I want constructive criticism about my hub and my writing. A real opinion on how I can improve. I'm a newbie on hubpages. I want some feedback. Thanks
Hi Alida, welcome to Hubpages, I hope you enjoy your time here. I took a look at your first hub, and I have to say that it is just way too short. I realise that it is just an outline for future hubs that you are going to do over the year as you master the art of cuban cooking, but in any case it needs expanding on.
I assume you are going to do this whole series and then link them together. If this was my plan, for my first hub I would probably write a detailed article about what Cuban cooking actually is....perhaps some history..styles of food...Personally I don't know anything about it yet, but I'm sure you could come up with ideas. You could also add photos of Cuban dishes etc, perhaps a picture of Cuba, or Cuban people..
Do it all in several text capsules so that you can add the photos down the right hand side. Good luck
I would suggest putting the comment box at the end of the hub. I made the same mistake as Polly on first glance and thought there was only one paragraph on the hub. Otherwise, it looks good
Welcome. I read your hub and have these comments:
- The comments capsule needs to be at the bottom of your hub, after all of your text, or some people will not read to the end;
- You tend to repeat the same words over and over - try to streamline your text and vary it (e.g. Miami / this city / the metropolis)
- You write well otherwise, mixing personal thoughts and experiences with the matter at hand;
- You should use at least one image, possibly also a video from YouTube.
Since you only have a brief paragraph, so far, I would suggest adding at least five or six hundred more words, with a few photos if possible, before calling it a hub.
(I love Cuban food-- looking forward to seeing the expanded version. )
Take a look at some other hubs (maybe on cooking subjects)to get an idea of what a hub can be.
Welcome to HubPages.
There are more paragraphs, Rochelle, that's the problem - they are hidden underneath the comments capsule.
OK-- I see now. This happens to a lot of new hubbers, because they don't know they can reorder the hub capsules either by using the up and down arrows or the reordering feature on the right side.
It is still a little short, but I'm sure the suggested reading -- and even just exploring the edit features-- might help.
I agree with website examiner. I very nearly left the hub on finding the comments capsule; the rest of the hub wasn't visible and I was left wondering "what kind of hub is this?"
As examiner points out, a picture or two, particularly of that dish, would be helpful and increase interest. Snap a pic of dinner each night perhaps.
I didn't care for the first part - too many short, choppy sentences for my taste.
Alida, do you know how to reorder the capsules, on the right hand side? I still think it could do with some pictures, too.
Just by looking at hub one and only hub, I've come to the conclusion that you need to read some hubs about HubPages and other things.
So, my best advice right this second, is in the links below:
Frogdropping and Darkside, both excellent hubbers and writers. Their links are respectively setup below.
You can read anything by Sunforged on SEO techniques and Relache has a hub on earnings, if that's what you are here for.
Other than that. I do hope you enjoy your time here.
I'd like to see some additional commentary on what can go wrong and how to avoid it.
Failures can be much more interesting than successes.
Post some links to your own hubs, let's see what we'll find.
I'm sorry, did you think I was being critical?
I was following up on the suggestions that the hub could be a bit longer. Adding information on what can go wrong could be one way to do that.
I probably should have been more clear about that.
I think it was the word "failures" that caused me to respond. I like your new version better. Trying to be a bit protective of the new hubber, that's all.
by Variety Writer6 years ago
Hello,I am a newbie and I am looking for some feed back, especially from hubbers who have been here awhile. Hope I'm on the right track.Thank you.Here is my very first hub ever ...
by lyricsingray4 years ago
I'm not sure when you stop becoming a newbie, but I know being one is tough.Meeting people is even tougher.This forum is for the Newbie, I myself at 4 months still feel like one but also feel a transition to a more...
by Lily Rose7 years ago
I had never heard of HubPages before two days ago and now I am the proud author of two hub pages. I have a lot to learn and would appreciate any feedback anyone can give me on my hubs so far. ...
by Marisa Wright3 years ago
I'd like to suggest we get rid of Hubber Score - and perhaps even Hub Scores. They:- are constantly misunderstood;- cause a lot of upset and grief in the forums; and- encourage newbie Hubbers to direct their...
by Cagsil5 years ago
Hey Hubbers,This has not been done for a while, so I am doing all over again.If you're a newbie, meaning you've been here under 6 months, then post a HI or Hello and get yourself noticed. Don't post any links.If you're...
by nell796 years ago
I may just be a glutton for punishment, but I've enjoyed the four hubs I've made so far since joining last week and it's always good to set goals, so I may as well jump right in!
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.