I was baptized Catholic so by the time I was old enough to ask questions for myself good and evil had been pretty well defined. The problem I had with their assessments was that everything revolved around them and I don't believe that either good or evil revolves around or is solely the property of any one group or religion. But in answer to the question, for my very young mind it was the Church.
It's odd that you should mention the Catholic church has determined what is good and evil when you take into account the Catholic church was responsible for murdering 50 million people during the dark ages. Did they tell you what they did was evil.
I was about 5 when I started asking questions. I wasn't a big reader of history at 5. In fact, I couldn't read at all at 5. Want to complain about the Catholic Church? Find someone who's still participating or someone who cares...
It doesn't take a Catholic to care about 50 milion people.
Really referencing the dark ages? Are Germans today bad because of Hitler. Are Vietnamese still bad because.... Are Italians bad because of Caesars or Mousaline? Are Scandinavians bad....? Is my son evil because of genocide of Native Americans?
Well Eric, today's catholic church clergies don't murder people. Today the clergies molest small children and then use the church system to hid their crimes. That's evil.
Well you have a point -- but it fails because those are individuals not "the church. But you have a better argument with the way the church handled it. They came about slow but they never condoned it which would be a sanctioning of it.
"Never condoned it" are you kidding me. If the VICTEMS of the crimes had not come forward , the filthy catholic church clergies would still be covering it up.
KingdomCome you have to be a lapsed Catholic. No one hates the CC like a former member hates the CC. They may be responsible for many things but they're not responsible for every wrong or evil that has ever been. Maybe close though...
Cissy 1946- The catholic church is just as worthless as every other churches out there. JW, Mormons Baptist, SDA and many others. When a person studies and understands the word of God, he/she willnotice many false doctrine of man made made churches.
Evil spelled backwards is "Live"
Well following the humorous logic:
Good defines good and evil because good spelled backwards is doog.
And desserts spelled backward is "stressed." This revolutionizes the way people should think about that serving of warm apple pie with ice cream on top.
You're crazy Dr! lol
Love that sense of humor!
If you spell humor backwards it becomes aromuh - spells becomes smells.
In the Christian faith, good is what God is and our perception of good is from Him and written on our conscience. His commandments define what is evil.
Hence, the definition of good and evil are transcendent. To clarify, consider this thought experiment: is there someone somewhere in the world that is doing something wrong (evil) right now that you want them to stop regardless of what they think or feel?
This means that what defines what is good or bad has to come from something external to the person and is independent of their perceptions of it. If the definitions of good an evil are not transcendent, then they fail to have any real value.
Custom, pain and the absence of pain, power structures. Similar with the origins of taboo. It then gets crystallized into laws and in older times in myth and so called divine origins to try to add more meaning and force to the contract. So societies as they evolve through the ages are the origin, so it is never completely fixed. In the end when we have these more abstract concepts and restrictions we call the sum total civilization or being civilized.
There is a line of philosophical thought that makes the case that all words and indeed concepts come from context. If I recall correctly the favorite of these thoughts uses the word justice. But love, good, evil and of course right and wrong fit in just as well. Good and evil require a construct and context.
So the speaker in any given usage is who defines the meanings of good and evil. Not even a God or common usage.
Pie is good, means something totally different than God is good. Democrats are evil means something totally different than heroin is evil.
All words are different depending on their usage through the context. And each word has a different definition depending on use.
In line with the spelled backward concept is the dyslexic who praises dog, but takes his god for a walk.
I write a sermon usually weekly. I mean it to mean, and in the context it means a discourse on a moral issue. While out of context it means something like what preachers in church do.
The boy who sneaks a loaf of bread to feed his family who are starving is likely thinks of it as good. Same store different guy gangster robs it at gun point. If he gets away with it - he thinks it is good.
A Christian thinks that God is not only good but great. And an atheist thinks the imaginary thing, god is evil because he has caused such hardship and leads people like sheep. And basically that people who follow religion are evil because the follow something blindly.
Good and evil are defined by the person using them within the confines of context.
Spelling it backwards doesn't help
EVIL = LIVE
GOOD - DOOG
Live is meaningless without context, and DOOG is meaningless period.
Good and Evil are defined by society, and religion.
Good is whatever is not deemed Bad.
God spelled backwards is Dog??
That in English evil backwards is live is irrelevant to the meaning of evil.
Good and evil are defined by the religious system. In Judeo-Christian belief systems, all life is sacred and protecting it no matter the religious affiliation is important. In Islam, spreading Islam is the highest good, hence killing a few people horrifically and advertising the atrocity to scare others into converting to Islam is moral, because the conversions to Islam are worth more than the life of the unbelievers.
by graceinus 14 months ago
Should churches be allowed to invest the money from donations to be used for investments?Did you know that a lot of money given in the form of "tithing" or "donation" to churches are then used by the churches to invest in stocks, bonds, mutual funds and other investments solely...
by mtsi1098 8 years ago
by Roberto Lima Netto 5 years ago
KW: Jesus, Christianity, Catholic Church, Christ, Buda, Matthew, Mark, Luke, Gospel of John, Gospel of Thomas, Nicene Council, Description: The article discusses the controversy about Jesus being God or an illuminated Rabbi, a hot issue in the initial centuries after Jesus death. Is Jesus a...
by quietnessandtrust 6 years ago
1st Timothy 2:13 For Adam was first formed, then Eve. 14 And Adam was not deceived, but the woman being deceived was in the transgression. Why would the Apostle Paul need to explain that Adam was formed first and then Eve? Don’t we all know this? But the Church at Ephesus was taught a lie about...
by Ralph Schwartz 2 years ago
Why is the Pope getting involved in US Politics by sparring with Donald Trump?Saying Trump isn't a Christian is a very decisive statement
by Cecilia 8 years ago
I find the god no god discussion so tired. Yet for some reason when human behavior is discussed good and evil creeps in, sin and virtue. What about humanity and its complexity without tainting it with religious antireligious sentiment?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|