Can you tell the age of a writer by their work?
Lots of people have no profile picture online or use an avator. Do you think you can roughly gauge a writer's age by their words?
Frequently, depending on the subject matter. If the person is talking about current events but does not mention any relationship to the past, he is very young. If a person talks about some type of classical topic, the demise of some tradition, he is older. Also, grammar and syntax tell a lot. Older people never say gonna nor speak with initials. Younger people usually are short on details in short answers and depend too much on TV personalities for their source regarding current events. There is nothing wrong, it is just a stage we all go through. I was young--once.
Thankyou Larry Wall for reading and for answering.
I smiled when you said 'I was young--once.'
I know how you feel.
What if the writer is old but after doing research, acts young and writes young and uses young words, etc.?
If he was old his phrases, adjectives and other similar things would give him away. However, it would be harder to detect age on a formal paper than a Hub question or comment.
I supppose if the writer is deliberately projecting a young age rather than their own more vintage one; then that is the age they will appear to be in the virtual world. As it's all about the words.
You made me grin, Larry. As you know, I'm no spring chicken--and although I will definitely say "gotta" when I'm being colloquial, "gonna" is still kind of...TABOO! LOL! (Note the Laugh Out Lout initials, deliberately and gracelessly inserted.)
Since we have not defined what is old and what is young, it even makes the line between old and young writers more blurry. Thus we may have proved that in some cases we can tell and in some, we can never be sure. I dunno.
This is a very profound question, Anna. I think sometimes you can determine the age of a writer by the lack of strength. Then again, that can apply to any new writer. I think age comes forth in the genre that they choose and the colloquailisms they choose. Older writers use metaphors because they relate old to the new, while young (new) writers don't have that luxury unless they have mentors or parents who teach them the wonders of yesteryear.
I'm a writer of old and don't relate much to the new format or mindset. However, I can spin a tale, write a poem and put forth my thoughts without anyone responding with WTF?.
A true writer doesn't show his age but rather his experience.
Possibly, but not usually. In my lifetime so far I've seen some older people with very little sense and some young people with a whole lot and vice versa.
Wisdom goes beyond years and age. It's a matter of the heart.
Forget about roughly gauging the age from the style or the subject or for that matter anything from writing of any hubbers here, actually I can not guess the age of a person face to face also if he/she is maintaining well.
Thank you and its a interesting question:-)
Apparently. Most seasoned and aged writers use wisdom and real life experiments, and experiences in their writings...the younger ones are mostly theoretical and basically based on the findings of their research.
Interesting theory. Thankyou for taking the time to answer Jynzly
I'm speaking as Professor for College students for more than 20 years. In just one look I will know what age bracket the writer is. Sophistication has nothing to do with it; and am not just being theoretical...it's a professional observation.
Thankyou for clarifying that Jynzly.
In that case it would seem that there is futher evidence to suggest that an experienced reader maybe able to pinpoint a writer's age.
Very interesting question. I think though, that the answer is no, because even if they style, genre and subject of writing might point to a particular age group, it doesn't mean that the writer is within that age group.
Some yes, some no. Even older writers may be unsophisticated in their style and approach.
I think it depends on the material they write, but some people wirte a variety of things so you never can guess.
I don't think I'd be able to guess. Some teenagers are very mature for their age and much more knowledgeable about some subjects than people twice their age. On the other hand, I know adults who have act and write like kids.
by Russell-D4 years ago
I always ask this one question of writers. Who do you write for?The answers vary a) I write for a general audience. b) I write for a specific audience c) I write for myself. c) always makes me smile because few of us...
by Janis Leslie Evans7 months ago
What makes a journalist different from a writer?Are journalists news reporters who write? Do writers focus more on the subjective than the objective? Are journalists more fact-based and writers about the art? Explain.
by pmorries2 months ago
Does a person start dying at the moment of birth? Or, does a person start dying at the moment of...conception? Or, do we start to die after we reach our physical peak, which is reached at about the age of 25? Some say...
by Russ Moran - The Write Stuff5 years ago
Do you have a niche or are you a generalist, and which is better in your view?
by Veronica Roberts5 years ago
At what age is your very first memory (from)?Your earliest memory... I've always found it fascinating to find out how far back people can remember. Do you remember being 3 years old? 7 years old? 11 years old?
by Kathleen Cochran3 years ago
Are you a first-born in your family?Where do you fit in your family's birth order: first, middle, baby? Do you think your birth order inclines you to be a writer? Don't know about famous writers' birth order...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.