Is it always good to have morals first before you follow the laws and rules?
In the case of a lifesaver who was removed from his job because he saved a drowning man out of his area of jurisdiction. There are a lot of implications of the act of saving a drowning man, what if the man died, leaving your post is unlawful etc.?
Perhaps the better question is where do good moral values come from? I submit that the ONLY place morality comes from is from God's law in the Bible. Do not kill? It is in the ten commandments. Do not commit adultery? The same. Do not steal? Ditto. Whether or not we give credit to it, morality originates with God's law.
With regard to your example ... my question would be, whose is the higher law? The municipality, or God's? I would think the value placed on a man's life would trump the municipality's law, which is not to say that he would not be unjustly punished. However in the end, I believe his correct choice will be justified and recognized.
I was going to say have good morals first but Sports Better made a point. These days "Morals" differ.
For me, I would rather save a life, than follow the law. Its not nice to live with the fact that a person died because you didn't help them.
Morals are base on natural laws. Thou shall not steal the property of others. Thou shall not do to others what he would not want done to self. These are moral values deriving from common sense, which is why they're considered natural law, they do not need to be thought. Rule and state laws are base on our civic duties as citizens. Although there can be some similarities, they don't always follow the same logic. State law - NO Parking, Do Not Enter. State laws doesn't have to follow common sense, it's an order. Having good morals doesn't help us accept State laws, it forces us to question why the law is there the first place.
In your example the act of saving a man fail short because the man died which could become consequential although the intent behind the attempt is just. But had the man lived the action saving the man should have become justified and praised. Therefore, the unlawful act of the man leaving the post is balanced out with the action of the man saving a life, which doesn't make the action of the man leaving the post lawful but canceled out by his brave act.
there are laws that are not in adherence to morals and there are morals that are not legal, yet we must consider that life supersedes above all else regardless whether it is moral or legal...
Good comment raciniwa. Life is indeed the most to be considered, but I wonder which among the laws that are not in adherence to morals are you thinking about or perhaps you can provide examples to those morals which to you are not legal. The example
Morals first. Lifesaver is correct to save drowning man even if it is against regulation. Better to save life and lose job, than to save job and lose life -- obviously.
I think it would be immoral to allow a man to drown and not attempt to help him. How could you live with yourself? I know I couldn't! In most cases, the law and most rules will fall in line with morals...but as in this case it doesn't. A person has to use their own judgement and decide is saving a life worth breaking a rule? I say screw the rules if a life is at stake.
My answer to the life guard is DO WHAT YOU CAN LIVE WITH. In other words I am pretty sure this guy will fnd another job, but would he have been able to live with himself if he let that man die? I would rather look for a job than live with letting someone die. This is not a moral choice it is the life guards job to save a life. The person who should have been fired was the life guard who was suppose to be watching that area. Policy should never take the place of common sense!!!
As for morals, they are a from the bible. Without those morals men would still be clubbing each other to death for meat (ok so this still happens in some countries). The point is we built the basic laws of this country from the ten commandments. Men have proven time and time again that when they are left to make laws it will be dumb laws.
Carmel California "Women may not wear high heels while in the city limits". I could go on...
by Judy Specht 4 years ago
Is it better to have more rules/laws in a given club, city,state, country or fewer laws?Do laws protect us or create problems?
by SportsBetter 6 years ago
Any law the people have to follow, should the government be held to that law as well?
by Keith James Kennedy 18 months ago
What would happen if there were no rules?Can morals replace police and government?
by JMMBS 6 years ago
There is no way for us to know if our morals that we have today is the right ones or not. Our Morals are made out of our "Common Sense".If we don't know if we have the right morals or not, then can we truly trust our conscience when it's based on the society/governmental morals?The common...
by Minister Mitch 3 years ago
Do you think the Ten (10) commandments are really no longer useful?What will happen if the 10 commandments are no longer taught in the homes of Americans?.
by andrew savage 5 years ago
What are the aspects of the two modes of practical law that make one incompatible with the other?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|