First impression (from the "mission statement) is that B4uact is trying to re-label pedophilia not only by calling it a mental illness, but by tacking on a liberal label of "minor-attracted", thereby leaving out individual responsibility for wrong behavior.
Some of the group's commentary in their agenda is very disturbing. They're apparently trying to help people, which is a good thing!, but they're leaving out morality and even allowing the pedophiles to categorize themselves as victims! The write-up said experts in several fields were at the conference, including "ethics"......I'm wondering how much imput involved ethics at all. Especially since the admonishments against "judging" were forefront. And I wonder how many victims or their families were allowed any input.
Conservatives have been warning people this would happen. Make immorality mainstream and give adult decisions to children, and it's only a skip away from a push to legalize criminal immorality.
So you are saying it's not a mental illness? I see nothing here that says they will still not be punished as they should be. Maybe by studying this they can prevent people from becoming paedophiles in the first place and acting on those feelings?
Maybe so! And that's a good thing. But there's the very real danger in the way they seem to be going about it. I didn't read all the speeches of course, so I can't really make a firm assessment. There was mention of a scenario where a 15-year-old might need help with his sexual attraction to younger kids. In cases like that, yes, it would be great if he could be taught to make good choices. But why couldn't they just teach him right from wrong instead of labeling him with a disorder? Everyone faces temptations. Temptations are normal. Refraining from acting upon those temptations is, believe or not, normal. We all have a conscience. I think that group is simply trying to "help" via a roundabout way instead of taking a direct approach, and they're gonna confuse the person even more.
Why pussyfoot around these sexual predators? Afraid of labeling them what they are? I don't think they need to be studied, but rather pulled out into the middle of town and hung for their crimes against children. Do that a few times and we'll see how quickly the" mental illness" is cured.
Everyone is so quick to look for some underlying reason why some people are just scumbags that no one is afraid of getting caught breaking the laws because there is always the scapegoat of "there must've something wrong with them". This country is going soft......and no one has any fear of consequences.
I agree with that in part. I don't agree with a generalized judgement of having the offender hanged! Because sometimes, as mentioned, the situation is between two young people close in age; so there shouldn't be such a generalized label put upon all people.
But there are reasons for everything, but not excuses for everything! And most things that people do are their choices.
People are going to read into this whatever they want obviously.
Mental illness is not an excuse for anything. The APA does not make decisions based on pushing a political agenda like some.
But, it's easier to call for someone's head or death rather than find ways to avoid it from happening in the future.
Age does play a factor, you are right Brenda. I think if the victim and the offender are close in age- usually when the offender is labeled as Level 1, like maybe he/she are 21 and they have a relationship with someone 17. However some filthy 57 year old man being attracted and then violating a 3 year old deserves nothing but a death sentence. And I believe doing so publicly would deter others from acting out their sick fantasies.
by Alternative Prime 10 months ago
WHY Are Some Repulsive "CHRISTIANs" In Alabama FORESAKING Their Bibles / GOD To Support Roy Moore?Just like OUR Chronically DECAYING White House, did HELL "Pitch a Tent" in Alabama when nobody was looking?? This southern region was always a STRANGE, Creepy place where...
by Peeples 2 years ago
Is always being worried someone will break into your home a mental illness?My husband works a lot and I always worry about someone breaking in. I leave a light on when he isn't here. IS that some sort of mental illness?
by Leland Johnson 8 months ago
The federal government could declare a state of emergency and post at least 2 well trained, armed personnel, either police or military, within our public schools. Gunmen attack soft targets. They like to assault "gun free zones." I believe 20 years of wrangling over...
by Theresa Collins 20 months ago
Why do some families of the mentally ill turn their backs on them?I have seen many people who are truly, seriously, mentally ill with diagnosis such as Schizophrenia have no one, absolutely no one. Their families have disownded them. Although it is extremely difficult to deal with someone with that...
by Michelle Zunter 2 years ago
More gun violence very close to where I live yesterday. Most weapons, including guns, are available to anyone in this country at any given time. But what about the people who are using the guns? Are they mentally ill? are they psychopaths? Are they terrorists? Are they all of the above? In any...
by Karli Duran 8 years ago
I'm 32, and I have suffered with mental illness all my life. Sometimes with certain people I don't mind talking about my certain disorders, but other times, I feel ashamed and embarrassed. I guess it depends on the people you are talking to and the mental illness you are disclosing to...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|