Is there any way to stop manipulation of social welfare programs?
Is there really any way to stop people from using the system?
Questions of ethics are always challenging to answer. I do not know how to answer it especially in the socio-political context.
Firstly you need to define "manipulation"
Then you have to define "using the system"
I assume that your question is why should hardworking people have to pay for others whom you perceive to be ms-using the system
If people did not need it, it would naturally disappear..But in every society, there will always be those that will need the help of others, be it a friend, a neighbor, a government, so even when it is abolished by the government, it will still exist, under a different name.
Just my opinion.
I meant those who are actually manipulating such as those working "under the table" while still claiming they are jobless and need help.
Oh..I did not know they exist..my apologies..
In this case they need or desire more than what they are getting and to lie or not to lie is their choice.
Would it be to much to handle if you were open to the realization the system is designed from manipulation. What about people who abuse their positions of power, why are they never called out, Oh yeah!!! They have a respectable label in life.
Those people are called out ever day Matthew. It's all over the internet and news, The Occupy movement tried to call those out, yet still nothing done about thousands using the system.
A liveable wage is a wage that offers health care. What about the doctor that charges double for medicaid?, housing that costs double for P.A?, can you pay all your bills, all of them on 7.25 an hour?, if you can you are a miracle worker.
We have supported a family of 4 on 7.25 an hour. It's called living within one's means. There's no doubt problems within government but there will be as long as people want to rely on them instead of themselves!
I work for the system and while I will say there are parts that are certainly broken, I've seen and helped a number of people that needed it. Actually they needed more help and couldn't get it. I think we (as society) could do a lot more to help out.
Heaven knows I've needed help from time to time, but legislated "compassion" isn't the way to do it.
I think the programs need reworking, but they are needed. Depending on the compassion of the general populace never worked before here or on most other parts of the planet.
I have done a lot of research on welfare systems- and other social programs- and I completely agree with you! People who cheat the system make popular media but skew public perceptions. Most are not cheating the system- the system is cheating them.
You may be right Becky but in my line of work I have met literally hundreds cheating the system. I'm sure it's no different in other areas.
People would not need it be it they were paid a liveable wage. way i see it we should not need a system in the first place if workers were paid respectable wages, Oh!!! that would mean advancements toward equal classes, they won't let that happen.
What's your opinion of a livable wage Matthew? Here 7.25 is a livable wage. Cost of living is super low, yet people still cheat the system. There will always be those who want more no matter the wage.
Good question but unfortunately I think not. As long as the offices don't HIRE enough people to screen and perform due diligence at the initial filings and on a random basis, there will continue to be people that manipulate these programs.
People that don't actually NEED the aid should not be able to get their hands on it. Those who have received everything that they could should not be able to come back for more, especially when the rules were clearly laid out or they've had plenty of time to adjust to the end of the aid.
The problem is that there are many people that need social welfare, many more than what some out-of-touch politicians believe. Some who are in need don't get it.
Make employment pay people a liveable wage. What about Doctors? they depend on Medicaid just as much as the recipient, what about farmers bail outs? what about McDonald's last I remember they are subsidized, any store that receives food-stamps/ E.B.T.... They are all on Welfare, they just have prettier titles. If you want people to stop using the system it is easily resolved....PAY PEOPLE A LIVEABLE WAGE!!!!! where they can afford health care, pay there bills, buy their gas, put clothes on their body's, food in their mouths....Oh!!! Ive seen first hand what "Social workers" do for a living, I would never refer to them as workers, they don't work!!!! That is not work!!!! You Social people who think that your not on welfare, ha ha, you are!!! you just you get a name tag and a fancy label.
Not every one is uneducated retards to this economic crisis, I've seen our public buildings waste a lot of money just because they had a time limit to spend it, then turn a hungry, homeless man down for food stamps, because he had no address.
Legislated "compassion" is no compassion at all.
Vote Ron Paul for president in 2012. Despite what the Corporate Party media kool-aid says, he's the only choice to restore the Constitution and fiscal sanity. Eliminating IRS would stimulate economy!
Pharmacy's are the the biggest welfare recipient out there. They are a drain on Medicaid. Half way house bilk medicaid and cash assistance that the recipient receives. Programs such as C.H.A.D, are huge drains on Medicaid.
Yes. The simplest way to stop people using (or abusing) social welfare programs is to eliminate them altogether.
Compassion should not come from legislation. It opens up too many chances for abuse, not only from people using the programs, but from the legislators and bureaucrats who manage them.
Too much Nanny (Communistic) State gives people Learned Helplessness. It's making America weaker and more dependent.
Social welfare programs are unconstitutional. Big corporations love them, but they don't care for the "customers" or "citizens." Just like Big Pharma is dead set against cures -- bad for the bottom line.
How about a Veteran with no legs. Does he deserve disability?
I would like some light shined on corporate welfare scams/fraud. They are taking on a much larger scale than the few hundred a month, and food stamps/Medicaid, the recipient receives.
From what I have seen those who really need it get turned down. Those who do get it just keep having babies for the check they will get for each child. I think these women should be provided with birth control and cut off after 2 babies. Check for 2 kids, "NO MORE!" I knew of a guy who was in a wheel chair and didn't have any legs (Veteran) It took him 2 years to get his disability. A Travesty!!!!
What you say is so true. I know a baby machine that has had her children repeatedly tested in hopes of getting a check for a disability that doesn't exist. There are vets (homeless & not) that give up hope on their benefits because of the red tap
I was not going to make a hub on this topic, but here go's. We live in a country that was stolen and constructed from boards of deceit, theft, murder, lye's, treachery, pain, misery, human suffering, stolen labor, slavery, savagery, rape, and Inter... read more
This is a question that I honestly believe has several different answers. I personally know more people that abuse the aid than people who use it for what its for. My ideal social welfare program would be like a rehabilitation program. You are assigned a case worker (NOT an overloaded case worker) who is assigned to you for x amount of time. The social worker and person work as a team, like a counselor/teacher and student towards a goal together. If the person(s) stops cooperating and gives up during that time then they no longer receive help. People need to be held responsible for their actions and choices they have made in their life. Unexpected pregnancies happen, job loss happens, emergencies happen. The journey to get back on track always takes longer than the incident that caused someone to need the help. However, as long as the Government keeps holding these peoples hands and giving them what they need to live they are never going to stop abusing that free help. Unfortunately our country has alot of lazy people who think they are owed something by the Government for one reason or another. I really do believe there is more than one right solution to this ongoing problem. Hopefully someone will be able to implement a successful solution.
What about corporate welfare. They should be held accountable for their misfortunes, they did not have the misfortune of an unexpected pregnancy, yet the government grants them, so how long is the government suppose to hold them down.
I completely agree Matthew. There should be no gov't aid for a select few companies when many others have suffered losses.
by theirishobserver. 7 years ago
Social Welfare Inspectors have identified over 50 social welfare recipients who are being paid by Sinn Fein to put up posters and campaign for Sinn Fein Presidential candidate Martin McGuinness. Social Welfare Inspectors in Monaghan, Meath, Donegal, Louth and Dublin have reported their findings...
by rhamson 9 years ago
The two types of governing and commerce are continually discussed and argued on this forum. Capitalism is usually associated with the right and socialism is associated with the left. What are the differences and can they be combined to form a new form of governing?
by Jack Lee 23 months ago
What do you think of a new social welfare experiment in Finland?They are giving random people $587 per month in a socal experiment to encourage people to work.The idea is they don't want people on welfare to be penalized by working. Is this a solution to the welfare state or is this a solution that...
by Grace Marguerite Williams 5 years ago
No humane person is against the government giving needed assistance to the indigent elderly, the severely mentally and physically disabled, and to those who otherwise cannot work. However, there are plenty of able bodied people who refuse to work thus further draining the economy and...
by Foodeee 4 years ago
Do you think General Welfare Programs will ruin our nation?Mainly, Giving welfare checks to individuals with no income. OR Free housing to those who are homeless.
by Keishia Lee Louis 3 years ago
Why are social programs (i.e. welfare, universal health & college) so controversial in the USA?Do you think it has anything to do with our diverse ethnic, cultural and religious ideas? Or is it something else?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|