This has been a problem for years now, really since the induction of the HubPages ad program and it's pretty much what has made me give on on HubPages (I used to write a lot, now seldom.)
I have a hub that occasionally gets huge bursts of traffic as it's popular in social media. On those days, I usually end up earning far less due to plummeting CPMs. Is there something I can do to keep my CPM high? It's really disappointing to see hubs do well, yet I continually earn the same... or even less.
From my understanding, social media traffic is worth less than search engine traffic (am I correct in assuming this?) However, it's just disappointing that when people actually like my work so much so that they share it and those views earn peanuts.
Just my thoughts/frustrations. I know HubPages isn't a charity or anything and this is likely falling on deaf ears, but I just thought I'd be earning more.
Paul E. made this forum post two weeks ago about improvements to the ad program:
So far this month, my CPM is up. However, it's by no means consistent and has varied by as much as $2 in the past seven days.
Like you, I am frustrated when traffic is up on a given day but the income is down due to a lower CPM. Apparently, we are not allowed to discuss specific CPM amounts and I've never seen any advice from management on what Hubbers can do to improve CPM. I presume that all we can do is look at AdSense costs for keywords and write about higher paying topics.
Hi Mel, I'm following along to see what turns up. My earnings the last few days have been a bit higher than usual, YAY me. Most of my traffic is Pinterest first and then Google. Who knows - trends, sales and traffic will always be volatile. Maybe CPM stands for = Chocolate Peanuts Melt
Same here. Earnings are higher than usual in the last few days. Maybe Christmas is near or the new ad layout. I hope it's the latter. That would really be great news for all of us.
It's dilution, which is hard to compensate for unless you've got a topic that advertisers are really hot-to-trot over, or (as was pointed out) your readers are too.
I'd meant to post something along these lines... There's only so much CPM to go around, so to speak. The good news? When overall HP traffic drops, CPM goes up (I think).
I think that the CPM depends on the kind of traffic you're getting. In case of search engine traffic people would be actually searching for something and hence they'd probably click on ads etc which would result in higher CPM's. Social traffic would reduce the CPM rates. Just my once cent
As I understand it, CPM means cost per 1000. In other words, the advertiser says, "I will pay X dollars per thousand views/clicks, but my budget says I will only do so for so long." As traffic increases, advertisers drop out as their budget limit is reached. I really don't think source of traffic matters in this scenario... If advertisers do indeed differentiate page-arrival sources, can you state an info source for that?
I'm not saying there's a source that says clicks pay more etc. What I was saying is that HP could be getting paid per click and not just plain CPM and then they divide it among hubs in those categories etc? Not sure, was just wondering because the CPM's go haywire sometimes. For the past few weeks it's pretty stagnant.
Correct. The advertising value of traffic from different sources can vary significantly.
I'm not sure if it's still available in Google Analytics, but you used to be able to see the AdSense CPM by traffic source and other visitor characteristics (such as browsers, country, etc). From what I recall (circa 2008), social traffic (facebook, etc) was worth something like 30% of what search traffic was, people that used Internet Explorer were 60% more valuable than Firefox, etc. Pretty interesting stuff.
The ultimate value of an advertisement is almost always eventually tied back to conversions, which can mean people clicking on an ad and buying something or signing up for some service, or a conversion can be "brand lift" (which is what those little things that you see scroll into the page asking you to answer a few quick questions are trying to determine). Smart advertisers measure their results in order to know they are getting value for the dollars they spend.
And, it doesn't take a great leap to realize that someone casually coming in from Pinterest, Facebook, or Reddit staying on the page for 12 seconds and going back, may be a lot less likely to "convert" than someone that comes in from search. As a result, advertisers won't pay as much to advertise to those visitors. Of course, the way advertisers decide how much they are willing to pay considers a ton of other factors, not just the source of the traffic.
Can you please explain what dilution means in terms of CPM? I really would like to understand this.
I guess she meant that each category would have a certain set of advertisers who have a limited budget per day. If we all have hubs in the finance section and the total budget of all the advertisers is $X and say there are just a handful of finance hubs that receive traffic on a particular day, then they would get a bigger cut from the $X. But if a huge percentage of hubs get good traffic and more views, the same budget needs to be shared by a larger crowd.
When you have low traffic a high proportion of those people have a strong interest in the exact subject of your site.
When you have high traffic more of those people are not interested in the subject and came from blind stumble, irrelevant keywords and otherwise "by accident".
Small tends to correlate with focused and coming deliberately to your site for a valid reason (proportionately speaking).
Makes sense and exactly what I suspected for some time.
The most valuable visitor you can have is someone who is determined to buy something that day. They are longing to find an ad to click and a product to buy.
And the easiest way to make money is to provide the kinds of page that motivated buyers of this kind are interested in visiting.
The problem is that these kinds of page need to be very, very helpful to visitors, or they will earn you any one of a range of penalties from Google.
Therein lies the dilemma of the affiliate marketer.
I've kept up with updates, and I did write one new Hub last month. Since several of my Hubs had to do with antiques and collectibles I could count on some income from Ebay. Now unless there is a sale, they are not paying. When I get time next week, I will delete Ebay from all my Hubs and I'm urging other Hubbers to do this too. Why advertise for Ebay for free?
Already done, a few days ago. And entire month with zero earnings and I gave up on it. Hoping I can make the $10 or so per month up on Amazon.
I personally wouldn't delete my Ebay, I made over $2 in one day on Ebay this week. Not a goldmine but earning $2 in one day for Ebay on one hub is worth keeping. All sales are hit or miss...that's just business. I dont think it is worth the trouble of deleting a capsule in all my hubs if it might bring me a buck. Why close the window on an opportunity to make a sale? Perhaps I'm not understanding.
Not a whole lot of posts on this thread. You'd think this would be a major concern for most Hubbers!
This topic has been brought up several times in the last couple of years. Someone (I think Izzy) tried to explain it, but I didn't get it then either. If you get a lot of readers who come by but don't click on any ads, your CPM will go down.
I have experienced this too but I read somewhere that you can raise your CPM by using keywords with a high CPM. If you go input some words on the Google Keyword Tool, and you press on the CPM column (which will show the highest CPM first) and write articles surrounding those high CPM keywords that your CPM should go up as a result. Is that true or just a load of nonsense?
And by writing about a topic which you know nothing about, but picked for high CPM keywords (for which there is an amazing load of competition), you're going to somehow get more readers/traffic than all those other articles....how?
Well, I only write on topics that I am highly knowledgeable about including science and technology. Usually when I am selecting topics to write about in those niches, I may pick keywords that have decent value (not ones with no CPC at all) and make sure that there is point in writing about them. When I am deciding on what hubs in my niche to write about, I verify that they have a pretty decent value. I would never ever write about topics that I don't know anything about just for the high CPC keywords; my hubs would not be high quality.
When picking keywords with the Keyword Tool I :
1. Type the words that I may want to write about (usually in my niche).
2. Pick words from the list that have low competition on SERPS, enough traffic and have a CPC of over 20 cent.
My HP ads income yesterday was one of the highest of the year and two to three times the sad amounts I was seeing in October.
Generally, I'm pretty happy with the program this month.
+1 I haven't taken the time to understand the ABCs of CPMs and what hub is making what but all I know is that yesterday was an all-time high for me, too, for views and earnings since I started at HP last year. I hope it continues for the rest of the year, Will.
It is true that search traffic earns more than social traffic. We have been doing a number of things to increase yields for authors. We've switched out ad types from Google in the last month. This has been a nice increase. We are also doing some fixed CPM deals that help put a bit of pressure on Google's auction (In the ad server, adsense bids against fixed cpm deals).
We are also working on mobile and hope to improve the yields there as well!
I'm certainly no authority, and I don't even understand all I know about it, but it seems to me that people will click only on ads relevant to what they are reading.
Of late, I've noticed ads dropping in that are way out in left field with nothing whatever to do with the topic of the article.
Perhaps that could be the problem??
Unless you have turn off the default setting, the ads will be based on your browsing history rather than the page content.
That doesn't even make any kind of good sense! If we are not supposed to click on our own ads, then why in blazes should they have anything at all to do with OUR browsing history, rather than the page content???
They are based on your browser history for all Google ads. It does not base use your browsing history to generate ads and then display them to every visitor in the world. Every single person will get a tailored ad experience when they visit your page.
oh--based on the READER's history, not "ours." Ok, that makes marginally more sense, but it still is designed to make them click off our article...and go to the ad, ergo, it would still make more sense to be relevant to the topic.
Apparently Google's data shows otherwise.
OK...so... in other words, "The Big G" doesn't give a fig about anyone but themselves,and their whole INTENT is to draw people away from what they're doing to look at an ad.
Yeah..more corporate greed at work. Ok....THAT's the angle their data is taking, then.
So, in other words, everyone's carefully crafted, informative articles are essentially getting nowhere with informing anyone from those "organic" searches, because those who would click on ads are more interested in reading ads than in becoming educated.
So sad, really. I guess that's "good" for us in a way, if it's making us some pocket change, but I still find it sad that "G" can't place ads relevant to the topic, so people would BOTH read the article, learn something and THEN go look at the relevant ad...seems that would be more of a win-win.
But, I've always had trouble with getting the world to check with me before deciding how things should operate...
Presumably what people click on more is what they want. So: win/win?
If I want them to see a specific product I link than within the hub.
One way to look at it is that if the ads displayed are not about the subject of your Hub, then they are not in competition with your viewpoints and/or your information. If your Hub is about how to grow turnips, maybe it is better that the viewer doesn't see ads for other websites touting similar information about how to grow turnips.
I am amazed at what people buy from my Hubs – things I've never even heard of! I know that wouldn't happen without the personalized ads they are shown.
Depends where you're writing and whether the Adsense click is worth more that the cents you earn from Adsense.
CPM can make a huge difference in amount earned.
If I was making 3.50-5.00+ per thousand views I would have made much more in 2011-2012 and that stuff I been working on lately.
Is there anything HubPages can do in particular to increase CPM for all users? Or is this really matter of how much advertisers pay and the type of topics and time of year etc.?
Hubpages implemented the scrolling related search adds. Probably done some other stuff too. The game is rigged in their favor. If they really cared about hubbers they would not of gone and done this to us. I am sure everything they do is related to trying to make THEM money and not really caring about us.
by Kristy Callan 9 years ago
When I look at the questions section of hubpages I see pages and pages of silly questions. A lot of the time, when I click on "unanswered" or "latest" I see that the same person has asked ten or so questions in a row. I suspect that in most cases this is because of the fact that...
by jasoncox83 13 years ago
Ok this is not for promotional, only as an example of a recently published hub.http://hubpages.com/hub/Is-Space-Travel-Worth-The-CostThat or feel free to visit my hubs pick a random one..Although a few I understand why they are not earning anything but ones like this above (Only as an example) or...
by Andrew Day 7 years ago
Hi,I've signed up and am ready to start making hubs in my specialised subject, but I was wondering what the earning potential of hubbig (if that's a word) actually is. I realise it all depends on how attractive your pages are and how good they are etc, but what are people actually earning? I am not...
by Jyoti Kothari 15 years ago
Google says no nudity. These hubs violating policy. The so called authors of these hubs are very clever. They become fan of any one and in return they get fans. Thus they have maximum number of fans. As these galeries need no intellectual,they publish number of hubs.This way they get highest...
by Jason Seale 7 years ago
Hi Fellow Hubbers!I have done a bit of (unscientific) averaging of AdSense income on HubPages.com, and calculated an earnings rule for Hubs:On average, any given hub will earn about $10.00 per year.My page showing my sources is: http://hubpages.com/hub/Hubbers-Reveal- … s-EarningsDoes this...
by Elisabeth Meier 2 years ago
Hi fellow writers,Yesterday I recognized that the homepage of HubPages has a new design and in the mid of this I discovered a fellow writer with the most earnings here at HubPages. He's a member since 7 years, has published 55 articles which have been read over 1,000,000 times and he makes over $...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|