Do you think it is right that people can fight for our country at age 18, but cannot drink till 21?
Over the many years the drinking age has been raised to 21. To serve and die for your country you can be 18? Do you think that is right?
This issue has always been a problem for me even as now it is a remote concern. We create second class citizens for those aged between 18-21. Either you are of the age of majority or you are not, this quasi thing is very annoying. We had these arguments in 1970's and it clearly unfair then as it is now. As far as I am concerned the age of majority is 18 for all things adult. If they can require your military service and put your life on the line, require that you be bound by contracts you sign, etc, why can't you have a drink?
I also think if you are old enough to fight / die for your country then you are old enough to drink / smoke / vote / get married / have kids and make the same kind of decisions that you are able to make protecting our country .
They seriously need to rethink this law and change it asap
No, I've never agreed with that .. it's like they are saying ok you can die for your country but not drink .. I feel the age for drinking, voting and joining the service should be 21 -- that way its fair all the way around .. I used to think they should lower the drinking at to 18 but don't feel you are responsible at that age.
No. We had a similar argument to that in the UK, could serve in the armed forces at 18 but couldn't vote until 21, eventually the voting age was reduced to 18.
It's not like 18 year old soldiers are just given a gun and a uniform and are being sent into battle. They are being trained, disciplined and drilled into a battle-ready soldier who is capable of making decisions based on orders and the strategy given. While 18 is not the most mature age in the world, they are being prepared for whats ahead.
As a contrast: Someone who is 18 years of age doesn't recieve training and drilling in how to responsibly consume alcoholic beverages and handle the drunk state of mind one gets himself into. Even if such trainig was provided when someone is drunk the training flies out the window.
My point? An 18 yr old private with a gun in the hand is able to think more responsibly and maturely than an 18 yr old student with a 40oz. This is probably also the reason why army is 18 and alcohol is 21.
Joining the military is a choice at 18. Drinking may only be a choice because you are following your friends. When they sign up to join the military they know that part of that job could be to die. When you start drinking you are voluntarily making the decision that you might go kill someone and yourself if you drive drunk. I respect the drinking age of 21 because too many people die from drunk drivers and 18 year olds do not drink responsibly and a prime example is spring break even at 21 they dont drink responsible. How many kids have died at frat parties? How many kids have died because of drinking and driving? How many kids have died from alcohol poisoning because they dont know when to quit because their peers pressure them to keep going.
I'm with Catzgendron. Where's the logic in saying you're old enough to die for your country but NOT old enough to kill yourself (albeit more slowly) with alcohol? upping the age for military service, voting, AND drinking to 21 would make much more sense because 18-yr-olds are NOT responsible (or wise enough) yet to be involved in any of the three.
I think the drinking age question is an interesting one. Logically, it seems like the age of majority should be the same across the board (drinking, voting, going to war) and I think our "prohibition" type attitude towards drinking doesn't do much good. And yet the Age 21 drinking law has saved considerable teenage lives that would have otherwise been lost to drinking and driving. So, it's a public health response to a problem that has been effective. It's hard to argue with saved teenage lives.
When I was 18 I thought it was utterly ridiculous. When I turned 22, and met with my friends who had enlisted out of high school, I saw the remarkable change in them that 4 years of military training had accomplished. Compared to friends who had started drinking right out of high school (prohibited or not, it's still a reality) it was quite an eye opener. Since then, I'm just fine with military service at 18, and drinking at 21.
No, I has always thought that if you could die for your country, you should be able to drink. Why is the age for dying lower than the age for drinking?
I do not think this is right. My husband is in the army, he joined the day he turned 18, and he is 20 now. I feel if you are responsible enough to be in the military, you're responsible enough to drink. Many people say that people aren't responsible enough to drink at 18, but I know quite a few people who aren't responsible enough to drink at age 30. And no matter the legal drinking age, tons of people drink before they are 21. Hell, I started drinking when I was 15. (note: I don't drink anymore. at all.) Just because the government says you can't drink until you are 21, doesn't mean there aren't people out there who disagree with it and will buy alcohol for their friends or whatever. On other note, I think the fact that it's technically illegal to drink until you are 21 makes it even more appealing to younger people.
I've never seen anyone old enough to drink. I'm totally against it in any form. I've not yet known of a disciplined drinker at any age, but I have seen 18 year olds seek out a disciplined life as a soldier.
by spbarton21 6 years ago
Do you think the drinking age should be lowered to 18?Should the drinking age be lowered from 21 to 18? If an 18 year old is allowed to vote should they not be allowed all the freedoms we have in our nation? Is it fair that states can reduce the drinking age but will lose federal funding for their...
by Peeples 5 years ago
Why is the legal age to drink 21 in the majority of USA?When the legal age to join the military is 18, the legal age to consent to sex is 16, the legal age to buy pornography and lottery is 18, and the legal age to be held responsible for a signed contract (credit card/house purchase) is 18.
by momster 6 years ago
You can vote, buy cigerettes, become a legal adult, sign a bonding contract, and serve your country at the age of 18. You cannot legally consume or buy alcohol until the age of 21. Should the age limit be lowered for drinking or should we raise the age for all the other things that are allowed at...
by ngureco 9 years ago
Should It Matter If The Drinking Age Is Lowered From 21 To 18?
by Mahsa S 2 years ago
Should we raise the age limit for drinking? What should be the ideal age? Should it be banned?We do know that drinking has some serious consequences and may even put a huge impact on your brain/body in a long term situation as well. Should drinking be banned? Should we raise the drinking age from...
by Charlu 6 years ago
Should those in the military be allowed to drink even if they are under age? Why or why not?We allow men and women of the armed forces to serve our country and fight in conditions unbearable to most, yet we don't allow them to drink. Do you think that literally being willing to give up your...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|