Do you think the government should legislate nutrition?
From McDonald's toys and fast food menus to the vending machine industry, local, state and federal government is increasing its legislation in nutrition matters. Should it be doing this?
Absolutely not, the government needs to focus on the myriad of problems it still hasn’t solved for the past 100 years. Instead of looking for new sugar czars, and bloating a morbid budget, the Big G should be streamlining, let the adults be adults. Nanny states do not solve problems, they create helpless whinny drones.
absolutely not-that's government overstepping it's bounds. . . and it's a symptom of big government, which is a beast we see rearing it's fugly head in this country. Also, media, the un=official, and most hideous form of government in this nation.. . .should be ethical as well. Wait a second. . . .I must have been dreaming to have suggested ethics within the mainstream media. . . .
Give 'em an inch, they'll take a mile. What appears harmless can become more harmful than people realize. Where I'm going with this is the movement toward implementing 'Sharia Law', which governs even the dietary laws of those under it. Right here in Sacramento, CA restaurants in Old Sac had to turn off their blowing fans that draw people in by the smells because Muslims can't stand the smell of 'pork'. Campbell's Soup in Canada had to make their soups 'halal' certified, due to the Islamic religious movement and pressure. Anyone heard about how Oklahoma just passed a law barring Sharia Law ever being implemented in that State? Real deal.
Look back in the times of the Law of Moses ~ talk about dietary laws! Islam claims to follow the laws of the Old Testament ~ including stoning and hanging people. What IF some claim this has nothing to do with religion? It is an imposed way of life in an otherwise free America. Allow legislation about such a basic freedom as the right to eat what one wants, and before you know it, more ground is given to radical movements taking away more and more freedoms. It's no joke. Don't crack the door! LOCK IT.
No, and I do not believe this interference is about our health.
Nutrition is not a new science, people knew what healthy food was many generations ago. If the gov' was concerned about our health, vending machines would never have been allowed in schools.
People are not going to a fast food place, or a diner, because they are unaware, they are going because it is easy to do so, and some may even like the food. Basic nutrition info is everywhere, across the internet, on the labels, on the paper menus, in the news.......there is no excuse for adults not knowing.
no. the government has no right telling us what we can and can't put into our bodies. what they need to do is make it illegal to sue others because you became over weight from eating at some place. people need to make their own choices and deal with the outcome on their own,.
They have labels and nutrition facts you know what you are eating that is enough regulation for me.
No, however the government should not be paying the hospital tab for diabetics or obesity. People should have free will to do as they wish...just don't come crying to uncle sam when you have to pay the consequences! It's all about the choices we make people!
Absolutely not...this is another area in which government needs to get our of our lives. There must be standards and practices established and enforced with regard to health and food safety. This is a government function and will probably remain one. Regulating food nutrition is one step away from telling us individually what we can eat and cannot eat which eventually leads to crop controls and on and on and on... The government and some of the officials in it need to get over the idea that you can protect a fool from himself...it just does not work. It would be nice to believe that is all they are trying to do but we are only kidding ourselves. Government inserting itself into the lives of people is a grab for power and an opportunity to take away some of the pursuit of liberty afford you under the Constitution. WB
I'll answer this question with a couple of other questions.....Should government legislate the right to ask such questions, or limit access to the internet?
Should government require that Americans present papers to cross from one state line to another?
That's where this sort of legislation ultimately leads! Freedom is stripped away in small pieces, so by the time you realize its gone, even the right to say something about it has been stolen from those that would otherwise be free.
When people of so-called superior intelligence are allowed to dictate what others can say or do it leads to the same type of dictatorships that existed under Hitler or Stalin!
Absolutely not. It's a massive stretch to demand nutritional information, even. Does ANYONE understand the massive costs involved for a restaurant to use the lab services to analyze the food they serve, and the massive cost to have it redone each time they make any change? And then the cost of republishing every printed item just to add or remove some minor ingredient?
These things do us no measurable good, but they cost enormously, a huge tax on our lives with no benefit. Please, people, stop begging to be regulated into bankruptcy as a nation. Think about the costs of things before you start making fanciful wishes...
I say No... the government should not be regulating the diets of individuals. I don't think the government should regulate the health related decisions of individuals period.
My main reason would be that the Government is not capable of forcing people to be healthy. Endless laws and regulations don't guarantee that the public will adopt healthier lifestyles. There are numerous examples that support my stated reason.
Drugs, Prostitution, and Bar Fights all carry health risks and they are all subject to legal penalties. Does that stop people from engaging in such activities. Well maybe some, but for the most part people do it anyway and many incur legal and health consequences.
Drinking alcohol in large quantities is not the best course of action for one's health. Of course we all know that Prohibition was a giant failure and people still pay higher sales taxes to consume adult beverages, but the consumption still persists in heavy doses.
As for the recent happy meal ban in San Francisco, there is no guarantee that irresponsible parents won't substitute giving their kids a happy meal with something else that's even less healthy. Who knows maybe some will just buy their kids a large bag of candy every week or introduce them to smoking cigarettes so they don't have to listen to their kids whine about not getting toys with their greasy fast food meal.
What will the powers that be in SF do then? Will they pass new laws that will create new unintended consequences? Then what? Will they create a new government agency and hire new police to monitor everyone to make sure everyone in the city is taking their vitamins and eating their wheaties?!
And what will all the health consequences of that be? Why doesn't anyone ever think about the health risks of an oppressive government that meddles and interferes in people's lives? After all taxes, traffic tickets, acquiring the required licensing standards, etc., etc. are all sources of unwanted stress that wear us down mentally and aid the destruction of our health.
Healthy choices have to come from individual desire not the "manipulation" and "control" of the government.
I want to thank everyone who have answered this question. I'm thinking about writing a hub and/or a blog article on this issue. I appreciate all of the different opinions.
H*ll no! I know that continuing to eat Big Macs may kill me, but if I decide I want one, well I am too d@mn old to be told by ANYONE that I can not have one. I think I will go smoke a cig now.
by Grace Marguerite Williams 12 months ago
Do you believe that the nuisance known as Obamacare will finally be repealed? Why? Why not?I believe that the government SHOULD NOT be in private affairs such as health care. I believe that health care is the sole responsibility of the individual. If individuals want health care,...
by Rebecca Sue Mallory 9 years ago
Stop The Government From Taking our Freedom of Choice in Health Care Before It's Too Late!If you disagree with our Congress pushing "reform" that will force America into a government-run system like Canada or Europe. If you care that the American people will no longer be able to keep the...
by Henry Wordsworth 4 years ago
Should we place laws against unhealthy foods?Many people argue that laws prohibiting certain foods infringe upon our rights. However, if unhealthy foods were outlawed, the obesity epidemic would die down, healthcare would become cheaper, life rates would increase, and I suggest that we would...
by shynsly 8 years ago
How do you feel about the "safety police" governing our society today? I don't have a problem with common sense laws that protect us from each other, like no texting while driving, but it does irritate me that we have so many laws governing personal behavior, such as seat belt or helmet...
by Dr Abby Campbell 6 years ago
Do you think government should play a role in health education for our children?With the obesity epidemic on the rise, do you think government should crack down on health education for our children in public schools? I often hear from parents that our children are not being taught health or...
by ga anderson 9 months ago
In the news: a 4000 - 5000 person immigrant caravan is heading for the U.S. border - determined to enter the United States."TAPACHULA, Mexico (Reuters) - Defying the efforts of four governments to break them up, thousands of mostly Honduran migrants rose at dawn on Sunday from the shores of a...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|