The US and UK rank pretty much at the bottom of the pile for rich countries.
Sweden comes top for children's material well being.
Italy comes tops for family relationships (kids in Mediterranean countries always look like a different species to me. They look happy.).
Belgian comes top for educational well being.
The Netherlands come top in subjective well being just beating out Spain and Greece.
The US and UK fought it out for bottom spot in most parameters.
As someone addicted to travel none of this surprises me. When I see kids in England I feel sorry for them. When I was in the US ditto.
Mind you, kids of the kind these two countries produce make excellent soldiers when they come of age.
It's interesting to note that the further to the right the UK swings the higher percentage of children living in poverty rises.
Different thread, same answer.
Since the USA is a union of fifty sovereign states. Why not compare a state like Massachusetts to those of the world.
If that's the case, I vote we all declare a war of annihilation on Texas.
The other 49 states. We are sovereign, right?
The Republic of Texas was an independent sovereign nation in North America which existed from March 2, 1836, to February 19, 1846
Wouldn't it be easier to allow them to revert back to their Independent status, without the whole central government tyranny forcing them to stay?
#1 I doubt they would want to in the majority, polls certainly indicate they do not.
#2 It's utterly irrelevant to this forum post.
That was in response to a post to me.
My point is that there is a state in the U.S. that would probably lead the world in living standards, Massachusetts. Even some Americans do not realize that there are fifty separate states within the nation. What can be said of Arkansas does not hold true for Deleware.
The question is, what is Sweden doing differently from England and the US?
The rich countries are failing their children. That was the basis of that study. It is just another push for socialism.
That was the hypothesis, then it is tested against the data to confirm or disprove it, the data confirms that hypothesis.
By an incredibly respectable research and statistical organization I might add.
- and this should make you pretty happy, Josak!
No it makes me sad, the children of today are the adults of tomorrow and we are ruining our next generation through poverty and neglect, there is no greater disservice a nation can do to it's future.
The drop out rate in LA means that the kids are smarter than the school system. The kids are alright in America!
No it does not and quite obviously the results show they are not. Not only the results of this study but also our incarceration rates show we are failing our children as a country.
The school system needs to be changed. When our students drop out they exercise their freedom of speech. Its a GOOD THING!
When children drop out of school thus raising their chances of incarceration, lowering their average income, reducing their life expectancy, massively increasing their chance of ending up on government support etc. that is a good thing? That is horrible.
We need more freedom. Not less. We need school vouchers. The school system and the government is failing our kids. The insistence on the status quo must give way to
power to the community!
What we need is a revolution in education!
Dr. Maria Montessori had the answer.
If we read her books, we will have the answer.
Respect the inner life of the child.
Respect the child's interest and joy of life.
Respect the right of mankind to possess
The government must stay
OUT OF THE WAY.
The love of independence in/of human nature will always triumph, in spite of the Doubting Thomases who mistakenly feel, in their impulsive panicky mental state, that the government must become/be Daddy/Mommy.
(BTW let's get rid of O MAMA care!)
This really is a sad desperate attempt to change the topic entirely, the thread is about our failing education system compared to those of other nations not your small government ideals.
It really is all quite connected. Do try to keep up.
The US's "freedom" to leave children in comparably terrible conditions and poverty has produced the biggest prison population in the world and the worst child well being conditions in the first world. Congratulations! RAH RAH for small governemnt!
The US's "Freedom" has left poor children trapped and decidedly unfree in poverty and lacking the education or support necessary to get out leaving the US with the highest poverty rate in the first world and the lowest economic mobility in the first world. Awesome!
In comparison those evil socialist nations have tiny crime rates, tiny recidivism rates and much better child well being.
YAY for small government! Continue to enlighten us on how much better it is
What a joke.
I won't bother. Some people have so little faith in the strength of human nature/spirit. I won't trouble anyone who does not agree with what I have already posted.
I believe that all Americans have the potential to be man/woman enough to live in independence and freedom. Otherwise God wouldn't have sent us the founding fathers! Thank you, George Washington. May you please stop rolling over in your grave and reincarnate already!
Personally I think there is a lot going on in these stats. It certainly isn't all about money spent on schools (although that matters) it is also about the way kids feel about themselves. Bullying won't go away with extra money, for example. It would ease with greater respect and empathy. And with fewer examples of violence and aggression.
But I reckon one factor is how much you load onto the children and how much the challenge of growing up is shared around. In the US and UK the price of failure at school is so high and kids are made very aware of that very early on.
In a country like Italy kids still have large stable communities and relatives of all kinds to fall back on in times of difficulty.
Very interesting data Will. I noticed that the UK is actually high for quality of school life (4th with Iceland, Norway and the Netherlands above us.) That suggests that in the UK at least, schooling is not the main issue.
I have just read an excellent book by Kristin Neff who has spend years researching the effects of focusing on self-esteem rather than self-compassion. She sees self-esteem as looking for differences between ourselves and others and striving to be above average or "better than." It stands to reason that 50% of the population cannot be above average for everything and so this focus is stressful from the outset. But it also leads to over-inflated opinions of one's own achievement which Neff (and many others) see as a major factor in the rise of narcissistic behaviour. At the same time, a sense of self-worth obtained from achievements is a very fragile and dependent on constantly defending those achievements. The result is alienation and fear.
Self-compassion (the name of Neff's book) allows us to make mistakes, and as importantly, it looks for common human experience. When we feel connected we are happier.
Neff's research totally backs up your views above regarding empathy and respect: "It certainly isn't all about money spent on schools (although that matters) it is also about the way kids feel about themselves. Bullying won't go away with extra money, for example. It would ease with greater respect and empathy."
Well, apart from needing to prove you are worth something, you will encounter a great deal of judgmentalism in the Anglo world about the most trivial things (from your sexuality to the ties that you wear, or don't wear).
I've been in Thailand for several years now and it is amazing how people just accept others for what they are. It is still shocking to me that people will reveal every facet of their personality on the first meeting if they happen to feel like it. Or they won't tell you anything. Either way, they expect no come back.
How wonderful that there is so much acceptance. There's much we Westerners have yet to learn in this respect!
by Julia Chang 10 years ago
It perplexes me that despite the advent of the Internet and the quickness with which information can travel nowadays, so many young people are still so woefully ignorant of the issues that affect our society. Mainly, the ignorance of politics and the workings of our government is what I'm concerned...
by Cassie Smith 7 years ago
How can an 18 year old girl not read and write after going through our public school system?Rachel Jeantel, a material witness for the prosecution in the George Zimmerman trial, can't read the material that she prepared. She even needed someone to help her write what she prepared. What...
by Peeples 7 years ago
Is school (for children) a waste of time and money?Thinking back to elementary, middle, and high school I can remember very little that I have actually needed to know outside of basic math and reading. So is there really a purpose to all those years of schooling. Is there a better way that could be...
by Matthew Dawson 8 years ago
Can our current public school system survive much longer with the federal budget cuts?In the last year there has been more scandalous stories of teachers, school administrators, and local school politicians violating the civil rights of our children and there family. I believe this is happening out...
by Christine Miranda 8 years ago
Do you agree with the teachers strike in Chicago?The Chicago Teachers Union is on strike for the first time in 25 years. It is the 3rd largest school system in the US. The school board agreed on a 16% increase in salary over the next four years. So what, may you ask, are they striking about?...
by Rose West 11 years ago
I've been writing an article about the government's involvement in education... It seems to me that our kids would be a lot better off if the government had never gotten involved. But what if the Department of Education was stopped? What would education look like if public schools were closed?...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|