I think forums are confusing for many new hubbers. Heck, I've been here 3 years and sometimes struggle with them, but it would seem to me that forum posts beyond a certain age should either be archived completely, or at least made to where comments are no longer being accepted.
I am seeing a lot of very old posts on here get restarted. Chances are the information in the original post is no longer valid seeing how the landscape around here changes so often. Is there not a way to make this happen that isn't overly complicated?
I can't be the only one who sees this as problematic right?
There is a notice that shows on forums when someone tries to post to an old one, and we say in the site policies to not open such old threads as well, but obviously there are people who ignore the notice and the rules.
As it stands, if you think a thread has been opened that should be closed, you can use the "report" function to flag it and it will be reviewed by a moderator and in some cases closed if it is too old or out of date.
We do not currently close threads automatically, but this has been requested in the past.
We will keep this in mind as a feature to consider going forward, but here are some details to consider.
When should a forum thread be closed? 2 months? 6 months? a year or longer?
My personal opinion and I hope others will chime in also, is that anything over a year is probably outdated or could stand a new thread. I can see the value in maybe reading old posts, but honestly, keeping things fresh, interesting and relevant would probably be a better idea. I think after a year things grow stale.
I also support that after one year, a forum thread should be closed for new comments on it. It may be kept in archives, if somebody wants to simply view it, but should not be allowed to comment. This will probably ease things for people browsing on forums.
One year is long enough to keep a forum thread open, especially if there have been no comments for quite awhile. Any new information on the subject can be reason for a new thread.
The threads that pop up at the bottom (related discussions or something) are hugely outdated. This has created problems, when someone doesn't notice the date on the old thread and it includes information that's not accurate today. Is there some way to filter the 'related discussion' links so the old ones (like, years old) won't appear?
You're definitely not alone, Christin!! I know that 2 yr. old forum thread we hopped on yesterday was surely outdated! I have said this about Q&A that are 5,6 & 7 yrs old!! But sorting through thousands would probably be this side of impossible. We have bigger fish to fry!! LOL
by Elsie Nelson5 years ago
The count is off. I posted two separate posts to the same thread and the first one registered as my having made 330 posts, but so did the second one (which should have said 331 posts). As I said, it doesn't...
by Csanad7 years ago
I have read that some bloggers disable their comments. This way other bloggers who want to discuss will have to write a separate article on that blogpost on their on blogs, so they have to link back to the original...
by Person of Interest2 years ago
However, we don't want to make the same mistakes that Bubblews did.60% of what the forum ads actually pays sounds about right. And only Hubbers with 10 or more featured hubs would qualify. And only the first 10 posts of...
by timorous7 years ago
I sometimes post comments in the Sandpit forum. Yet, when looking through my recent 'All Hubtivity', I don't see any references to my Sandpit forum posts or anything from that forum. Yet if I go to the...
by Cagsil7 years ago
Hey Hubberville,Just curious- How do you surf the forums? Do you have multiple windows or tabs open at once? Or do you use feed to scope comments made?The main reason I ask is so to understand better about what's going...
by Aficionada6 years ago
There are two changes I would love to see on the page that lists my forum posts (accessed by the "Your" tab).Currently, it lists (1) the thread title; then it says (2) "Posted by" whoever...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.