jump to last post 1-16 of 16 discussions (21 posts)

Is the death penalty an effective deterrent to crime?

  1. Seckin Esen profile image90
    Seckin Esenposted 4 years ago

    Is the death penalty an effective deterrent to crime?

  2. profile image0
    Natasha Petersposted 4 years ago

    What a great idea for a hub. I've seen studies and observational data that points both ways (so perhaps it depends on the culture), but I think an even more probing question is, "even if it is effective, is it morally justified?"

    Between considering the burden placed on jails (and therefore taxpayers) to keep morally corrupt people in jail for life, the hypocrisy of legally exacting systematic and premeditated killing (or "killing people to show people that killing people is wrong"), and how many innocent people have been (and thanks to the nature of human error, will be) executed, it's a very difficult question to answer.

  3. profile image0
    Copper Manposted 4 years ago

    The short answer: It prevents further crime by the person being executed, but not for the criminally inclined still at large in the community.

  4. RTalloni profile image89
    RTalloniposted 4 years ago

    Not trying to divert from the actual question, but there is the matter of justice for victims.  The issue of whether the death penalty is a deterrent is only part of a complex and bigger question.  It's important to consider the answers to this question, but only useful if all the issues surrounding the problems of dealing with crime are addressed.

    1. wmhoward4 profile image69
      wmhoward4posted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Very good point. Can anyone tell me why that animal who grabbed a 10 year old girl, shot her brains out and dumped her, should have three hot meals, free health care, TV and a room for the next 40 years? Tell me why he should ever get out on parole ?

  5. profile image51
    roseunlimitedposted 4 years ago

    The death penalty as an effective deterrent to crime is only "as" effective the person in whom it pertains to. In other words people in the states where the death penalty is law, they may consider the death penalty as a way out, means to an end or may feel it they will not be caught. As you and I, the death penalty is and will be a deterrent to crime.


  6. Mahfoudh Muhammed profile image61
    Mahfoudh Muhammedposted 4 years ago

    Here are some of the crimes of which death penalty is the perfect solution.

    Murder - If someone intentionally kills your mother, brother or anyone who is close to your heart in any means, ask yourself, what do you think they deserve? I don't know about you but I find death the right answer.

    Rape - Apply the same process and you'll get the same results. Actually, if someone ever rapes my sister I would wish to torture them to death but that's how it works. They will deserve death but in the most merciful possible way, so will I for letting it happen, morally not literally.

    Betrayal - Corroborating with the enemy for personal benefits leading to the deaths of hundreds of people is definitely a death deserving act. Not all betrayals require death penalties, however. Every case should be studied deeply and given the right judgement.

    1. raymondphilippe profile image82
      raymondphilippeposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Death penalty is not a perfect solution imo.

  7. Thief12 profile image91
    Thief12posted 4 years ago

    Death penalty is legal in many countries, including most of US states, and yet, crime still occurs. So I suppose the answer is no.

  8. raymondphilippe profile image82
    raymondphilippeposted 4 years ago

    No. Not an effective deterrent. There is no proof for this.

  9. profile image0
    sheilamyersposted 4 years ago

    I don't think it is. If someone thinks they have a reason to kill another human being, they're going to do it whether or not it means they themselves may end up being executed. As for other crimes people mention that does have or should have the death penalty (rape, betraying your country, etc), I still don't see it as a deterrent. It may make them more cautious and they'll try to cover their tracks because they at least think they can get away with it.

  10. THarman7 profile image59
    THarman7posted 4 years ago

    I feel that criminals have something haywire in their brains. They think differently then the average person so no I think they would still do the things they do. The death penalty would not stop them but it would help to keep costs down in the prison systems if they just disposed of the ones that have life sentence's, and have committed hanis crimes why keep them sitting in prison, and the tax payers are paying for them.

    1. raymondphilippe profile image82
      raymondphilippeposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      And what if, for whatever reason, somebody was wrongly convicted? Happens all to often.

  11. CWanamaker profile image97
    CWanamakerposted 4 years ago

    No not really.  Some people are just hardwired for crime and others have dug problems making rational thinking impossible.  Also, many criminals believe that they are either above the law or won't get caught.

    1. wmhoward4 profile image69
      wmhoward4posted 4 years agoin reply to this

      If they are hard wired for crime, maybe the community is better off if killers get what rabid animals also get.

  12. wmhoward4 profile image69
    wmhoward4posted 4 years ago

    This is why people need the right to defend themselves. In countries where the government disarmed the public, criminals are pretty much getting their way.

    1. raymondphilippe profile image82
      raymondphilippeposted 4 years agoin reply to this


  13. Hackslap profile image86
    Hackslapposted 4 years ago

    I think it is .. ever heard of someone even remotely trying to smuggle drugs in countries like Saudi Arabia or Singapore?

  14. Alphadogg16 profile image92
    Alphadogg16posted 4 years ago

    I absolutely think so, I think we should adopt some of the punishments from other countries. If you rape some one, castrate them, an eye for an eye. It says alot when almost a third of your population is incarcerated.

  15. Angela Kane profile image78
    Angela Kaneposted 4 years ago

    I believe the death penalty is a deterrent to crime and all hardcore murderers should get the death penalty. Even if it wasn't a deterrent to crime, I would be for it because I believe if you take a life intentionally that is not self defense, you should suffer the same fate.

  16. lisavanvorst profile image76
    lisavanvorstposted 4 years ago

    If someone takes a life than I believe their life should be taken. However there have been cases of innocent people sent to jail. Many of these cases occurred before DNA testing. Not all states have the death penalty. In those circumstances I feel those who commit murder should get life in prison.