Do you support De-extinction efforts?
Reviving an extinct species of animal is a controversial topic on many levels. There are loads of issues involved, and the more one thinks of it, the more issues one can imagine.
The science is not there yet, but it is being worked on, and furiously. Do you think this is a good idea? Why or why not?
As in any human endeavor there are pros and cons.
Frankly I think this and going to the moon or Mars or any other unnecessary waste of our money and resources when half the whole planet is starving, waging war, trampling human rights and frankly in a mess is insane. If we applied all the resources possible to solving this world's problems maybe, once the problems are solved, maybe it would make sense to undertake these endeavors but honestly to do it now is no different than taking the rent money to play the lotto.
These animals would undoubtedly be exploited not to mention potential diseases they could inject into the present.
Of course it is probable that our world's problems will never be solved but that isn't justification to play God or (for you atheists out there) to tempt mother nature either.
Be that as it may my words will never be headed as long as there are people (or governments)with money and a free reign to experiment anyway they see fit despite any moral implications.
Today we have an administration that would like to lock up any American who disagrees with man made global warming while they partner with countries who are the worst offenders when it comes to carbon emissions. By their measure shouldn't we be at war with countries like China, put them in jail? After all they are aiding and abetting the greatest threat to our security today according to John Kerry "Climate change as big a threat as terrorism, poverty, WMDs !"
John Kerry, he's also half man, half bear, and half pig!
Lets engineer more GMO mosquitoes and then sell vaccines! PROFIT!
That's three halfs wes? Oh, I see he's the result of a de-extinction experiment.
LMAO!!! I was going to comment on the 3 halves thing...but I could never have topped T's comment!! LOL
LOL! I'm hoping you've seen the Southpark 'manbearpig' episode. If not, do yourself a favor and watch it!!!!
Wes,you got me on that one,never watch SP &ever heard of the man,bear,pig episode,well done equat'nKerry with a cartoon episode,I watched a clip&there is a definite resemblance.I never have seenKerry's feet,I thought I had,but it was his chin
Generally speaking, I think nature takes care of these things. Extinction often comes from change of environment or catastrophe.
Having said that, man can cause both those things, so maybe man should try to make amends. However, we make more mistakes rather than leaving things to nature, I feel. So overall, I'd be inclined to let nature fill the gap. It usually does.
That is a huge motivation for de-extinction - making amends for carrier pigeons, the Thylacine, etc.
I would totally be cool with a re-introduced Thylacine, who couldn't want a marsupial wolf/dog looking thing with tiger stripes running around?
Who indeed?! That would be quite something, wouldn't it?
I think you meant passenger pigeon Wes, we have carrier pigeons.
Hello Wes & Tsad.....This is not anything on my "Thoughts for Today" list, Wesman, my sweet boy toy.....But for you, I'll muster up a comment.
Actually, ya know what? Since I don't really know much about this here topic, amigo......just mark me down as "Ditto" what Tsad said. Every once in a while~NOT often~ he seems to know what he's blabbing about.
What he says sounds good to me. By the time this country gets around to doing anything of any significance, Ole T & I will be gone. Just you whipper snappers will be left to deal with all this CRAP! Maybe by the time you are old & grey, Wes, they'll get that wall built!
You'll have to pay big bucks to import the Senoritas!
Have a great week-end & behave yourself (if you can possibly do both at once).....Love ya, Effer
Ha! You mean you don't spend hours and hours of each and every day dreaming of seeing a real live wool coated mammoth?
"Every once in a while~NOT often~ he seems to know what he's blabbing about." whaaaaaaaaaaaaa...???? I'll take that as a compliment! (something I learned while on Venus)
Oh? You learned something? Wow. Too bad you couldn't have stayed longer!! Was that a long drawn out WHAAAT? or are you crying? LOL
It could be a good idea if it helps restore regional ecosystems, as bringing back the mammoth or great American pigeon might.
Yes, but with the way it is going with elephants, maybe we should save them first!
Good point Wes, e should do that instead of trying to rewrite history. the ramifications to de-extinction of a species are many & the whole end game needs to be planned before the kick off. Fat chance,scientists r more int. in next paycheck.
Tsad's answer was on point, but I have to admit it would be cool to see a dinosaur or a mammoth live in the flesh. Or a saber tooth tiger.
The mammoth is the best shot because they find them whole and having been frozen since forever - so the dna isn't so degraded, AND they know they can implant an embryo in an African elephant. So you may get to see that mammoth!
OK but then what, you have an elephant that looks like a mamoth. Creating an animal 100% identical to an extinct species is probably an impossible task. Then what do you do to propagate the animal? No diverse gene pool, environment?
TSAD - no the idea is to put an embryo into an African elephant. An embryo from a mammoth. No, I've no idea how they are going to get the embryo - cloning, I suspect.
Well from what I've read the Asian elephants are closer to mammoths than either is to African elephants &they are not trying to make an exact copy of a mammoth,but rather a cold-resistant elephant by splicing mammoth genes for certain traits
No, such is an exercise in utter futility. Many animals become extinct because of natural selection & change in the ecosystem. Also, mutation plays a part in the evolution & extinction of animal species. Nature is never constant, it is changing, evolving, mutating, & dying to be replaced by new forms of nature.
Animals become extinct for a reason. They could not adjust to the ever changing ecosystem. They did not have the mechanisms to survive in their new environment so they died of. Nature has a law of the survival of the fittest. Animals who adjust & adopt will survive while those who cannot simply will die off.
What we need to do as humans is to take care of the animal life we presently have on our planet. Many animals are becoming extinct because of the incessant greed & selfishness of humans. We do not need to gratuitously hunt animals for trophies & for sport. That is beyond barbaric & reaches satanic levels. We must learn that there are other lifeforms other than human life forms & respect/cherish those lifeforms.
Well said GM,but managing wildlife populations often requires hunting or some populations would overrun their ecosystem&destroy other speciesIt's illegal poaching that is the problem which isn't always incessant greed&selfishness but surviva
The Thylacine and the carrier pigeon weren't killed by the environment - except humans are part of the environment. Also, both went extinct in the 1900s - so I'm all for bringing those two back.
Not in your or my lifetime, won't happen. So who cares, I won't if I'm not around.
Personally I believe that extinction is a part of life. I remember learning about many Native American People who are now extinct and at one time thriving. There are reasons for everything and with extinction a lot has to do with climate change, mating and, food availability.
Should we work on genetic DE-extinction? Considering what we have done with genetic manipulation of wheat leaves most in a quandary as to what benefit would come out of any genetic DE-extinction effort.
I believe we need to concentrate on keeping what we already have. There have been too many new extinctions even in my own short life.
Yes, all the most majestic animals in Africa are currently in danger or only in zoos. If all there is of a species is some individuals in a zoo - they may as well be extinct, as they don't know how to live in their natural zone.
The official breeding programmes in good zoos allow for the fact that will and can be returned to the wild after training and hacking back. There does have to be a suitable wild environment to return them to though.
I support de-extinction efforts only if man as a homo sapiens sapiens was the main cause in the original extinction of any species. This would mean I support de-extinction of all the fauna sent the extinction way by humans during their expansion into Polynesia, Australia and New Zealand (moa birds, island wildlife, etc.), human expeditions into the new World and decimation of wildlife during those, invasion and colonization of the third world countries by the European powers and attendant annihilation of local wildlife, etc. This also means I support de-extinction of woolly mammoth, cave bear, scimitar cat, dire wolf, etc. at the hands of humans some 40 to 50,000 years ago.
by Theresa Ast 10 years ago
My apologies, but I think the high school and college teacher needs to avoid such broad sweeping questions (very few students nowadays - and I see them in my classes all the time - are ready for such questions). I think you have to start small demonstrating and teaching individual skills and...
by Hotplate 10 years ago
Is it true that 95% of the world's problems would be solved if everyone just minded their own bus.?
by Hotplate 11 years ago
Would the world's problems be solved if everyone minded their own business?
by threekeys 4 years ago
in life? In work, family, religion, hobbies, philosophy or something else?
by Alondra Lopez 8 years ago
Is religion part of many of the world's problems?Maybe it's my first time thinking out loud..Clearly many individuals view things in many different ways; especially in religion. There have been many wars due to people not keeping things to themselves or minding their own business. I have seen many...
by stanwshura 9 years ago
I know I'm depressed. On meds, see a therapist. Now what??Having trouble "initiating" - even getting ready for the day is an intimidating and wearying chore. I Just want to be able to process my thoughts and make the simplest plans without becoming exhausted. How...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|