Do you like standardized testing or do you think it stifles the creative mind?
I used to think that... But without standardised testing to assess the level how can we move the learners towards higher learning goals. It 's not the testing but 'the teaching for just doing the test' that is the problem. Having an 'outcome goal' ( ie., I just wanna pass the exam) instead of a ' performance goal' I want to be good in this subject' is what stifles creativity. If the teachers had the confidence to teach creatively and widely while giving the learners the confidence to treat tests as a mere benchmarking exercise- creativity minds will thrive... I have been teaching to this end and have had good feedback from learners and good outcomes& performance!
There are many ways to move towards higher learning (doing!)without grades and tests. & I agree-- not everyone thinks this! I'm a prof at a university and when I tried to give students comments instead of grades, it did not work for some.
True, as someone said, that tests only test what has been learned as rote, to regurgitate back into the test. Sadly, tests can be so much more - they are an aid to learning, to cementing knowledge, but are rarely used for that purpose.
Of course it stifles the creative mind. But that is not what it is for. Standardized testing is exactly that, a test. There is nothing creative about tests. It is just to see what you know, how you test, your critical thinking skills, etc.
I totally agree with you. I am currently studying for the GRE and as much as I oppose it; I know that it is beneficial for the schools to see the scores so they can gauge their incoming students.
I'll be where you are in two years. Good luck on the GRE! I'm sure you'll do fine!
Standardized testing has always been an unfair and inappropriate way to test children in our school systems all over the country. This is mainly due to the different cultures, and diversity of the kids being tested. Some are from low income families and not exposed to all that other kids in more middle class families are, some are new immigrants or children of parents who don't speak English fluently and have a great difficulty in understanding the directions of test, much less, the content. Tests of all kinds, are usually originated in California systems and make their way slowly across the country eastward and by the time they reach the east coast, they are obsolete and thrown away by California testers as being outdated.The East keeps right on using the tests, and teaching techniques,though, or other similar educational precepts, that may arise as time moves on, and educational funding is chopped out be various regions of the country. Standardized testing needs to be changed to tests that are appropriate for children's culture, race, and levels in society, that may have a great influence on each's ability and knowledge. With a little care, tests may be much more fair in assessing a child's true capabilities and levels in subjects such as reading and math.
Very true... Do you think there is a good way to do (semi) standardized testing while taking into account different backgrounds?
There needs to be adapted tests for ethnic groups or tests that do not confuse and have material that kids are not exposed to in schools districts .
Standardized testing does not stifle creativity. Creative skills are something that exist independently of tests.
However, it is a limited way of guaging a person's abilities which tends to "reward" people who are more skilled at taking those types of tests and which does not accurately reflect the broad spectrum of ways in which different people think and problem solve.
I agree with docmo it is teaching to the test that is the issue not the test its self.
I think that for most people (children mostly) standardised testing is important as it allows people to learn properly and prepare for tests, and everyone is judged in the same way so it is mostly fair. I think where it does fall down and other factors need to be taken into consideration is when it comes to disabled children, or children with learning difficulties. For those children, they are probably not going to be able to do the same tests as everyone else and do as well, so there should definitely be a system that supports them and recognises where their individual talents lie.
I think standardized testing is a good thing. There are some things we just need to know - creativity doesn't enter into it.
At the same time, focusing too much on standardized testing can force creativity out of the classroom. So I don't think it's the tests that stifle creativity, but the push that everyone has to pass the test and so we don't have time to let kids explore other interests.
True-- I agree we should all have a certain knowledge base... But how to decide what is most important when there is so much to know?? (And still let kids --and adults! -- play and be creative...)
2+2=4 is a great piece of knowledge for standardized tests to measure. If you are an artist, a portfolio is a better measure of your ability. Being on a test or not isn't about being important as much as how many "right" answers are possible.
Standardized testing has both pros and cons. The good things about it, is that is teaches children how to take tests and can be used to more or less gauge the intelligence of a group or individual. Standardized testing fails however, to provide unique testing. Different people learn different ways and express their knowledge differently for example, some people are linear thinkers, some are more "creative. It all depends on your type of intelligence. Since these tests are always exactly the same for every person, test takers of close intelligence might earn drastically different scores simply because one of them thinks the same way that the test was presented, and the other thinks in a different way. This method of testing can be unfair and inaccurate in most cases.
Standardized testing is important for collecting data and information, but it should not be the ONLY was of testing because it will prove to be inaccurate.
by Adamowen 5 years ago
Do you think test scores are a good indication of a school's competency?
by HeatherH104 3 years ago
Do standardized tests determine who will be successful?As a former music teacher I noticed that a week or two before standardized tests all classes/recess were cancelled to cram test ?'s and answers to the test. Does this really prove what kids have learned or how successful they will be in life?
by EDU 101 8 years ago
How do YOU feel about standardized testing? My main interest is how many parents use the test scores to determine school placement for their child (and how they achieve that placement), but feel free to talk about any aspect of standardized testing.
by OLYHOOCH 7 years ago
WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama said Monday that students should take fewer standardized tests and school performance should be measured in other ways. Too much testing makes education boring for kids, he said."Too often what we have been doing is using these tests to punish...
by Caerleon 7 years ago
What place, if any, do you think standardized testing has in our schools?
by RJSkains 9 years ago
I was just wondering if anyone else thought that standardized testing in grades K-12 is a good indicator of if a child is smart or not?
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|