I dont mean a traumatic brain injury that causes one to lose their senses, what I am asking is...when experiences are shared (such as being in school, not home-schooled) how does a person grow up to be naive?
There's a guy I know, extremely intelligent, but also very naive about nearly everything. I don't know too much about his history, but he was raised by a very Christian family who seemed to have sheltered him a lot. So I contribute his naiveness to that.
dont mean to pry, but how old is he? has he become less naive since being an adult?
He's 19 I think. I don't know whether he has become less naive, I've only met him in college this year. His nativity is almost child-like.
I'd have to agree. One can't be sheltered from the world AND be worldly at the same time. I think parents now think spoon feeding their children the answers and not teaching them to think through issues on their own are feeling like they are doing them a favor. I don't believe that to be true. I believe the opposite, but that's just me. If you've been successful at raising a worldly child who can think logically and quickly on thier feet WHILE spoon feeding them information and answer....then my applause goes out to you.. You've done a great job.....that's just not been my experience.
A belief in god/s is the acme of naivety.
I've spent about 40 yrs "chatting" with them and studying their propensity for a belief in the "supernatural."
I have not, yet, met one who has been able to overcome the English definition of "naivety."
Shamefully, they are "blissfully" ignorant and unsophisticated.
Some of the brightest and least naive people I've met in my life are those whose education has not been "frustrated" by religious indoctrination and bigotry.
why the seperation of homeschool from public school?
I was publicly schooled, and very very naive
because no one told me anything.
my children are homeschooled, and well on thier way to being far more informed then I was when I was thrown out.
I guess my answer is seclusion causes it.
thats what I mean, by the time one is finished with school and is an adult, they should no longer be naive, right? So...how does one get to be an adult yet still be naive?
That's what I would reckon.
We are all naive, until we learn. Whether it by experience or even knowledge imparted to us. It's a slow process. We'll get to the end of our lives and still be naive about 99.99% of everything.
It's called "The Selective Learning" progression. People selectively pick and choose what they want to learn, after being schooled, regardless of home-schooled or not.
Most people will learn until they refuse to learn anymore and become content with what they know or think they understand.
As youngsters grow into adulthood, it's obvious, many get set in their ways early. They have a limited view supported by limited knowledge.
This goes hand-in-hand with selective hearing syndrome. The selective hearing syndrome has been growing in recent years.
This is having an adverse effect on the level of ignorance humanity has been registering over the last decade.
Just a thought.
I understand selective hearing, having been a victim of it lol
but selective learning? I can understand that in terms of the educational system but not for Naivete
Selective learning is when people pick and choose what they learn. Life itself is going to school you on the things schools don't teach, which is where experience comes into play.
Should you decide against learning something, then you're being selective by choosing not to. It's based on choice. As a human being, one is to never stop learning and should close never themselves off to learning.
You can choose to be open-minded or closed-minded or even narrow-minded, with extreme tunnel vision.
But, you selectively learn when anything other than open-minded.
what if it isn't a conscience decision to not learn? an example would be...someone with Dyslexia doesn't choose to not learn how to read. So, can someone actually continue through life being Naive about...say...how to effectively communicate with other people? (without having a learning disability)
I don't think we "become" naive. We are born that way and as we have experiences and learn new things, we become less naive. The word naive is French loanword (adjective, form of naïf) indicating having or showing a lack of experience, understanding or sophistication. (from Wikipedia)
We are born naive. Most grow wiser as they grow older. However, there are some who live very sheltered lives and continue being naive until reality sneaks up and bites them in the ass.
Some people are extremely sheltered by there parents and even occasionally by their community. For instance I would consider Mennonites and The Amish to be naive in comparison to most people.
Yes, one of my relatives married into an Amish community and her husband, although ten years older, is quite naive compared to her. He is so trusting of strangers and she worries that someday they may take advantage of his kindness.
although I can acknowledge this as a legitimate concern, I believe the Amish are capable of knowing when someone is taking advantage of them - after all, they live in a close knit community and do communicate with each other about more than their way of life.
I have dealt with Amish at my previous job and they are trusting, but can also easily sense when something isn't quite right.
How long has your relative been married?
They have been married for five years now, I believe. And yes, I'll admit that my cousin's husband may be an exception to the Amish naivete. However, I do know that the Amish are often used for cheap labor around here. In larger cities, especially, the people using them for labor on their homes will take advantage of their kindness (i.e. refuse to pay them for minor flaws, pay them little more than what the supplies cost, etc)
In smaller communities, the Amish seem to be well-respected individuals. Many will offer their car as transportation to the larger cities for a small fee. And it is common for people in smaller communities to befriend them as well. Amish bakery goods, fruits, and vegetables are a thing that people in these smaller communities go crazy for too.
that is more than I knew about the Amish. I wish people would understand and treat the Amish with the same kindness and respect they give.
Unfortunately, there will always be people out there who are willing to take advantage of others, especially when differences in their ways are so easy to identify. It's sad, but many believe money and material things are more important than the way they treat other human beings.
I live about 20 miles From Lancaster Pa. The Amish and Bretheren alike a mostly very respected here but that was not the case where I grew up in De. I think it is because the communities here are so much larger and better established.
Alright....here's my experience and it either applies or it doesn't to others. My father was very much apart of forcing us to think logically. He did NOT spoon feed us info like kids are today. He made us THINK before he gave us the answer. I think we are all born with a blank slate and whatever our influences are while we are young are written on that slate and we carry those through life. We learn from them or not. My father was very wise in making our lives a wee bit more difficult by making us logically think through life's issue rather than giving us the answer. I credit him for the logic skills and life skills I have today. Fire away all...this is MY experience so please don't criticize.
In addition, I can't say that I'm not naive today....I STILL have alot to learn and believe me, I'm way past my 20's. Being naive is part of the growing process. If we all woke up at the age of 21 and knew all the answers, I don't think any of us would suffer some of the issues we have today. Again, opinion...don't care about criticism.
If we all woke up at the age of 21 and knew all the answers, I don't think any of us would suffer some of the issues we have today.
that is a very interesting statement, and does kinda answer the question without being specific. What I am asking is...are there some people who will not be able to overcome the issues they suffer from due to being Naive? I am not referring to mental health issues some people have from childhood, but generally speaking of being Naive.
Cagsil has it about right in my opinion. I would see it as that we selectively learn everything, either because the selection is imposed on us by others like the christian guy, or we choose to learn what we want as we go along, and this would include learning from experience. Two people can experience the same thing and learn completely different things from it, marriage may be a good example BUT to be naive is not necessarily to be ignorant, as in lack of understanding. From Critical Thinking, and most of the ancient thinking some of which survives as religion, we know that to really see what is going on around us we must "see through the eyes of a child". This is to try and strip away our own prejudices and pre-conceptions and try to see things from other points of view. This is to be naive.
I did not lead a sheltered life, yet I was very naive, until I started working in a place, where the bad things of this world were exposed as reality. No more TV shows, where you know it is all an act. When I met people who outside the home, who seemed like nice people, but they were't this helped me to wise up real quick.
you are born that way, but then due to experiences and your personality, people tend to want to believe the best in others, but most of the time the rest of the world just take advantage of that. because they see it as a way to get what they want, whatever it may be
I admit to still being naive even now. I believe people when they give me a sob story when they can't pay me what they owe, for example. Some people are very very good at lying and I am too trusting even now. That's naivety.
When I was a taxi driver I heard all the stories believe me, but I still let some of them away with the fare because I believed them.
Even now, someone posts they are in trouble and I assume they are not lying until proven otherwise.
Isn't that naive too?
I don't care. It's part of my humanity and who I am and I guess I won't change now.
I'm an old bastard and still naive about some things, like spoonin'.
by WriterGig8 years ago
I often wonder if there are other formerly-homeschooled adults out there. Homeschooling was relatively unheard of when I was in school, but the numbers today are huge.I wrote a very short hub about being hoemschooled....
by Emile R5 years ago
I was just reading through some of the more emotional and fanatical posts on the religious threads and I'm beginning to wonder how many of the more extreme posts aren't simply theatrics. Reality TV style.Am I the only...
by Davinagirl37 years ago
I have decided to home school my daughter. We can't really afford private schools, and public schools have destroyed their curriculum with standardized tests. I am curious to see what you all think.
by Holle Abee5 years ago
What do you think? Do you think it's okay to wait until you're far enough along in a pregnancy to see if you're carrying a male or a female? And if it's not what you want, get an abortion for that reason alone? I could...
by kirstenblog4 years ago
I have often wondered about this. I personally have no education beyond that of High School. I do not hold any special qualifications and think of myself as being average in intelligence. I do read a lot and pay...
by Mygell6 years ago
Many say that it is always the best thing for us to learn.To get indulged into it so as to know what and how it feels .
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.