Currently 9 men and women comprise the Supreme Court of the United States. It has not always been 9 members. This supreme court of the land includes men and women who are appointed by president and confirmed by the senate. My contention is these are ruling parties and therefore skew the court to there own liking. Judges are supposed to be impartial, but they are just people. Some judges are better at following the constitution and law than others.
As the court is about to rule on some high profile cases it is essential we remember Plessy v Ferguson in which SCOUS ruled states had an obligation to segregate schools, lunch counters (separate but equal) etc.
"My contention is these are ruling parties and therefore skew the court to there own liking."
This has been my complaint for years. Who would wish to go to court with a judge who leans anyway but the middle. The impartiality should remain impeccable and without cause for recourse. If you listen to the senate confirmation hearings when they are charged in confirming these judges you are taken to liberal heaven and conservative la la land with the questions and the answers they want to hear. I love the hypothetical questions especially as the inquisitors back the nominee into a corner to explain their feelings on a made up situation paraphrasing supposed related testimony to manipulate a stand. Each case is different and should stand on its own merit which requires a impartial determination. Unfortunately what we have now are conservative and liberal plants by both parties.
Its almost like a Tribal Council vote on Survivor where one alliance gangs up on the other. The real heartburn is when one burns their alliance.
I would not say that the court decision obligated the states in question to employ Jim Crow, it just allowed them to do so.
Your statement is totally incorrect. In Plessy v. Ferguson, the Supreme Court did not rule that states had an obligation to segregate schools, lunch counters, etc.. To the contrary, the court ruled in a 7-1 decision that Louisiana’s Separate Car Act (1890) did not violate either the 13th Amendment, which prohibited slavery, or the Fourteenth Amendment, which granted full and equal citizenship to Black Americans.
For more about the legal nuances debated by the court, I suggest...
http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/top … v-Ferguson
Meanwhile, I am looking forward to a vigorous debate about impartiality.
Quilligrapher, You are absolutely correct, and the resulting outcome was since, segregation when separate but equal, was totally within the constitution guidelines states therefore had the right to do so.
by Scott Belford 21 months ago
My thought is No, they should go ahead and filibuster Judge Gorsuch now and not wait. The fear of filibustering now is that the Rs might use the "Nuclear Option" - using a simple majority to change Senate rules to eliminate filibustering for Supreme Court nominees; just as Democrats...
by bill yon 8 years ago
Do you think SUPREME COURT JUDGES SHOULD BE ELECTED FOR LIFE?
by Akriti Mattu 3 years ago
Personally, i feel it's a huge leap forward. What are your views ?
by Beth Perry 5 years ago
Which TV judge would you pick to be on the US Supreme Court?Often it seems the judges on court TV shows possess a lot more common sense than the judges that grace the United States' Supreme Court. If you had the chance to pick the next Supreme Court judge from among the judges in court TV land,...
by niall.tubbs 8 years ago
I don't know anyone in America that doesn't support the freedom of religion. Why do you ask?
by Kathryn L Hill 3 months ago
Does he favor and lean toward the the Right, or does he truly follow the precepts of the Constitution of the United States.Some would say the Right ARE the upholders of the Constitution! (And the Left are the destroyers of the Constitution.)
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|