jump to last post 1-6 of 6 discussions (8 posts)

Spanking Children? Right or Wrong? Why?

  1. Johnjfernando profile image60
    Johnjfernandoposted 6 years ago

    When Does Spanking Children Cross The Line From Discipline To Assault?

    1. profile image0
      Brenda Durhamposted 6 years agoin reply to this

      When a parent does it in personal frustration instead of in a attempt to teach the child right from wrong.

    2. rebekahELLE profile image88
      rebekahELLEposted 6 years agoin reply to this

      Spanking is not discipline, it's punishment. Physically punishing children for misbehavior doesn't make sense, especially to a child. It generally teaches kids nothing more than to not get caught next time/or that mom and dad can hit their kids, and sometimes each other!

      Pearldiver, where have you been? Missed you! smile

  2. Dale Mazurek profile image71
    Dale Mazurekposted 6 years ago

    I have never been a believer in spanking.  My wife said I should have spanked the kids more when they were younger LOL. 

    I am not against spanking, just for me it wasnt something I wanted to participate in.  After all you still are striking your child.  Now you tell me is it okay ever to strike your child.

    There you go.

  3. Pearldiver profile image80
    Pearldiverposted 6 years ago

    You Might be better off asking this question of Monkeys yikes smile

  4. jcmayer777 profile image73
    jcmayer777posted 6 years ago

    I completely disagree with most, from what I can see so far.

    Since when did a spanking become assault or abuse? It's not.  It does NOT qualify for child abuse in a legal sense, contrary to what some people think. 

    Of course, there is a line that cannot be crossed, but a whack on the rear end when a young child goes onto the street or something is a real attention getter.

    I'm not promoting taking the kids "behind the wood shed" but I see nothing wrong with a spank for certain instances.

  5. kerlynb profile image91
    kerlynbposted 6 years ago

    Some people may say spanking is right but personally I believe it's wrong.  It creates all these emotional scars and embarrassment and awful memories in children.  I can say this because I personally went through a good amount of spanking when I was a kid.  Luckily I realized how bad it is when I grew up.  Many people do not realize that and so the cycle of spanking sometimes goes on and on.

    In the Philippines, where I do live, many parents spank their kids as a form of discipline.  Sometimes, however, I can see that parents do not do it as a form of discipline.  They do it because they are so stressed out in life and their kids become their stress receiver.

    Well, parenting can come with plenty of stress so I hope parents would be enlightened enough to know how to relax, breathe, respect kids, and teach them what's right and wrong.

  6. recommend1 profile image69
    recommend1posted 6 years ago

    Spanking is only right in the same way as getting a punch in the face would be right for making a mistake at work while learning how to do the job.

    Any kind of teaching that icludes physical assault is bad teaching and the use of physical aggression is the only lesson that is learned.