Before I get into what I really want to say, let me clarify this. I have no sympathy for those that molest little children. I have three myself and I want to protect them from the sick minds out there. That being said...
I personally know a man who was 18 and slept with a 16 year old. He was beyond foolish. No question about that. Most 18 year olds do not have many brain cells functioning properly. She became pregnant. He was charged with sexual assualt through the act was voluntary on both sides. He was legally an adult.
Fast forward many years later. He is still on the list. He is trying to get his life straight. Companies won't hire him because of this felony. If he doesn't get a job to pay child support, he goes to jail. He has to find a place to live outside the halfway house or go back to jail. His PO will not approve any of them because every place in this very very small town is near a park, library, museum, school, bus stop, or has a child living somewhere nearby.
Where is the justice is treating a foolish teenager who a few months earlier would have receiving nothing from the legal system the exact same way as on who hurts a ten year old? Should there be levels of sexual offenders so that all cases can be handled properly?
I guess your list is in the US - it is the same in the UK, there seems to be a vindictive and vicious campaign to get anybody onto the sexual offenders list for the smallest offence - that has nothing to do with serious sexual offences that the list was made for.
I note a young guy touched a policewomans butt, got a fine or jail - I don't remember - but he was then put on the sexual offenders list. This is feminist Mcarthyism and witch-hunting at its finest.
The pity of it all is that Judges and especially Magistrates seem to use this just because they can, and it completely negates the point of the list which is to protect our children from paedophiles and women from rapists.
It may not seem fair, but you know, some time or another, our society should learn to open their eyes to things that have happened in the past and adjust themselves so that it does not happen again in the future. I have heard of several instances that this has happened to people, but you know, if they have not learned from the mistakes of others then I am sorry this country is going to fall apart. Most of the average American citizens are so busy living their live that they do not pay attention to what is going on in the world around them, so the government can take advantage of us even more because society is so busy and living with blinders on that the government can get away with practically anything, and that includes making the lives of our young that have made mistakes suffer the rest of their lives for them.
No he does not deserve to be on the list. Teenagers make mistakes, I think he has been punished enough.
They should not put these young teenagers on the sex offenders list unless it was a case without consent like rape etc.
They were practically the same age, young, silly, an age when you learn from your mistakes. Don't we all make mistakes.
Absolutely. All kinds of injustices occur under our current systems for dealing with sex "offenses," especially those involving consensual sex between young people.
Yes absolutely there should be levels. In the UK, a girl under 16 is considered a juvenile. So, say she is 15 and he is 16, he could end up on the Sex Offenders Register, but to my mind they were the same age and if they choose to have consensual sex that is their business, even though she is underage.
That is quite different to a man of, say, 32, having sex with her when she is only 15.
But the Law treats them the same, and I think that's wrong.
In my mind an 18 year old is the same age as a 16 year old. Why should they be punished for a stupid act that would be ok legally a few months earlier?
When I was 16, 18 years olds were too immature for me, I was looking at 20 year olds!
Yeah...to be honest for a sixteen year old girl, any guy under 25 is fair game.
But in the quote I made above, it shows the stupidity of the Law. Two kids, almost the same age, but one gets labelled for life? How unfair is that?
The Sex Offenders Act, or its US equivalent, should be for offenders, not young lovers.
Then again....where do they put a cut-off age? Girls are sexually maturing earlier...13?...12?
I think, in all honesty, if we have to have a minium age, and we do and for good reasons, then we have to look at the age of the partner.
There could be a sliding scale...the nearer in age he is to her, the less likelihood of his being placed on the sex offenders register.
Or is that too complicated for the bureaucrats?
It probably is too complicated for them.
A sliding scale would be good. And taking into consideration how long they were dating.
I had an acquaintance who was arrested for indecent exposure on her 18th birthday. She always said the best gift she could have gotten was a pair of handcuffs and a note reminding her that she was now an adult and would be held responsible for any and all bad behavior.
So, you think if say 30yo would have sex with 13yo - without any violence, mutual consent, using condoms, both having fun - he deserves the treatment you just described, right?
That is too big of an age difference for consent. I'm talking about when the ages are so very very close. 30 and 13 is sick.
Oh good God...
Not another person advocating people having sex with kids.
PLEASE go away.
Did you read what I wrote. An older man with a child is wrong. An 18 year old still in high school dating a 16 year old for the last 2 years now goes to jail for their activities?
Typically you purposely misread a post. The question is whether the two things warrant the same treatment= the poster was clearly not advocating the disgusting behaviour that is so clearly at the front of your mind.
I'm sure you read the same thread post as I did, and I'm astounded that you would make a response like this.
I'm not sure. I'm talking to the fool on this forum comparing a 30 year old child molester to a 16 year old child that has sex with another 14 year old child. Are you that ridiculous FOOL?
Yeah, you live up to your handle. I'll leave it at that
I see the difference. Ignore those that are that obtuse and ridiculous that they have others wondering if they're deliberately trolling or if they really are that stupid.
I agree with IzzyM.
Each case should be considered on its own merits or lack thereof.
Why older man and younger girl is wrong?
Not with a young child. My 14 year old is way too young for a man in his thirties.
I see how you feel, you did not answer why you feel that way though.
Because a 14 year old can easily be swayed by a much older and sophisticated looking man.
My post is more for those that are not really older yet fall within the legal limits.
Probably yes, but is it really related to sex? If he is just a friend? Just a teacher?
And for your post - I am trying to understand where do you put the boundaries, when it is OK and when it is not - cause you have to have them if you propose a different approach for different ages...
My husband has a co-worker who is on the list. They guy was arrested for peeing in his own fenced in backyard! It makes me very distrustful of the lists.
by Dear_hubs6 years ago
It has been a gray area for a long time that in the UK, sex below the age of 16 is illegal and many frown on it. I'll be honest, I lost my virginity at 15, however I am not a criminal, I have lead a community driven...
by Grace Marguerite Williams4 years ago
Michaela Shunick, a Lousiana college student, was missing since May 19th, 2012. She visited a friend's house and disappeared on her way home. A police investigation revealed that Ms. Shunick has...
by kimberlyslyrics6 years ago
Is it enough punishment to help safeguard our children? Not to mention our adults?As often as rape occurs, sex offenders still do less time in prison than drug traffickers.Given we know sex offenders attack...
by steve-bc-ca2 years ago
I met my share of rapist and child sex offenders in jail. Even though many of them committed these crimes before I was born and they now seem very remorseful, it is almost impossible to look at them any other way. I...
by Shawn May Scott5 years ago
We have all heard of attachment parenting and co-sleeping etc. But is it too much to be breast feeding your almost 4 year old son??? In my former profession as an RECE I have met many women who have done this and I have...
by theirishobserver.7 years ago
In 37 Days Larry Murphy will be released from Prison, this article is not written in order to single out Larry Murphy, but rather to highlight the failings in the Criminal Justice System, failings put in place by weak...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.