As I was putting together a computer from old parts, I found a hard drive that someone didn't erase. It was full of the owners emails. I felt a wrong reading them. But this passed quickly as I found them to be truthful, funny, romantic and touching. It's a real love story unfolding before your eyes.
They are from 1999 and pretty amazing. I became addicted to reading them and thought I should share them unedited (except I have changed the real names) at bored olives.
Love to hear what you think.
This guy has been spamming lots of different forums with this post for months. I suspect it is just to promote his book.
It's copyright infringement and invasion of privacy.
If you are ready to suffer the consequences..by all means.
if you put yourself in their place, you wouldn't have to ask.
In theory, you don't have permission to use the contents of what's on the harddrive. Yes, I realize you received from someone else, but that was someone's life.
It would be the same as a hacker of a unprotected machine- full access.
So, I would say no.
But, that's just me. What I say probably won't matter anyways.
Even if you think the story of someone's love life is amazing and romantic it is still personal! If these people come across their personal words on the internet... they could sue you if they have proof! And if the person on the other end of the computer kept their files they could have their proof easily!
You shouldn't be reading someone elses personal stuff! I know, sometimes, we humans are nosey... but it's immoral and irresponsible to post them on the internet unless you found the original writers of the emails and got persmission in writing I would say NO WAY!!!
I've a question Crisps. How would you feel if someone bought your old computer, found a whole lot of emails you had sent to a loved one and published them?
Take a look at Bored Olives. Crisps has actually published those e-mails. Did you even give the authors the chance to approve your use of them? To me, it seems as immoral as a doctor revealing your symptoms to the rest of the world.
Noooo! Is that true? If so, its disgraceful behavior. I searched Hub Pages for Bored Olives and Bored Olive and couldn't find him/her.
Yes...I found it thanks and he makes no secret of how the emails came into his possession. He even says he felt "compelled to share it".
Where is his moral compass?
I read some of them, and they are pretty funny, could be made into a movie, something like Bridgett Jones diary.
I didn't read them all, but it was kinda funny in parts.
Anyway, with the names changed and if the authors don't mind I don't see the harm.
It is morally wrong to publish them - even with names changed, there is enough information there to potentially cause distress.
On a legal note, it is misuse of copyrighted material - on HP, we are the first to complain when somebody steals our work. This is no different.
http://www.netmanners.com/email-etiquet … ght-myths/ has a good summary:
"E-mail is a written work that once created is copyright protected by the author. This means you cannot post publicly an e-mail sent to you privately. You cannot post private e-mails to your site, to message boards or to your blog without the author’s specific permission to do so.
Just because an e-mail was sent to you as a private communication does not mean you then own it and can do with it what you like. In addition, e-mail that is posted to a group of people, on a mailing list or Newsgroup does not make the e-mail available for reposting, copying, or any other use – not without the express and written consent of the author."
The thing about Crisps is that these e-mails weren't ever meant for him. He had a computer in his possession and used the content from that computer. To me, it is just so wrong.
On the other hand, he has managed to get traffic to his blog - it seems that he joined up just to tell everyone this
thats kinda what I was wondering about...joined six hours ago and this is all thats happend?....hasnt even come back to reply or anything
Its like when my kids ask me a question and clearly dont care what the answer is as they are walking away before Ive even finished two words. "Mommy, can I get a cookie?" "no, we are..." and they are already in the kitchen eating cookies...
totally agree with you... its copy right infringement and you shouldn't publish what's not yours
I'd agree that if it isn't your work, it shouldn't be published without permission.
But what if it is his work?
Since the information on the site seems to be set out over quite a period of time, how do we know that this person isn't just trying to create a publicity stunt, similar to Lonelygirl15.
Maybe I'm just used to dumbing down my emails.... but those emails don't read like anything I've ever written or been sent.
Then of course, that's an entirely different matter but the way he has gone about it, the sensationalism for drawing attention to himself is still shameless.
I doubt that is what is going on here though but I don't know the Loneygirl15 story.
People believed her to be just a teenager who made youtube blog videos and became famous for them - turned out she was an actor and it was all fiction.
Ah, the age of instant celebrity. Unfortunately, you don't have to possess any talent at all, just too many beers and a camera phone. I feel sorry for future generations. Barbra-Lee
Wow, what an amazing amount of responses. I would never have thought it would create such an intelligent argument.
I am also fascinated by the legal back anf forth.
If it helps I have secured permission from the authors to publish. Indeed they were thrilled as long as I removed any clues to their real identity. This I have done.
But thank you all for engaging in the discussion. This is truly one of the more intelligent forums I have stumbled upon.
After reading the OP, the comments and the email letters, I'm wondering why Crisps even asked the question. He already got permission to reprint. Seems to me like part of a brilliant marketing plan. I went to the site to read the letters so it must be working.
It seems to me to be part of a deceptive spamming campaign that has already got him banned from more than one forum.
This just goes to show you, there are people out there who will expolit any situation.
Hi! This is such an interesting topic! I'd like to participate more on this forum and get to meet interesting people.
I am Diana Mathew, an Australian Entrepreneur, ebook author (The Money Tree by Diana Mathew) and a Saving Money guru.If you have time, maybe you can visit me too:
Yes I did want people to look at the site - this is true. But I'm not selling anything. It's free. No ads - no monitizing. I've been quite specific in that. I have targeted some forums but the intention is just to share the story as I thought it was really amazing.
But thank you all for commenting. I really appreciate it.
by Michele Kelsey 7 years ago
Do you have to ask permission to use someone's hub?If you find someone's hub very relevant to what you are writing about, do you need to ask their permission before posting a link to their hub?
by kbdressman 5 years ago
Appropriate way to ask someone's permission to link to their hub?If I wanted to link to one of your hubs in my article as a great hub that gave more information on the subject I had written on from a different perspective, would you think it was inappropriate for me to comment on your hub, the one...
by Faith Reaper 6 years ago
I have not received any email notifications from HubPages since yesterday, March 9th, just before noon. Has anyone else had this problem? I will retype my email address and check my junk folder.
by Audrey Hunt 7 years ago
I received this message in an email. "Hello Audrey I am writing to ask permission to share your story, Saving a life and the power of words. I am a pastor's wife and will be sharing a devotion on the power of words and was searching for a story to drive the point home when I came across your...
by Pennington 8 years ago
One of hubs was found on someone's blog. What can I do about this?I noticed one of hubs was placed on someone's blog without my permission. What can I do to prevent this from happening to my other hubs?
by psf 9 years ago
I joined on HubPages 4 weeks back. I am enjoying being on HubPages and meeting many great fellow hubbers everyday. Yesterday when I was checking my emails, surprisingly I found an email from a reader about one of my hub, saying thanks.He said "This is excellent information that I haven't been...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|