About three in ten murderers were later found not guilty and executed. shoud we stop executions over
The law says innocence is no bar to a finding of guilty in a capital case. 30% error seems acceptable. Other crimes which are pled before trial and forced through intimidation probably have a higher not guilty rate. Aren't a few errors ok to protect society?
In my opinion, NO. I do know it is tragic for innocent people to lose their lives, but were they really innocent? You are not going to receive the death penalty (in most cases) for a first offense. These scumbags spend YEARS on death row. With groups like the Innocence Project, and the ACLU working to get them off, if after all those years they are executed, TOO BAD. I know I sound really heartless, but if the death penalty were carried out more quickly, the taxpayers would save a fortune spent on the care of inmates. Knowing that if convicted and sentenced to death the penalty would be carried out within say 3 years, some people MAY reconsider BEFORE committing the crime.
I'm English so the notion of the death penalty is slightly disturbing in many ways as it's alien in my culture. If you have a death penalty in your society I suppose you must accept that there will be a margin of error and innocent people will die as a result of your system.
So, to follow the logical argument, and to say that's accepted, why wait so very, very long to kill your prisoners? If the system is accepted then executions should be immediately after the appeals process is complete I'd have thought.
The fact that prisoners are on death row for years suggests an underlying uncertainty in the use of the death penalty as a punishment, be that for cultural or political reasons.
The end result seems to me to be a pretty miserable torture whereby you're sentenced to several years of psychological abuse before being killed. Perhaps that's the point. Whether that's a sucessful deterrent I don't know.
I worked for 25 years in the Texas Department of Corrections and for the State and Federal Courts. I have worked with adult and juvenile offenders. I also support Project Innocence, more appeals for inmates, ACLU and mandatory DNA testing of evidence when necessary. Also do not fool yourself into thinking that you can not be sentenced to die for a first offense. Texas has the busiest death chamber in the United States, something I am not proud of. I am not against the death penalty, I do belive it should be applied fairly and only when there is no other way to protect society. Believe me when I tell you that doing life is a much harsher penalty than dying. Some of the abuse suffered by the inmates at the hands of the staff are the things of nightmares. So before we take that step to take another persons life, we need to be absolutely sure that there is no shred of innocence, even if this takes years. Those years are not spent in luxury, trust me I know from experience,
from my viewpoint, the chances of one person being wrongly executed makes the whole practice intolerable... and 30%??
no. one would certainly not believe that such errors were 'ok to protect society' if he or one of his loved ones were to be the one sacrificed.
I think that even if I was wrongly accused of a murder and put to death...I'd at least die knowing something was being done about crime rate and prison population.
Sorry, but it's not about God. It's about money. And if you seemed to have committed a crime, you're going to do the time--or get buried trying.
I support the death penalty, and the reason is this: apart from arguments concerning the value of human life, redemption, and whether or not the state has the right to take a life (all arguments that will get you nowhere with me in opposing the death penalty), most of the arguments against the death penalty boil down to the fact that you could get it wrong, which is actually an argument against the entirety of the justice system rather than merely one component of it. People just get squeamish because a prisoner can always be released from jail, but you can't raise the dead (or, at least, not in any form that I would like witness). Personally, I think the differences that people like to see between these two outcomes provide a false sense of comfort--the person that you threw into jail with a life sentence and who has served 25 years before being released is just as dead as the person who you executed. The person that you threw in jail is gone. They have no chance at a normal life--a family, a good career, ect.
by RealityTalk 5 years ago
Should Jodi Arias get the death penalty or life without parole?Jodi Arias has been found guilty of first degree murder and guilty of cruelty in the aggravation phase of her trial for the murder of her ex-boyfriend, Travis Alexander. The jurors who found her guilty of the first two phases of...
by Cut The Bullshit 5 years ago
Do you believe in the death sentence for murderers? And why?
by Beata Stasak 3 years ago
Do you believe that death-penalty should be abolished worldwide?There are convicted murderers and rapists who are guilty of horific crimes and unlikely to change their behaviour, however reading recently about unsuccessful death penalty procedure taking two hours before aborting the effort, we have...
by KK Trainor 7 years ago
Texas executed Humberto Leal yesterday evening. Leal murdered a 16 year old girl after raping and brutalizing her and bashing her head in with a huge chunk of asphalt. He was kind enough to leave a stick with a nail on the end of it sticking out of her vagina. As a Mexican national, Leal was living...
by Seckin Esen 4 years ago
Is the death penalty an effective deterrent to crime?
by Patricia Scott 3 years ago
Where are you on capital punishment?Karla Faye Tucker was put to death for a heinous murder Her story is told in a poignant, reflective film in which her life changes dramatically after imprisonment.And yet she was not spared. At her execution, the sheriff who was involved in the case said...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|