Over the Labor Day weekend (actually, just on Monday), 4 of my hubs suddenly got unpublished with the tag "dubious offer".
The problem is, NONE of the hubs have any dubious offers in them! All of them are CRITICAL of MLM, and mentioned no specific MLM other than citing historical cases such as FTC vs. Amway, FTC. vs. Koscot, and FTC. vs Omnitrition which established what makes MLM legal and so on. Any MLMs mentioned are cited as NEGATIVE examples!
Argh! Already wrote to email@example.com requesting review, but it's annoying and frustrating!
You have the cart before the horse. Please tell us what is happening after HP advises you. I have had a lot of hubs published, but not received the "dubious" label, but have had various other advisories. Be calm, be patient, you will soon get a reply...Bob
Someone probably flagged it, and it was then reviewed, after which it was deemed inappropriate. Ideally, you should try to scan through your content and make any necessary corrections. If you're certain that you haven't made any "dubious offers" you could just ask the editor to cite just one example. Been there, done that. If nothing else works. just go ahead an publish it elsewhere.
Did you have any links in the articles? If so, they may have been construed as links to get people into MLMs.
However it's not unusual for automatic content filters to look for words such as "MLM" and "Amway" and use them as flags to unpublish hubs.
Hopefully you'll have the issue resolved by the team shortly.
Looked over one of them from top to bottom. It has two links to Amway, but only as illustration on
1) legitimate MLM have "code of ethics" (links to Amway's version),
2) legitimate MLM have high profit margin and pays commission on sales, not recruiting (links to Amway's compensation plan).
LESSON LEARNED: Even linking to a real MLM as example on what a legitimate one look like is verboten.
Just heard back from HP team.
According to them, even advice on how to pick legitimate MLMs is considered "dubious offer". Clearly, there is no such thing as legitimate MLM on HP.
Not that I disagree with them though... But I can see how some MLMers will be screaming about this.
As you have stated, these hubs not only criticize MLMs but "...offers advice on how to pick legitimate ones." This is considered promotion of dubious offers, and is not permitted on HubPages. Let us know if you have any questions.
On Mon, Sep 5, 2011 at 7:29 PM, Kasey Chang <XXXXXXXX@gmail.com> wrote:
I am kschang on HP. Several of my MLM criticism hubs were moderated on
as "dubious offers", and I don't know why. There was not a SINGLE link
to an existing MLM in these hubs! In fact, all of them are CRITICAL of
such programs, and urges caution, and offers advice on how to pick
by kschang6 years ago
Apparently all hubs that promote MLM will be unpublished as they are found. It's okay to review the PRODUCT. Here are the actual quotes:"Hubs that promote the products sold by a well-known MLMs are permitted, but...
by Marisa Wright6 years ago
There has been a discussion thread about this, but I just wanted to alert other Hubbers to it.You will receive a warning email about some rule violations - but for some, your Hub will show a warning on the Hub itself,...
by Marisa Wright6 years ago
Could the HubPages team please explain why some of us are getting warnings about non-compliant Hubs, but others are having their Hubs unpublished with no warning?I saw this post on another thread...
by Victoria Lynn3 years ago
Sometimes when I have ideas for hubs, I "start a hub" and sometimes finish it later or just let it sit there for a while. Maybe I should just write down my hub ideas instead. Does it hurt my hub scores or...
by Sally Gulbrandsen2 years ago
I know that our own views are counted on the stats page but I have not opened this hub to edit it today and yet I can see that I have had four visits!
by ABeautifulMind5 years ago
I was under the account hroger.hubpages.com for more than one year. It had been almost 2 months since I had written my last hub. One morning I wake up to check on my account and noticed that all my hubs had been...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.