Hey everyone, I recently approved some fan mail from the popular Hubber ParadigmSearch and I found that he’s been banned from HubPages. Does anyone know why this happened? He wrote good articles and posted frequently, especially in the forums—I participated in his $25 contest and he followed me for it. I can’t think of any reason why such a major contributor to the community would be banned—does anyone have any ideas?
There was a bunch of weird meaningless messages posted on one of the admin posts - over a dozen, I think.
It's not the first time; I'm sure PS will be back soon.
The messages are still there on the last page: https://hubpages.com/community/forum/34 … ost4150388
No PS will not be back because this time it is a HP ban and not a forum ban if you take a look at the profile. HP is giving old hubbers bans instead of forum bans, it's crazy.
That's crazy. Are they having a purge?
I'm not the only one noticing https://hubpages.com/politics/forum/349167/forum-bans
EDIT: I just realized the lack of punctuation in my previous comment.
Yes, I saw that, but thought that the people they were referring to had overstepped the mark or something. PS is just a bit off the wall. He's not rude or prone to attacking other hubbers.
Oh well, maybe I'll be on the list
Edit: His comments weren't even deleted, so the 'crime' couldn't have been that bad.
Hmm, just saw the Lobobrandon comment and link. Maybe PS is permanently banned after all. Randy Godwin was temp banned on many occasions over the years and so maybe I'm not so surprised in his case, as he kind of enjoyed pushing the boundaries. Maybe the never-ending drive towards professionalism has become more risky for the more rogue-ish characters here. I don't care about the politics forums at all, but some real writers gone it seems.
True, I don't care about those forums, but some real writers seem to be getting the permanent boot. I wonder why they don't just get a permanent forum ban instead of an account ban?
Certainly in the case of Randy, he was capable of writing provocative hubs when banned from the forums - HP are Nazis etc. He certainly had a strong contrarian streak.
No idea if that was the case with PS. I mean you can still do stuff like hubs and comments without being in the forums.
We just don't know what happened unless HP gives us their reasons for the bans, which they probably won't.
I don't know the procedure for bans, presumably you get a number of warnings and the temporary bans get longer and longer (that's what it says in the forum guidelines).
Nope. I though he was a staffer of hubpages.
Wow, didn't even know that happen. He's been around a long time.
I think those random forum messages might have been part of that flash fiction he talked about writing in another post? Ooh... looks like we’ve got a mystery on our hands!
He's searching for another paradigm? But seriously, I assume he'll be back. He seemed to be overdoing it with the number of obscure comments. Likable chap, though can sometimes drift into eccentric conspiratorial criticisms of HP, and opaque posts/comments. That doesn't merit a permanent ban though, so presumably it's temporary and he'll be back. Unless there's something more serious that we don't know about, but I doubt it.
That’s good info... I hope you’re right! Do you think someone saw what he was posting and decided to report him (is that possible?), or did HubPages just see it and decide on a ban?
Woah! This is all pretty surprising... I didn’t realize there was something bigger going on.
This is sad but does ban mean no chance to come back? Anyone any idea?
Specific, I've seen few hubbers banned temporarily. Make a come back for good. I realized it's a small matter about s.x. Now, put out your pen and write about coitus like the man in the middle, HubPages' now Google Panda, will instal sense in you. Ok?
I didn't think Paradigmsearch had been banned as often as Randy but then, we don't always know when someone has been banned. He may have had a lot of black marks against him already.
I suspect both of them may have earned a ban once too often. I've never seen anyone say there's a limit - it's not "three strikes and you're out", otherwise Randy would've been gone a very long time ago! - but maybe they've introduced one now.
I'm noticing that HubPages is much less social nowadays. I think management tolerated misbehaviour much more in the days when this was a writers' community, because having a few "colourful characters" kept the place lively.
I still don't see why they don't just introduce a permanent forum ban instead of a complete ban. Complete bans are going to make people less willing to say stuff freely.
But perhaps there were issues outside the forums that we didn't see? For instance, a heated email exchange with a staff member? I don't feel that it's possible to assume that it's entirely related to forums.
That is very possible. Often he would ask staff to PM him outside of the forums. I am not sure, of course, how often that happened.
Possible. I wonder if they have a rule for account bans for being rude to staff members.
They can ban anyone at anytime for anything, according to the terms of agreement. I'm sure that in practice they don't ban people lightly. But the reality is that they don't need rules for every scenario.
I guess my point was really that what we see may be everything. Or it may be the tip of an iceberg. Or somewhere in between. Difficult to know. For me, HP feels like a big city and I only know for sure what's happening in one particular street.
I'm probably getting over-philosophical...
I agree with your point, didn't know about them being able to ban anytime and for anything.
2b of the Terms of Agreement: "Maven at any time and for any reason, in its sole discretion and without any liability to you or any third-party, may suspend or terminate your account or use of or access to the Platform (or any portion thereof)."
Like I say, I don't believe that they ban people lightly. PS and Randy both had been banned multiple times previously on a temporary basis for discretions, as far as I know. But it's a private company and we essentially enter into a private agreement when we agree to the terms and conditions.
It's getting tighter though. A reflection of how the internet is going generally, perhaps...
Like I said, I believe a time is coming when the social side of HubPages will disappear. Once all the niche sites are transitioned, our HubPages profile becomes superfluous, since nothing links to it except the "slush pile" articles on the main site, which Maven doesn't care about. So following and fan mail will fall into disuse or be removed. There is no other way to connect with authors on the new layout. I'm not convinced they will reinstate comments either.
HubPages tolerated characters because they helped keep the social side of HubPages alive. If, as I suspect, they've decided that's no longer of value, I expect to see more and more people getting banned for minor infractions - unless their Hubs are making good money.
The followers, fan mail, political forums are superfluous in my opinion. Early HP kind of wanted to be many things, including social media. The multimedia approach was common at the time, for example, there was Yahoo which did email, games, search engine, news, etc. Nowadays, sites are generally slimmed down and focused.
The main, perhaps only social thing that I care about is that there is forum for us to express feedback and opinions on the writing and earnings aspect. I feel that that has been a positive of this site and has worked well over the years. It will be sad if that goes. Learning from others is invaluable. I also hope that the site maintains a sense of the writers and HP working together towards success.
I know of one other member who got a temporary ban for that reason.
I already feel this way. I like the HubPages forums but not so much I would risk getting into arguments that may get me banned. I rather stay silent and just publish before that.
The way I see things. There are plenty of other social media channels to get into that sort of thing if I really wanted to.
Yeah, it’s kind of a shame that we would lose any number of talented writers just because of what they say here. I agree that a forum ban would be better than a complete one—and that would be best for everyone, because then HubPages would still receive revenue from ParadigmSearch’s articles!
It's difficult to get a full picture of what goes on. We see the public side of things in the forums and often hear the hubber's side of things. But sometimes there may be arguments between staff and hubbers by email that we don't see, or other things happening that aren't obvious. Staff tend to play down fall outs with hubbers too, so they rarely give the HP side of the story. I generally see HP as tolerant, but when they temp ban people from the forums, it is intended as a warning I'm sure, but some see it as a provocation. At the end of the day, the forums are optional for me, it's good to be connected because writing is by nature an isolated pursuit, but not essential. There have been times where I've stayed away from the forums for many months.
A few years back, Randy Godwin was writing hubs about HP being Nazis and all sorts, so I wonder what he did to tip the balance recently, maybe it was just cumulative. His RV articles seemed solid enough. PS was likable and essentially harmless to me, even if eccentric, but then I don't feel like I'm able to see the full picture. I'm here for the writing and earnings side of things. I would still say that the biggest drama here was after the Panda algo hit about nine years ago.
These forums were very important to PDS. They helped him struggle through difficult times.
The notion that someone as vulnerable and harmless as PDS should be banned from anything at all is depressing.
It is a sharp reminder that online stuff claiming to be a community is often anything but.
I find it hard to imagine that PDS had a vile exchange with HP staff. He had been banned before, and when he was allowed to return, he was very supportive of HP and staff, almost obsequious in his cheerleading of the staff.
I expect that the run of strange posts was to blame. I am sorry to hear it, as the normal HP exchanges here were so important to him.
Mark Cuban warns us that all of our Internet comments and posts will one day be used to profile us by the authorities, as fitting the profiles of likely future criminal offenders or murderers. Lucky he who gets away in time.
If you toe the line long enough, eventually the hammer falls.
by simeonvisser 9 years ago
Does anyone use the "Feed" feature of HubPages?I mean the "Feed" link at the top, next to Forums. I just pretty much clicked on it for the first time and I just discovered that you can post status updates to your followers.Have you used it before? Should we use this feature more?
by Yves 4 years ago
In which cases would you flag/report someone to Hubpages, or even ask that they be banned?For example, if someone slandered your name, would you flag them? Here is a comment taken from a religious Q&A comment on Hubpages: "Compulsive lying with an inclination towards spreading...
by Sky321 9 years ago
Does anyone know where I can send an email or post a suggestion for the hubpages?
by ABeautifulMind 9 years ago
I was under the account hroger.hubpages.com for more than one year. It had been almost 2 months since I had written my last hub. One morning I wake up to check on my account and noticed that all my hubs had been unpublished due to my account being banned.I haven't received a reply from them for the...
by Gabe Abbott 11 years ago
I published my first hub today. The first comment I got remarked that my hub was funny. It's not. I can see that maybe a scan of the first paragraph might lead a casual reader to think that the hub may be going in an amusing direction but how can the death of my wife and my subsequent decision to...
by Mike Pugh 8 years ago
Who thinks we should ask to reinstate a page dedicated to locating hubbers by hubber score. Beginning with 100-0.We once had such a page here that made the hubber score much more relevant, and we could at least get a chance to locate the top hubbers who most definitely deserved high praise for...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|