think you should ever stifle your emotions when writing, of course you need ot channel your emotions into creative writing and not lets say a work report. I very often drawn on sullen feelings when writing some of, what I consider my best poetry.
Whether happy or sad, writing is about having an opinion. Anything that is well-written shows an opinion, takes a stance on a subject, and is biased in some way. Any expression in writing is better than waiting for a happier outlook on life. Some of the best works come about by feeling sadness, pain, or negativity.
by reggieTull 7 years ago
If depression is anger turned inward, then is it fair to say anger is depression turned outward?
by And Drewson 2 years ago
If someone is of sound mind, meaning they understand the consequences, should they be allowed to kill themselves?
by shemiahl 4 years ago
Should people be required to have drug test while on welfare?The reason why I ask is I work at a Travel Company and I had a customer ask me if we accept EBT (food stamps) I told her we didn't. I noticed that she had an HTC smart phone and her nails were done... Do you think this is fair? I don't...
by John Holden 6 years ago
Should people write hubs using biased information?I've seen quite a few hubs eulogising Margaret Thatcher. Usually posted by people with little or no experience of living in the UK and with no experience of living under Thatcher's rule.When challenged they often insist that they know more about the...
by Ruchira 7 years ago
Should people come after a month old anniversary of someone's demise to express their condolences?I feel they should not since the person who has suffered the loss, has come a long way (~30days) to overcome it and to take the person back to that memory is painful and making her do it all over...
by H C Palting 5 years ago
Should people be praised for doing the most basic things?Is a parent a good parent for simply providing food, shelter, and clothing...what about everything else that is required of parents? Is an employee due a pat on the back just for showing up? Does a person deserve a pat on the back for never...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|