Is it possible to be misdiagnosed and if so, how would it affect you?
It most certainly is not only possible, but happns every day.One only has to look at 10 years ago Doctor's conventional wisdom is being revised almost daily. Eggs are bad for us,then they are good for us,"Don't eat butter",Now margarine is bad for us. Truth is They really do not know.They rely on studies of population,given specific experiments of so many people, and then observe a trend.This is how they base their opinions.
It certainly is a worry.
Mental Health diagnoses are what is called 'differential', meaning that as more information on experienced symptoms is gained throughout the sessions, the diagnosis is refined and may change. Not enough clinicians work at doing that, simply giving and initial assessment and going with that. Many symptoms can represent more than one category of mental health diagnosis. In addition, mental health diagnoses are just categories, like a shorthand, to understand and describe an issue.
I'll give some more info.
I was diagnosed as bipolar at 16yrs old. It's not a fun thing to discuss.
Mom said to me very recently that there was nothing wrong with me but she didn't want me to run away as I wanted to and
as two of my older sisters did , ending up on the street selling illegal substances and getting into a lot of bad company. My other two sisters sweated it out (dealing w/ dad) till a little later. But there's a boiling point.
I only [b] said [\b] to them at the hospital I was suicidal to get help.
I was just at a loss of what to do/break down/whatever
I've discussed this in hubs.
(But I got twenty years of free therapy )
ADHD can often be misdiagnosed as bipolar by an inexperienced doctor. Untreated ADHD has many of the ups and downs as the bipolar disorder does. It also has the characteristic fatigue and depression. My husband was misdiagnosed as bipolar, and he only had ADHD.
ADHD is most commonly attributed to low dopamine levels which is typically an early sign of niacin deficiency. My husband has to take about 6,000mg to 7,000mg a day of niacin to control his symptoms. Contrary to what many in the medical community say, unless you already have liver or kidney disease, niacin is not dangerous. (Disclaimer: I'm not a doctor).
Vitamin C deficiency can also cause depression, lack of concentration and fatigue. Many people need VERY large dosages of vitamin C a day, but the RDA is about 200mg. I take close to 10,000mg a day, and it has completely alleviated my depression and my migraines!
For more information on megadose vitamin therapy, visit Dr. Andrew Saul's website doctoryourself.com.
btw....I wasn't suicidal. I had to sad that or they won't take you.)
Yes. It's very possible for a person to be misdiagnosed. I've known a few young people who had their diagnosis changed either after their mental-health professionals knew them better/longer or else when they switched doctors. I'm not at all suggesting that I think you have been - only answering your question about whether people can be misdiagnosed.
How it would affect any one individual with any one condition, diagnoses, treatment and/or lack of any real mental health condition at all isn't something I'm qualified to answer. In fact, I don't think anyone could answer that without a) being a psychiatrist and b) knowing the individual person, history, and everything that goes with it.
If you think there's the chance you may have been incorrectly diagnosed, that's something to talk honestly and calmly about to either a present doctor or one who could give you a second opinion.
Psychiatric diagnoses are notoriously unreliable. It is common for people with long-standing mental health problems to have been given several different diagnoses within the psychiatric system. It would make more sense to focus on specific symptoms (e.g. low mood, voice-hearing, delusions) and target these rather than dubious "illness" labels.
You are absolutely right gsidley. Diagnosis can be a flimsy affair with only the DSM as a handbook. We would all, at some point in our lives, fit into one of the disorders listed in there!
As for bipolar...years ago when I suffered panic disorder, I would have awful spells and better spells. When I had awful spells of the disorder, my mood sank. Naturally, those worst times made me react mood wise. I felt negative during those times. When I had a better few weeks my mood lifted and I became optimistic. This mood change was interpreted as bipolar and I was offered lithium three times! I kept declining as I could see the logic to my mood changes. Thank goodness I refused the lithium as it was totally unnecessary.
Too quick to label....too easy to label.
I'm wondering if I can feel even better than I do now which in my mind would require more decrease in pills. With the doctor.
My general opinion of our American medical profession...
I just published a hub w/ more info, if you're interested. thankyu
In my psychology class we talked about a period of time where bipolar disorder was a common diagnosis. Now, it is coming out that many of those diagnosis's were not correct. Back then, there were fewer choices for diseases that fall in to that category. Now, the development in the field of personality disorders, depression and autism spectrum disorders have changed everything.
If you feel you have been misdiagnosed you should investigate and find a good doctor. I was once misdiagnosed with a hematoma, turns out I had a tumor. If my parents had not fought for a better diagnosis I could have been in real danger. It is your health, you have rights, and it is important to stand up for them so you can get the correct diagnosis and treatment.
A friend of mine asked me if I thought I had PMDD.
I took an online test and I think I do.
This may explain the possible misdiagnosis because pmdd is wicked bad pms for 2weeks before.. so since I'm no longer angry everyday, as was on lithium, I can see the difference, but now I notice I feel crappy before the day. so, yeah.
Then I can see after I figure that out, if I can do without all the other crap pills I'm on. who knows. thank you
I knew of the PMDD symptom but not the term. I knew someone who was always angry 3 weeks out of a month before the ring of course. Yeah, that divorce is final
I don't know what I have. I'm in the process of discovering it still. thx
My wife was diagnosed as schizophrenic in 1985. She was re-diagnosed as manic depressive in 1988, then she was re-diagnosed in 1991 as bi-polar. She has lived, medication free since 1992, when we decided that everybody was full of crap.
When insurance is involved, the psychiatrist has to diagnose something to get paid. Fortunately - almost every kind of thinking is listed as some form of psychological disease.
Are they still going off that phony bipolar/suicidal diagnosis from your teens? When you admit you lied about being suicidal so you could get treatment!??
And what does it say about our mental health system that you have to lie about being suicidal to get help? I've experienced that up close and personal. Having my son "turned away" from inpatient treatment because he was NOT suicidal.
If you're concerned about misdiagnosis, insist on being rediagnosed. That is your right.
If you are on a cocktail of drugs and still not feeling right, then they are not working.
And maybe that is because they are treating the wrong thing!
And yes, bipolar has been, for several years now, the "catchall" diagnosis and I firmly believe it hurts more than it helps.
My two cents.
by Simone Haruko Smith 8 years ago
We all encounter diseases, disorders, and conditions some way or another- usually firsthand, though even more frequently through friends, coworkers, and family members. What have you learned from your experience that might help others suffering from a particular condition? Share your knowledge and...
by rlaha 9 years ago
Hi. I have a friend who is severely manically depressed and has been since he was 8 years old. He has not been on medication in about 6 months. I was wondering if there are any foods or natural things he can do to lessen the symptoms until he can afford his medication again? ...
by livingwithbipolar 8 years ago
I was diagnosed with being Bi-Polar a couple of months ago, I thought my constant mood swings was depression which I had since 2002-2003. I hate feeling like this, my mood cycles so fast, from being angry, sad, irritated, depressed, and crying alot, I usually dont feel happy, that is one mood I...
by schoolgirlforreal 7 years ago
I have found that Depakote helps me with pmdd.Anyone know anything else that helps? I hear fish oil and zinc are good amoung many other things.I was diagnosed bipolar 22 yrs ago, but from what I can tell it's pmdd. the symptoms are very similar except pmdd is around your period.
by schoolgirlforreal 8 years ago
The following is an account of what I now remember better:Starting to RememberA Reign of ControlI had a normal childhood up until my 15th year when Catherine and my mom started influencing me. Catherine told me to wear nun clothes like her. I lost my friends. Then she decided to enter a...
by H P Roychoudhury 10 years ago
What is the difference between Bipolar and Mental disorder?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|