Can democracy work without the 10 commandments?
If it has, please give examples.
It worked for the Greeks, they invented it, they never had the ten commandments as a tenet.
Look at Greece today. How long did democracy last? 200 years?
Tirelesstraveler, that is irelevant to the question which didn't queery the length of time a country had a democratic principle.
Was it Winston Churchill who said "Those who refuse to look at history are destine to repeat it"? Either democracy can stand the test of time or not. If 200 years is the full run, why bother.
It seems to me democracy and the 10 commandments have very little to do with one another. The only ones that have anything in common with the laws in the US are; 6- You shall not murder, and 8- You shall not steal. And I don't think you have to be a Christian or believe in the ten commandments to know those things are wrong.
I believe the 10 commandments were given to Abraham who became the father of the Jews first. Ishmael was his son too and he became the father of Islam.
OK, I'm not dissing the commandments, but I still don't get what the connection is between the ten commandments and democracy? Our government is supposed to be separate from any religion.
Sherry, it seems to me like you do not understand the separation clause. It is not intended to put up a wall between religious men and government but rather to keep government from forcing any one religion on the people.
Where profanity rules are enforced in schools there is no bullying. How many swear words include God in some way?
The ten commandments were given to Moses, not Abraham. There are big differences in the covenants of Abraham and the one of Moses.
contrary to common belief, the church/state separation was to make sure that religions did not interfere/influence politics - the main reason people fled to America in the first place.
d.williams, It was to make sure that the government did not dictate how people could or could not worship...it was NOT to keep faith out of the public domain...read the Founders.
History has a way of being twisted to accommodate the beliefs of the individual. According to some experts our history is rewritten quite frequently to reflect the ideas of the current political neophytes.
Sue you are so correct. Moses not Abraham. Brain Freeze.
Places like Japan and South Korea with strong democracies have basically no Christians and thus no ten commandments.
Any democracy shall ignore the ten commandments since it refers to religion therefore Christianity. I don't see why a "democracy" tainted with Islam is a theocracy whereas one imbibed with Christianity is a Democracy. Democracies are laical.
Actually Sherry is right. Democracy and the 10 commandments have nothing to do with each other. The 10 commandments were basic rules to live by set up by religion, based on common sense and decency. Democracy is a way of life where government is run for the people, by the people, without any religious considerations necessary.
The 10 commandments are not a necessity for a democracy or a government. Also, Christianity, per se, has nothing to do with democracy. When christianity was founded (by the Roman Government) there was certainly no democracy there.
d. totally agree that the commandments are basic rules of common sense and decency. Could a case be made that the commandments came before decency? Can you have democracy without decency?
No decency came long before the commandments, democracy grew completely separate to the commandments in Classical Greece thousands of years ago.
Democracies amount to mob rule. Democracies do not work very long. When the majority finds out that it can force its will on the minority, things fall apart. The ten commandments would be a good counter weight to mob rule. I would not want to live under mob rule, and am thankful that the United States was historically NOT a democracy. If you think it is, you many need a better political education.
Democracy is the best available today. the alternatives in the U.S. are theocracy or the current plutocracy, both of which do not serve the people. True Democracy can only work with the use of fundamental human/equal rights w/o religious influences
Democracy is not the best available. There is 'federated republic', which we began as. There is also 'confederations' and other models of government. Democracy occurs when things degrade to the point of mob rules, and is barely above street thuggery.
Your response amused me. These are the descriptions of persons who think with their passions and not their intellects.
I certainly hope Democracy isn't the best we can get d.william. Democracy when you follow it throughout history always evolves into a dictatorship and ultimately ruin.
d. Williams, a true democracy (which we are not) could only work for the benefit of it's people if all, or atleast a super majority, believed in a set of laws that transcend the whims of the individual...mob rules without that, fails...
I disagree. Democracy is not the best. A representative republic is very much preferred over a democracy since it preserves minority views, while democracy often tramples them and everything else in the name of 'THE PEOPLE'.
We do not live in a democracy. We are a republican form of government. This is not a R, but and r. A democracy is a simple majority rules, but we utilize representatives and a 3 branch of government system, which is not a democracy. You could call it a democratic republic, but not a simple democracy.
The Founders primarily believed that it was not possible to have a nation of, by and for the PEOPLE if those people did not have Biblical underpinning.
Love it when people understand the US is a Republic. While reading my son's history book I discovered they don't teach that anymore.
Tireless, And if you point that out, then you get labeled at nut...
No, a society where the basic commandments are not absolute, chaos or lawlessness will creep in.
by Rad Man 4 years ago
Are the 10 commandment applicable today? Are they applicable to non-Jews? Are they applicable to women? I ask because the bible says Jesus said one needs to follow them to get into heaven, but when I read them a few things stand out that makes me think they are not applicable to non-Jews or...
by Greensleeves Hubs 5 years ago
I ask this question because I feel a sense of dilemma. I hate extremism in general and religious extremism in particular. I am not sure exactly what the policies of the Muslim Brotherhood government are, but the idea of any government associated so directly with religion worries me greatly -...
by Minister Mitch 3 years ago
Do you think the Ten (10) commandments are really no longer useful?What will happen if the 10 commandments are no longer taught in the homes of Americans?.
by Michael Willis 8 years ago
A friend just sent me this message and I wanted to share. Maybe some of you have already seen this."Cows, Constitution & 10 CommandmentsThink about this: 1. Cows 2. The Constitution 3. The Ten...
by spiritactor 8 years ago
I believe that, ultimately, Democracy is a gift we continually give OURSELVES. But, as a society, a nation, are we ACCEPTING and USING it?
by Roxanne Marian Elizabeth G Haggard 3 years ago
Do you agree if we obeyed the 10 commandments justice would prevail?The law is not just, but maybe if we actually followed Gods law we wouldn't be so lost.
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|