the sumnation of healthcare forced on the people... I believe that is the message...
I consider it a piece of propaganda put out by people who do not understand or agree with the AHCA. It's meant to frighten people, and it will...and I personally think that is wrong. People are frightened enough about the economy, they don't need ads like this forced on them.
How is it wrong? The program is manditory and if you don't purchase the product you must pay a fine that is being caled a tax...explain how the picture doesn't represent that fact clearly.
Then people should research and learn for themselves and not be limited to visual ads when forming their opinions. You can only be a sucker if you allow yourself to be a sucker...
Pretty lame. That $2.35 gets pooled so that, what? Everybody gets to chew gum? Apples and oranges. Gum is a luxury. Healthcare is not. You won't die or become sick or permanently disabled because you couldn't afford gum. Methinks the "author" should stick to puns, knock-knocks, and...no...limericks might be beyond his/her talent.
It isn't discussing the amount of the payment, but rather the fact that citizens will HAVE to pay a fine (tax) for not purchasing a specific product. If you or I do not purchase insurance, whether we want to or not, we will be fined.
As wracked as I am wrt the means (requiring all who can, to help fund, proportional to their material wealth, a well-managed, open-record healthcare pool, federally acquired and overseen) - the ends, a healthy citizenry, is well worth it - and right.
I'm used to paying tax on things I purchase, so this seems very strange. What?! Pay tax on something I did not get?
For the first time U.S. citizens will be taxed for an inactivity...for NOT doing something...sounds like a fine to me.
I wonder if the Governement thinks that we as people are incapable of taking care of our own health/business. Are they going to start fining us for buying soda and not water? hmmm....
I liked the picture. It sums up in simple graphic terms what the whole individual mandate amounts to. Being forced to purchase something against your will, if you want it or not.
Here's the problem with ads like this, which compare health insurance to other products:
If you don't have health insurance and you get taken to the emergency room or hospitalized, you still will receive treatment. By law, hospitals cannot refuse to treat someone in an emergency situation, whether that person can pay for the $50,000 surgery or not.
If the person cannot pay, no matter what, eventually the hospital has to push the cost of the treatment onto everyone who can pay.
To go back to your gum analogy: it would be like someone coming into the store, and the merchant being forced to give him a stick of gum before determining if the customer can pay for the gum. When the customer cannot pay for the gum, the merchant is simply forced to eat the loss. To make up for it, he must charge more per stick of gum. However, making the gum more expensive results in more people not being able to afford the gum, making the merchant lose even more every time someone can't pay for the gum. Finally, the merchant goes to the government and asks them to pass a law to make everyone carry a gum-buying plan.
The moral of the story? Gum is not health care, so don't try to compare them.
The comparison isn't being made between the products themselves...it is about the fact that U.S. citizens are being fined (they call it a tax) for NOT purchasing something.
So long as we force hospitals to treat people regradless of their ability to pay, every American already has 'bought' health care. Those without insurance simply can't pay for it. Essentially, they're shoplifting health care.
by Peeples5 years ago
Curious as to what people who are against everyone having healthcare think should be done for those who really can't afford healthcare. What are the other options? Continue down the same road we are on now?
by David Stillwell5 years ago
Do we have the Right... To healthcare, To drive, to have children, To electricity, etc.I am exploring the concept of how People assume the right of something... It is my right to... yet the constitution...
by Grace Marguerite Williams8 months ago
Do you believe that the nuisance known as Obamacare will finally be repealed? Why? Why not?I believe that the government SHOULD NOT be in private affairs such as health care. I believe that health care is...
by ElSeductor5 years ago
Why are some people so eager to take away healthcare for people with pre-existing conditions?
by Susan Reid5 years ago
This is an unscientific poll.I am curious to know the answers to four very simple questions:1. Do you have health insurance now?2. Who pays the premium (main monthly cost) of your health insurance?e.g., employer,...
by JaxsonRaine5 years ago
John and Carl are identical twins. John exercises, eats well, doesn't smoke, and gets plenty of fresh air. Carl smokes, eats McDonalds, sits around all day on the couch watching his Soaps.Is there any reason why anybody...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.