I have at least 5 referral trackers for those who wish to sign up.
I have a total of 25 sign ups. This is good.
However, those who have signed up are not blogging,
or there is no traffic. Are these people ghosts?
What is the sense of having these trackers, and someone signs up
and doesn't participate in our community, and then
you have nothing but useless stats that you can't get rid of?
Anyone who has any ideas, or comments on what
I should be doing, I sure would appreciate it!
It gets discouraging to see someone take the effort to join,
then not follow through and it shows their inactivity.
Has anyone else have this same problem?
Although I haven't had any sign-ups for referral trackers yet, I do see many new Hubbers who join HubPages, write a hub, realise that making money isn't as easy as they think and leave. That really annoys me, because if you put in the effort, you sure can get traffic and earnings. I am sorry I didn't answer your question, but I can definitely relate to you. I am looking forward to seeing others' responses later on.
Hi susi 10,
Yea, I have been here for over 2 yrs now. Everyone of my hubs have been featured. So, contrary to some opinion (s) I think I am a fairly decent writer.
It just gets so frustrating when you have ghosts who come here and leave.
I will be sure to stop by and say hi over in your hub land area.
Have a great weekend. Shalom
Most people have the same experience. I don't even look at my referrals any more - less than 1% of them are actually writing on HubPages!!
When I first started on HubPages, I used to reach out to new referrals to try to help them get started. I soon found there are all kinds of reasons why people sign up.
One problem with HubPages is the comments box. The way it's set out, many readers think they have to sign up before they can comment - so some of my referrals are people who clicked on my link to read my Hub, then signed up to comment, with no intention of ever writing.
Then there are the people who sign up, then look into the site more closely and decide they can't understand it. I picked up a lot of referrals from Helium.com who decided HubPages was "too hard" - they didn't want to deal with capsules and advertising, they just wanted to write plain text in a simple text box!
Finally there are the people who sign up then never get around to writing anything, or write one Hub to promote their business and think that's all there is to it, or ... there are so many possibilities!
Your inactive referrals aren't doing you any harm, why not just stop worrying about them?
Well, what you have said, makes so much sense to me now. I will check out Helium. I just have to add it to my list of all the others I am experimenting with. Tumbler, Word Press are two I am learning how to navigate through and make sense of how to fix the font size, and the ability to structure the article so it has a clear straight lines with margins that
are easy on the eyes. The way I try to write my hubs. Working on learning over there how to space each line with 1.5 inchs from the next sentence.
You are so cool! I will quit worrying. thanks
Marisa will probably also point out that Helium is a quick way to lose your copyright and end up getting traffic based on social bias.
No, no! Don't add Helium to your list - run, run as fast as you can!
I wrote a Hub on Helium. It is not a good place to write, and it's a good example of why you need to read the terms of service before you join any writing site.
If you write an article on Helium, they keep it forever, even if you leave the site, or even if you get banned. You can, theoretically, publish it anywhere else you like - but good luck finding any other site that's willing to take an article that's already published online!! They can even use your articles in books without your consent.
I'm not sure why you would write on Tumblr or Wordpress.com since there is no opportunity to earn money on either of those sites. If you want to write your own blog, start one on Blogger (where you'll be free to add advertising later if you want). If you just want to write articles, try some other revenue-sharing sites like Infobarrel, Wizzley, Zujava.
Just a note - you can earn off Tumblr, it's just a pain in the butt because you have to code in banners yourself, and be careful with aff links.
Be sure to read the terms of service at InfoBarrel:
"unconditionally grant InfoBarrel, and any of its affiliates ... an irrevocable, perpetual, unlimited free of charge and exclusive right to publish the Original Content on the Site and/or on other Internet Sites the Original Content shall be referred to by InfoBarrel ...as InfoBarrel shall deem suitable under the terms and conditions of this Agreement, as well as allow users of the Site to view and further use the Original Content, free of charge, for any such purpose permitted by InfoBarrel, provided such use shall not be for profit generating purposes. Without derogating from the above, InfoBarrel shall be entitled to edit, delete, cutback, rephrase, reproduce, copy, translate, merge, add, use and make use of the Materials, in whole or in part, in any way or manner and at any time, as InfoBarrel shall deem appropriate in its sole discretion. InfoBarrel reserves the right to deny publication and remove any content for any reason. The decision to deny publication or remove content is up to the sole discretion of InfoBarrel and it's representatives."
It sounds more like the referral trackers aren't a problem at all, but that you aren't happy with who is signing up. If you don't work specifically at attracting skilled, active writers to join the site, then you just get whoever happens across the trackers.
wow. You came across to me rather cold and judgemental.
What did I ever do to you? Wishing you a nice day, anyway.
That's Relache. She says it exactly like it is, so at least you know she won't bullshit you
She's right. I have about 500 signups on all my accounts and only about 5% have ever written a hub. And out of those, only about 2% have written more than five. And I'd only class two as semi successful hubbers.
I have a similar situation, Wry Lilt. I have 37 signups with only about 3 being active writers and over 115,000 views from those few active trackers. I feel lucky that one writer is a great writer with lots of hubs. The rest, when they get ready to write, they will. In the meantime, the stats are of no concern to me.
Jo, I'm sorry that you've had little luck with the referral trackers, but it is true that it has nothing to do with the trackers, rather the people who've used the link to sign up. Slackers. LOL. One of the people who signed up under one of my trackers is my brother who works full time. Once he retires, he plans to write. In the meantime, his stats are low. Another one is my dentist who plans to write someday. No worries, it doesn't affect me in the least.
Thank you so much. It is so nice to see you. I think I have some other ideas, that I will just take the majority information, and just not worry about it. As far as copyrights, trademarks. And for someone to copy something and claim it for themselves. I have been down this road, a couple of times.
It obviously wasn't one of my best ideas, because I don't know about it. Therefore, they are sadly coming to realize, they did all that work, for nothing. No reward from it. Now, this is Karma
Well, WryLilt, I am working on learning to accept that some folks communicate in this way. I have run ins with personal face to face interactions with abrasive communications and it doesn't go well for me or the other person who chooses to approach it their way. Thank you for the heads up.
Well, WryLilt, I am working on learning to accept that some folks communicate in this way. Thank you for the heads up.
Thank you for your advice, I accept these lines of communication and I appreciate the advice. I will get right to work. Will make sure to come by later and read your amazing work.
That's how you chose to interpret what I said. Which happens to be true.
If you want to make money from quality referrals, you have to go find motivated, skilled writers. In my experience, those people can't be made or encouraged, they have to be that way when you find them.
The cold fact is that most people who sign up never make hubs. So unless you specifically recruit suitable people, this is what will happen.
You can either target people to sign up, or go for bulk and hope to get a few real earners in the mix.
I too have noticed this. When someone signs up, I try and become their first follower and welcome them to Hubpages.
I know there are others who mentor the newcomer for awhile. I tried this once but they didn't respond.
Good luck, I know there are other hubbers who are doing well from their referrals.
Hang in there.
See, I have these people who I think are surfers or spamers or something is going on. They sign up with my link. They write two hubs and then leave. The scores range from 7-65! So, If you have any ideas on how do I remove the non active ones, this would help. I looked through the HP help and searched for it, couldn't find anything. Thanks for your comment.
You can't remove them. You get 10% advertising share for the life of their account. So if those two hubs ever make money, you may be able to earn a few cents.
Writing isn't for everyone. Many think it's as simple as blogging, which it's not. Blogging will not make you money.
Just looked at your profile. You're here for fun and creativity, not money. After 2 years you have 23 hubs. Why assume your referrals will be different?
I had 50 once upon a time. I erased last years articles before I began a new working slate for the new year 2013. I wanted to save the material and brush it up on my spare time, (when ever this is) and resubmit to see if the comments and activity go up at all? It's one of my many theories I am working on. Thank you again, and I hope when I am ready, and really desire the concept of making money. I will receive the same response as I have thus far while I am on my learning curve.
Good luck You may want to work on your SEO, particularly your titles
Okay this is another thing. SEO and titles? When I choose a title of my hubs. It is based on what I will most likely open with in my article or the article in it's entirety is a reflection of my title. So my question is WryLilt,
Where do I find better titles, google? This is a program that fights with my PC often.
Titles need to reflect what people would type into Google to find your content.
For instance "A Journey with Emma and her Daddy" wouldn't match searches on child abuse. "Emma - Story Of A Young Child Abuse Victim" would be more likely to match people who are searching for things like "Child abuse", "Child abuse stories" and so on.
by Dorsi Diaz 13 years ago
I've had a few people sign up under my trackers when I send out emails of my hubs, but I was wondering what some of the rest of you have done as far as setting up a more unique way to have friends and family sign up here at hubpages? For some strange reason I don't think my profile link for sign...
by beta1070 14 years ago
Like referrals.1. Why insert an _referralcode into the URL. Couldn't you come up with a dynamic insertion solution? If an insertion was required, what's wrong with appending it at the end of the URL as in ?referrer=xyz? or would that make it too easy for hubbers?2. Why do pages like the Referrals...
by lady rain 10 years ago
I get plenty of traffic coming from my trackers outside hubpages but it has not brought in any new hubbers through my trackers. Has anybody had any luck in bringing new hubbers with their referral trackers?(I have posted this topic in Q&A yesterday but Hubpages said this should go in Forum...
by x 9 years ago
That hasn't happened in a loooooooong time...Just thought I'd start a thread about referrals. See if anyone is interested in the subject.
by Pandoras Box 11 years ago
Trying to see if I understand this correctly. The trackers only work from outside of HP, correct? So if I have a new affiliate tracker on my profile page or in a hub, it's worthless to me, right? And if I link from one of my hubs to someone else's via a traffic tracker, again, it does me no good,...
by Debra Roberts 3 years ago
I'm starting to recruit new Hubbers now that I have a feel and comfort for writing here myself and have 7 so far. One has started to write and few others are about to. I see all the other earnings reports from the HP ad program and Amazon, but I don't see where I will be able to track what I'm...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|