http://hotair.com/archives/2012/09/28/y … h-earners/
France has sent their tax rate to 75%. On the wealthy of course. Fine.
So let's all....and I do mean all...take a break for about five years and leave them alone and see what happens. This is the type of Nirvana tactic the left wants. Here's the test subject.
If it works the left can tell us they are right....
But if not.................................
We don't have to look to France as a test case.
The United States had a similar tax rate for 40 years before Reagan!
http://www.ntu.org/tax-basics/history-o … ual-1.html
75% taxation way too much! Well, this is the second French Revolution, instead of saying off with their heads, it is now off with their monies!
However, there must be some type of income balance. There should not be any poverty in the world at all but a standardized livable wage instead of minimum wate. The wealthy should be taxed from 45%-50%.
The best years of American development occurred under the same tax rate.
I would also like to add that there are plenty of examples to look at if you want to see what a moderate socialist state can achieve, take Brazil for example which has been socialist for about a decade, has halved poverty, grown from the 11th to the 6th largest economy in the world and is about to become #5 and it's president has just retired having served his terms as the most popular president in Brazilian history with an approval rating of 85%+ his party won the election comfortably again and everything is going well.
And aren't they hosting the Olympics, too?
Hey -- maybe Romney can go help them make sure it goes off well.
Can you do me a favor and give me a short simple refresher on what modern socialism would entail compared to what we've got now? It's been a while since I've dabbled in politics and forgot a lot of the specific points in socialism. My minds been stuck in comic book and NBC fall premiere heaven lately
Good question with lots of answers, saying socialism is as diverse as saying capitalism and one can have all sorts of variations within that system.
In the Brazilian context we are talking public aid for people to start small businesses, free schooling and university, increased regulation taxation and control of major industries by the public, high minimum wage, free healthcare, recognizing traditional land ownership, agricultural reform to ensure the abolishment of a peasant class in favor of small land ownership, free or subsidized public transport, progressive taxation and high investment in reduction of poverty (that's the basics I guess).
Thanks for that, definitely the context I was interesting in knowing about! I'm curious though, and this is what always confuses me; people would be able to run/own their own businesses, right? But major industries would be controlled by the public... we're not talking major industries like WalMart, are we? More like raw materials, like gasoline or cotton?
Correct, things like mining and manufacture, companies like Walmart would be subject perhaps to higher taxation and a higher minimum wage (plus a maximum wage potentially), but they would not be publicly owned (in a moderate system) and yes small business would be encouraged and aided albeit with more resources devoted to the protection and rights of employees. Working with unions it's a astounding how often employees aren't even receiving current minimum wage let alone appropriate overtime pay and workplace treatment.
well modern socialism definitely doesn't sound like a bad thing at all. i will have to read more and study more up on this. thanks a lot for the insight, Josak! much appreciated
More than welcome Magician, glad you found it interesting. If you are interested in doing some reading on the matter I suggest Walden Two by B.F. Skinner and The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists by Robert Tressel and the opposing views obviously, Atlas Shrugged and The Wealth of Nations.
Have a good one
This is just hot air. The "wealthy" French live offshore or in Monaco and pay zero taxes - the same as wealthy Americans.
Hi Mark, do you live in France? I believe I read somewhere once that you did, apologies if I am wrong, if you do what do you think of the new government and what is the public reaction and such like? I don't know anyone from France to ask, it's always interesting to get the view from the ground so to speak if it's no trouble.
Same as the old government. Much like the USA - it makes no real difference who gets in. They will spend us into the ground, over-borrow and increase taxes to cover the costs.
It's true. Why is it true? Because here in the states, over in Europe, somewhere in Asia - that's what government does. What makes it so deplorable to us here in the USA is that we're supposed to have the tools to keep it from happening. But all the best tools in the world mean jack if someone else has more money to hire someone else with more tools. Which is precisely what happens in government.
Recall the old joke that insanity is doing the same thing over and over again expecting different results. Check out this amazzing video - entertaining but amazing in its wisdom. Bar Stool Economics http://bit.ly/faqywt
Oh yes I have that video in my favorites and have for about a year or whenever he put it out.
I keep pushing for a deal where the liberals take some place.....NOT the US....and take over and implement all the social insanity they claim will straighten all our problems out and MAKE IT WORK!.
Nut when I say this they say Denmark! and Sweden! and all sorts of other place sand I say Greece! and Spain! and they blame some form of Conservatism.
That's why I want them to have some where fresh. do the whole thing and PROVE IT!
You do experiments on a small scale first.
As I said, plenty of countries in South America where socialism was chosen democratically between 10 and 15 years ago, go ahead and look at them, it worked.
Denmark and Sweden realized that socialism is an abyss; Greece and Spain (and of course, France) still hope it will work. How can a person keep thinking the same erroneous thoughts call himself a "liberl." I like "classical liberal" ( libertarian conservative).
Greece and Spain both have conservative governments... Particularly Spain. Countries like Norway which have economically superseded the US are moderate socialist nations.
They never want to do what i ask. Now South America is utopia.
Utopia's don't exist, things are however much much much much improved, economically and socially.
World politics unfortunately do not bow to our demands but there are plenty of examples of what you want.
But I want a new fresh example in plain light of day with our ignorant press watching. Not some example years after the fact no one has been paying attention to.
California is almost there. make it a nation. you could even get foreign aid from the US. Especially if you let the Muslim Brotherhood run it.
The examples I am giving are still continuing with enough years behind them to see that the results are actually related to the policy, they happened in the light and with the press watching.
In the case of Brazil which I qouted we are talking about the 5th biggest economy in the world, people have definitely been noticing.
Well the press must not have been very impressed. Wonder why?
How often exactly do you watch the foreign economics news? Besides "This country is doing well" is not something that really makes headlines.
Look most of the press here are liberal socialists. You would think they would be really happy to point out the great success of a Socialist nation.
Well I disagree entirely but press coverage has nothing to do with it, if you are intereted go read up on it, plenty of great resources online.
The proof is in the pudding Josak. Some of them may not be bad places but on the whole the Constitutional republic reigns. Jingoistic ain't I?
Those are constitutional republics. It's not jingoistic to believe constitutional Republics are the best system, it is a little troubling that you seem to think those are limited to very few countries. I believe every country in South America is a democratic, constitutional republic.
So I would think most here would agree that the best course is to wait and watch and see if the supposed history repeats itself.
That, of course, will also be subject to verification of the results.
Yeah I haven't had time to study what sort of system France is going to institute but if it's like their last socialist system they will have good results, as did the last one.
So then leave it be a find out. You can be a cheerleader all you like. Everything doesn't always turn out the way we hope or believe it will. Right?
Yeah exactly, given how early it is though I don't know why you made a hub on it rather than one of the many socialist states around at the moment that have had plenty of time. No big deal I guess.
Finally France is stepping out of the neocons' scheme. Given it is a socialist/liberal (in the economical term) government, it is time to apply the policies the people elected them for!
by Josak 5 years ago
One of the greatest criticisms leveled at socialist and perceived socialist nations is their high taxes, usually reinforced with the example of France and it's high tax rates under a newly elected socialist government.Let's examine that claim factually, a quick analysis will prove it false.For...
by Kathryn L Hill 3 years ago
FYIQ. Why does this title look so scary? A. The word socialism is very scary to the average US citizen who values his democratic republic.Q. Who pays taxes? A. We The People do.Q. Who is taxed the most? A. The wealthy.Q. Why is President Obama allowing so many needy illegals to stay in the US? A....
by Grace Marguerite Williams 2 weeks ago
Conservatives Only- The Democratic Party in America is becoming very extreme, even radical & revolutionary in its political stance. They want a socialist agenda for America in terms of universal healthcare, & creating even more social programs which will further cripple America...
by Sophia Angelique 8 years ago
sm.Socialism are services provided by the state, e.g. medicare, social security, unemployment benefits, disability benefits, etc. Socialism can also include things like subsidized transport, subsidized electricity, etc.Socialism is part of democracy and Canada, the US, the UK, all countries in...
by SportsBetter 2 years ago
Is social security a socialist program?
by ptosis 16 months ago
yea or nea? Are you HAPPY! that the richest .01% get less taxes? I mean - they did earn it didn't they?Do they just work harder? Is everybody else just stupid and lazy? Hard work will only get you so far if circumstances aren’t amenable. Do you believe that “If you’re still poor at 35, you...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|