I have a question and maybe it might rack a few brain cells.
Is choice evil?
Have fun with it.
Yes and no. It depends on what you are making the choice about. If the choice is between right and wrong, and you choose wrong, the choice could be evil. If you choose right, the choice could be good.
It is an inate thing. You know without knowing.
Right and wrong as defined by worldly standards or right and wrong by Godly standards? Because what's considered right in man's eyes may not be from God's point of view. However, anything the devil wants you to do is definitely wrong, both by men's standards (if they'd admit it) and by God's.
Choice is the involuntary [re]action called reason, that is adverse or opposed to the betterment of the individual -or better stated, the true nature of the individual.
Choice is necessity or necessitative, therefore lacking complete illumination or understanding. This is the actual definition of evil -the lack of complete illumination/understanding.
Answering a question with a question. A common approach. I would say that yes one would be able to exist without the other. Having said that, I'm sure there will be plenty of people to disagree and/or agree. Almost everyone has a different perception, which is derived from the knowledge gain and turned to wisdom, and not everyone has the same amount of knowledge gained nor do they possess the same amount of wisdom as others(both are going to be varied).
Slightly off topic, but veering into the "have fun with it" instruction.
Recently watched (for the 100th time) "Master and Commander."
There is a delightful scene in which Captain Jack and the officers are eating and drinking and making merry below decks.
Captain Jack turns to his learned friend the ship's doctor and asks him to make a scientific judgment about two small worms advancing toward a baked good on his plate.
The good doctor sizes them both up and pronounces the bigger, fatter, faster worm superior.
Barely containing himself,Captain Jack, engendering a groan and a hearty laugh from everyone at the table, corrects the doctor's appraisal with his own learned opinion that, in circumstances such as these, it is always wisest to pick the .........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
lesser of two weevils.
I will take a stab at working through this.
Should choice then be an action?
Use it in a sentence. "He made a choice. He has a choice to make." I am willing to go with choice as an action.
Hypothesis: That suggests free will.
A choice between evil and what?
A choice between evil and good? Good is not a part of the question.
A choice between two evils? Limited options suggest a lack of free will and then: What is the point of defining evil?.
A choice of infinite possibilities? Move forward with this.
Then the nature of the choice would imply the nature of the person choosing, based on another observer's (society?) definition of evil.
I would say choice may be a sign pointing to the nature of the person choosing, but choice is not evil in itself.
How did I do? Don't hold back.
Evil can only result from choice, as the right man's burden.
If we're talking about the debate about a soldier taking orders - a solider acting an order is still making a choice, and whether that action is legal or not has no bearing on whether it is moral. The killing of Jews was legal under Nazi law, but most would consider it immoral. If someone physically does not have a choice, then no, the action can not be moral nor immoral.
Well, if you want to have fun, use rephrase the question using the word choice in the context of abortion. Then you can get a bunch of people to call it evil.
That's when language gets fun. Half (I'm being generous with percentages here) of the people will say, "choice" is evil, and the other half will say "choice" is enlightenment.
Fun for everyone!
What's up Shades? Always nice to see you haunting the forums. I take it you're already on your second or third by now. So in a couple of hours you might actually be in perfect form for some real fun?
But, yes you are correct. I'm positive if I changed the context of what choice had to be made, then I would have a bunch of people telling me all about how they feel.
But then again, I didn't put this in the political or religious forums, so I guess it's unlikely to get the "fundies" to come out and actually think for a change.
How can we tell right from wrong?
Some would argue that if you have to think about it, you're already wrong.
"Right" and "wrong" are simply subjective standards that we all use. Over the course of our lives we will find things that we viewed as either perhaps being viewed differently.
I know I have reached that point several times.
Choice, in and of itself, simply is... "Right" or "wrong" are simply labels that can be placed on choice itself, or the choice selected, depending on the person viewing it.
Even using the "God's Standards" or "Worldy Standards" titles are flawed, for these are by no means universal. Christians as a whole can't figure out what "Christianity" is, or who "Christians" even are. They've been fighting for two thousand years and still can't come to consensus...
In terms of Islam, there are four distinctive schools of thought, with contradictions amongst them, and then there are Sufi's with another set of ideas altogether...all competing and fighting with one another...
I don't see consensus anywhere..
It is based on what choice you make and what are the criteria of your "Evil". People have different ways to see evil, and then you combine choices with it its even more random a question with no fix answer the answer can be no or yes based of choice person makes..Giving some one right of choice is not an evil that much I can say
LOL, I can tell it's been a long day already because I thought you were asking if evil was a choice. This is a good one and I'm having lots of fun with it Cags. I think choice is freedom. Is freedom evil?
by Grace Marguerite Williams 3 years ago
Are there people who are predisposed towards evil? Are there some people who are inherently evil? Is evil the result of parental and environment upbringing? Does childhood circumstances and situations cause certain people to lean towards and eventually become evil? Or is...
by janesix 5 years ago
I say we are born knowing right from wrong. People KNOW they are doing something wrong, and yet choose to do it anyway.Our moral compass is a gift from God.Morals are inborn in my opinion.Discuss.
by Rishad I Habib 8 years ago
God is perfectly MORAL. Morality is in always doing that which is RIGHT. Doing what is RIGHT requires one to know what is right from what is WRONG. God always knows what is right from what is wrong because God KNOWS EVERYTHING. But doing what is right and NOT doing what is wrong implies that there...
by Sophia Angelique 7 years ago
This is a very difficult question. It's about standards in different things. Standards of behaviour. Standards in work. Standards in writing. Standards in anything.It's about where we say, "This is acceptable, and this is not."I find it a difficult question because I think one has to...
by PhoenixV 2 years ago
Do Atheists Believe In Good And Evil?What is the basis.
by quietnessandtrust 8 years ago
I wonder why it is that a child has to be taught...not to steal, lie, cheat, curse, talk back, hit people, gossip, blame others, interupt, throw things, spit at folks, bite them...and on and on...I just wonder if we all come into this world with a nature that causes us to do these things without...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|