I really appreciate the comments I receive from hubbers, but I can't help wondering why there are so few comments from nonhubbers. I would think that at least a few readers who find my hubs through Google, especially, would comment. Is it just yours truly, or is this true for all hubbers?
I get non hubbers commenting also and most don't write anything meaningful.I had a bunch of kids using one of my comments box as a forum one day!
I appreciate any comment;positive and negative ,though.
I have recieved almost twice as many Google clicks than HubPages clicks overall. Quite a few come from email where someone sends the link to a friend, but I get more Hubber views than email views.
The nonhubbers don't usually comment, however.
It seems to be related to the subject of hub you write. Some of my hard hitting political sites get a lot of outside visitors, but still very few comments.
I get a few. I doubt if they ever come back to look for a reply. At least they spent some time looking at the hub. it's all good.
The problem is that the comment system here needs email notification for those non-hubbers who comment - and I don't think it's set-up like that here. I do get some nonhubber comments from time to time, and I do understand how people can forget to return with no reminder. I've done it myself.
I think most of my "mean" comments have been made by "outside people" on the same three hubs. One hub gets me accused of working for a company because the Hub uses a brand name. The other hub has gotten me accused of being mentally ill (by non-Hubbers, I'm pretty sure). The third one gets me called (essentially) an idiot (but at least, apparently, a sane one) - also by mainly non-Hubbers as far as I can tell. Then I've gotten a few "whatever" type remarks here or there.
I got a decent amount of outside comments on my last hub about cover songs, but overall I think it's about a 4:1 ratio, at least, in favor of hubbers.
I have several hubs that get commented on daily where all the comments are almost entirely from people not registered with HubPages, but those tend to be offering advice.
I've noticed more comments from non-Hubbers recently. I think it's probably a factor of traffic - as you get more outside traffic, it becomes more likely that you'll get comments from outside people. Nearly all my traffic is from outside HubPages but I'm only up to 75,000 views - if you split that up over my Hubs, it's not a huge amount and then only a small number of people who read will bother to comment.
Relache probably gets thousands looking at her advice Hubs!
I'd say I get one non hubber comment for every 3 hubber comments, but I don't allow all non hubbers comments. Usually the hater ons, or the insulting one's, or the off topic ones.
I had a comment the other day saying that I must be one of them "Liberal f**ks" (he/she hadn't *'d it) and went off about how liberal's were f*gs and poor. On an article I wrote about the Strangest Laws from around the world!
It's easier and better to get hubbers to comment, there not social retards for a start.
I've noticed that some commentors are hubbers but appear to be non-hubbers. I think this happens when they comment via the email notice, rather than logging into the site and then commenting? Usually, it seems to be newbies that this comes from, but not always.
I have several hubs that get tons of comments from non-hubbers. In fact, on two of them, nearly all of the comments are from non-hubbers. I think it just depends on the content. I have a hub about timeshare presentations and it is a topic that really gets people angry so there are a ton of comments on there LOL
by Nell Rose 4 years ago
How do you deal with an unpleasant comment posted from outside hubpages?I am in mid flow so to speak with someone who is ignorant, insulting and downright annoying! He won't read the hub properly but insists his country is far superior and I am stupid, basically. Even though its research came from...
by Sheila 9 years ago
I spent 25 years grading papers in undergraduate university classes. Sometimes, in the comments sections after hubs I read, I catch myself leaving "professor-type" comments ("Excellent!" "Good work!" "Keep it up, semester's almost over!")Sometimes I...
by Susan Reid 9 years ago
Hi seasoned Hubbers.What does it mean when someone approves your comments on his/her hub, responds to them, then later removes your comments? It this acceptable behavior? It sure does make the string of comments that remain (only the hubber's own and those that agree with, them) read like a giant...
by Tessa Schlesinger 9 months ago
I was quite stunned a week or more ago when someone made a statement on one of my hubs that she had commented twice and I had snubbed her by not replying. Her comment had been particularly flattering, and probably because I've spent a lifetime being flattered by others only to find that they wanted...
by N. Ramius 8 years ago
I only ever receive a handful across my entire account. Granted it's nice I'm not dealing with spam or off site crappy comments but wonder if there is some trick to it.I have traffic, I have some adsense click through rate, but few comments. More for my own vanity than anything, what type of...
by dellea 23 months ago
PROBLEM: Whenever I write a hub on a controversial subject, a number of people create new, fake hub accounts solely for the purpose of posting negative comments and feedback on my hubs and/or threatening me anonymously. These new hubbers have 0 (zero) hubs and no other activity, and they are never...
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|