Do you think it is ok to give kids Ritalin or other drugs because of their behav

1. 62

   Dr. Wendyposted 14 years ago

   Do you think it is ok to give kids Ritalin or other drugs because of their behavior?

   replyreport
2. 61

   Mandeeadairposted 14 years ago

   My immediate answer would be no.  However, I do keep an open mind because I know that some people have had extreme cases and I would hate to judge someone if I haven't walked in their shoes.  I would do everything else I could before giving my child drugs, everything.....I have heard of many horrible side effects of drugs to treat ADD and of its overuse in children.  I am no opposed to something that would better my childs life it the problem were that extreme, so I guess it would all depend.

   replyreport
3. 63

   Top Health Spotposted 14 years ago

   No! absolutely not. How about a little more discipline and more physical outdoor exercise. People are too quick to give drugs to children because they are unable to cope with raising spirited or hard headed children. Where was the Ritalin when I was growing up?

   replyreport
4. 61

   Cindy2011posted 14 years ago

   No - we need to source the problems, not apply bandaids, which is what I think of Ritalin fixes.  Is Ritalin needed by some?  Maybe there are some who do need it, but these days teachers are quick to request it of their students. Sometimes it's only diet and behaviour that need correcting.
   
   I socialize with teachers, who are quick to chat about the benefits of Ritalin in the classroom. Benefits referenced seem to only apply to the teacher, not the student.
   
   I think we need to be very careful with how freely Ritalin is being handed out.

   replyreport
5. 59

   london55posted 14 years ago

   I work within the field of youth justice and a number of the young people have problems with Attention Defecit Disorder. It is hearbreaking to see these kids trying to lead normal lives.  they cannot achieve to thier full potential, cannot fit into society, have little or no understanding the hurdles they will face through life. Trying to work with these young people is challenging.    I would say at least to be medicated and have a chance at leading a normal life has got to be preferable to leading a chaotic lifestyle that has its own dangers.  The parents of these kids also are suffering and may have other children to nuture and look after. I say YES, at least its a chance.  Parents need support, some young people will just refuse to take the medication stating that it makes them feel strange and different, it can also i believe, affect growth, so monitering and support is a must if medication in the preferred choice. I would have been for it if it was one of my own children,

   replyreport
6. 0

   hemustincreaseposted 14 years ago

   I personally see absolutely no benefit (for the child) in giving them Ritalin. It masks the ‘problem’ rather than seeks to work through it and overcome it. Being able to give attention to something whilst on a drug as powerful and mind altering as Ritalin is surely not what we would want for anybody? Is that not merely training them to be totally dependent upon a drug to enable them to function? I have no doubt that certain children truly do suffer from some chemical deficiencies which cause them to struggle in certain aspects of their day to day living. But far better to accept limitation than drug them up under the pretense of expanding their abilities. This question has no short answers. There are so many variables. But ultimately the parents of each child have the God given authority to make these decisions.

   replyreport
7. 57

   Tatjana-Mihaelaposted 14 years ago

   I am so sad when I hear that.
   At first - kids are today as they are because of style of life they lead - not enough of outdoor activities , nervous and exhausted parents who don`t know what to do with their own children, too many aggression on TV, on video and PC games, definitely wrong diet... so how they can be "normal" (whatever "normal" means) ? In addition, some kids are on drugs while not being problematic at all (but for some parents or teachers even perfectly normal child is not normal and cannot cope with him/her).
   Something is wrong with society and style of life people have today, and certainly with the way how society solves the problems - mind altering drugs as ultimate solution for everything from the earliest age cannot create healthy future of such society.  If this process continues, in following decades everyone will be on mind altering drugs from the earliest age till the end of life- I doubt that this will this make people better, healthier and more able to solve their own life problems...

   replyreport
8. 61

   nightwork4posted 14 years ago

   no i don't. to me it's just an easy way to control your kids and people have become so damn lazy and so into their carreers that anything that makes it easier to control their kids they do. giving kids drugs can't have a good effect in the long run but certain doctors will convince us otherwise.

   replyreport
9. 81

   ptosisposted 14 years ago

   
   
   NO! As in HELL NO!
   
   From url http://www.class-action-lawsuits.biz/Ritalin.php
   
   In children, cardiovascular injuries can be accompanied by disturbing hallucinations, as it was revealed by the New Scientist Magazine on March 31, 2006. As with other harmful drugs, there are groups committed to create awareness among patients prescribed with this medicine, and encouraging them to file a Class Action Lawsuit for damages received for the use of Ritalin.
   
   From wiki:
   
   The Ritalin Class action lawsuits were a series of federal lawsuits in 2000, filed in five separate U.S. states. All five lawsuits were dismissed by the end of 2002. The lawsuits alleged that the makers of Methylphenidate (Ritalin) and the American Psychiatric Association had conspired to invent and promote the disorder ADHD to create a highly profitable market for the drug. The lawsuit also alleged that CHADD (Children and Adults with Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder) deliberately attempted to increase the supply of Ritalin and ease restrictions on the supply of Ritalin to help increase profits for Novartis.
   
   What is the definition of 'normal'

   replyreport
10. 65

    ThunderKeysposted 14 years ago

    It's always best to apply the least intrusive interention possible. I would research behavioral parent training and really learn about effective evidence-based  strategies that in many cases have been demonstrated more effective than medication and, of course less harmful....

    replyreport
11. 0

    Starmom41posted 13 years ago

    No-  absolutely not. 
    all it comes down to is drugging kids for the convenience of the adults.

    replyreport