When the new rules were brought in, we were told we'd receive a warning email if a Hub was non-compliant.
And so we did.
But I've just had a Hub unpublished which was not on the list. It was for a link to a "prohibited site". I got no advance warning, and as it's one of my highest-scoring Hubs, I'm a bit upset about that.
So does that mean there will be no more warning emails, and we just have to open and check all our Hubs on a regular basis?
I was very pleased to see the warning on the Hub told me exactly which link was the problem, which saved a lot of time.
However I was disappointed that the site in question did have some good information on it, which is why I linked to it. It just so happened that the author was also promoting his ebook, so that's why it wasn't allowed. I didn't realize ANY site selling an ebook was prohibited, even if it wasn't affiliate - it makes me worry how many other problem links I might have.
Wow, Marissa. Didn't know that either. Now I'm concerned that I may have some, too. But with so many hubs up, don't know where it is, so I think I'll wait till it's found!
No, we only sent out the warning email once, since there was a change in policy. As to why your Hub was moderated for that link, I can think of 3 scenarios:
- the link was deemed a prohibited affiliate link after the policy change
- the link was (or links were) added to your Hub after the policy change (but in this case, you should have seen a notification while you were editing the Hub saying so when you added the link)
- or a mistake was made
I'm not sure which would be the case here, but I would send an email to team@ to check. It looks like your Hub was republished fairly promptly after you took the link out, for what it's worth.
Thanks, Jason. That explanation is the one I'm worried about - I was feeling fairly comfortable that the Hubs had been checked and all the problems found, but I think what you're saying is that continuing sweeps are happening all the time - so it does sound like we need to be checking regularly. A pain for those of us who have a few Hubs!
As you say, the Hub was republished quickly, if the moderating team can keep up that speed of response then it's not too painful to fix if a Hub is unpublished.
Those that are added are in line with those that have been prohibited since the start of the new policy: they contain lead capture forms, they interfere with user navigation, they promote dubious offers, etc.
If that wasn't the case for the site you mentioned, you can ask for clarification via an email to team@.
So...if a site is trying to sell something-anything...we cannot link to it or we will get unpublished???
There must have been a warning on the hub in question and with hundreds of hubs it is difficult to check them out individually to see if there is a warning . I have been suggesting that admin color codes warned hubs so that when you open 'my account' you know that you need to look into a particular hub. I hope admin does take this into consideration.
That would be a huge help to all hubbers. That way, if the e-mail is not received or lost, the hub with a violation can be easily seen in the my account page.
Just think how much better it would be if HP just published the information and let us check our own hubs before blundering in with unpublishing and all that unpleasantness. Publish the list and the warning and start unpublishing a week or so later would seem to be reasonable, even normal business practice !
This is the "Need Help" thread, where we were told we could post if we had a question. Doesn't HP answer simple questions any more?
Not to give you a hard time, but... When and how did HubPages say that they will respond to questions on this forum?
Where else can they answer this question, WE?
This is not a question that's specific to me. I fully understand that I can't expect an answer to a problem with a specific Hub, and that's not what I'm asking.
What I'm asking is, has the process changed?
When the changes were announced, Paul posted this:
You'll note he said our warning email would include "a complete list of issues in their hubs".
Jason and Paul subsequently confirmed this in these posts:
Two days ago, I had a Hub suddenly unpublished for a link to a prohibited site. That Hub was NOT in my warning email. It has since been republished, but for future reference - and for the benefit of other Hubbers - I think it's important for us to know whether something else has changed.
I thought I had done the right thing, but clearly I'm still at risk of having Hubs unpublished. Why is that?
Does it mean we all have to go and manually check all our Hubs, because the list in our warning email was not complete after all? If that's the way it is, so be it - but we need to know.
Simone said in her announcement thread that issues like this can be posted on this forum:
Each time we see a question or comment that has not yet been addressed here, we will update this thread. If you want to ask us a question that has not yet been addressed here, please leave it in the Need Help? Ask here. section (we simply can’t address everything that comes up in all Forum threads).
Thank you WryLilt and Marisa Wright, I appreciate the lectures and education. Sorry for putting you through the trouble.
I had been wondering why staff had gotten so active in this forum, at least for awhile.
by sunforged 9 years ago
This is getting ridiculous, well, it has always been ridiculous.What is so damn hard about making a list of sites you consider prohibited?What is so damn hard about making a list of sites you consider prohibited?What is so damn hard about making a list of sites you consider prohibited?What is so...
by And Drewson 9 years ago
We need an indication of what link is causing this error.Either that, or a list of sites that are prohibited. Expecting us to go through every link HOPING that we find the offending link is a waste of our time.This kind of message is not helpful."This hub contains prohibited promotional links,...
by Paul Deeds 9 years ago
As predicted in yesterday's announcement, we've rolled out some additional warnings on Hubs today. The new warnings that appear are detailed below. Enforcement of these rules is currently schedule to begin on May 14. In the interim, we will be fine tuning the filters that identify...
by ptosis 8 years ago
WARNING: This Hub is at risk of being unpublished for linking to prohibited sitesWhat?!?!? This hub has been on hubpages for 2 yearswith no problems. WTF? And when I go into edit mode there is no highlighted links as in when there are dead links.How am I supposed to know which link is prohibited if...
by Appletreedeals 9 years ago
Geez... I seem to recall HP advising we would get a "friendly reminder" to correct hub violations before un-publishing them... Bull!Received an email today advising a hub had been unpublished due to linking to prohibited sites. So ebay and Amazon are prohibited sites now?(and if this were...
by Sheila Craan 2 years ago
Lately, I have had 11 hubs unfeatured due to Quality Issues. I have assured my hubs do not contain grammatical or spelling errors. I have included relevant video and changed the titles and added new supporting texts and all this to no avail. The HubPages Staff continues to deem my hubs do not...
Copyright © 2021 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|