If you discover a drone hovering over your property, is it legal to shoot it down?
If the government shreds the Constitution and we let them, then they can do just about anything they want.
If you shoot down government property, then you're likely breaking the law by destruction of federal property.
If you don't want drones hovering over your property, invading your privacy, then help us legalize the Constitution again. Help us make America a land of the people, rather than a land of the corporation.
I don't think so. If you shoot in the city they will get you. suppose you fire and someone gets shot? And then suppose it were to crash in someone's house? Why not call 911?
I think shooting it down will cause more problems than we really want.
Wouldn't need to shoot it down to be causing problems. They are talking about pizza-delivery drones for when you are stuck in traffic. Too many drones=accidents. How you would like the air filled with the sound of giant angry mosquitoes?
I do not think you can. If you have that much firepower it concerns me and how do you insure that what you shoot down does not fall into a playground or school yard.
The old common law rule was that you own real property downward to the center of the Earth and upward to the heavens. That evaporated with the advent of air traffic, road building, utilities lines, and the other intrusive aspects of highly technological society. Today, government, not you, controls airspace, electromagnetic transmissions, water, mineral rights, and all other aspects of your property. It has the power to take any of those it wants, not always with compensation to you, to say nothing of your willing permission. You even rent from the government now, you don't really own it at all. Stop paying taxes, assessments and fees, and you'll find that out. Your real property will be repossessed by its real owner in short order.
Government is us. Our taxes are their pocket money to redistribute in the different departments. Therefore the drones are ours.
The most insidiously damaging fiction of today's American political life is the carefully cultivated lie that we are the government.
I was wondering if it was an arguable point in a court of law. I definitely know that we the people are not in control!
I'm sorry, I don't quite follow your line of inquiry here. Are you asking if a legal argument that because the government owns the drones, we the people do, and therefore we the people have standing to bar them from our space, might succeed in court?
What a provocative question. Yesterday, heard a guy on the radio talking about how 10,000 drones, in the sky ,working for police departments etc. will cause air traffic problems.
This q got my attention. At the risk of sounding stupid, might I ask, what is a drone?
Good question. It depends on where you live and whether you use self-defense as your reason. You might be fine in the legal sense depending on who the owner of the drone is and their purposes for studying you or your property. Drones can be put into use by public and private owners and be used for a variety of reasons including bringing you harm via weapons. Increasingly, they have heat seeking abilities to see exactly what you are doing...even in the privacy of your own home. I hope I'm completely wrong but it seems these things are going to become more common like a big (nosy) brother on steroids.
I'm pretty sure those drones fly much higher than you may think; you would never see it even it sees you.
And no, it's not legal to shoot it down because we don't own the airspace over our property.
I say let them patrol from the sky and catch the criminals that way, why should it bother us unless we're doing something we shouldn't? It's safer for the cops and for us.
What does that mean? Which part do you disagree with? Just wondering.
In a nameless state you can say your neeighbor did something and cause that neighbor to b fined $500. There doesn't need to be evidence to support the allegation. The day where you are safe doing right is obsolete
Wow Tireless, I hadn't heard that. Guess it's a good thing I'm married to a cop. I can only guess how you feel about them...
KK - what if you are making love to your spouse, and the drone has a FLIR unit that can see your heat images through walls? Florida has already ruled that as an invasion of privacy from police driving by looking for Pot hot-houses.
My problem with this way of thinking: ... >>why should it bother us unless we're doing something we shouldn't
"why should it bother us unless we're doing something we shouldn't?"
Tell that to a survivor of the Holocaust.
They already have very loud and intrusive helicopters hovering at 200 feet above suburbia looking for pot plants. What is the expectation of privacy from the air? None.
I remember when I was living in Winston Hale in downtown Chinatown of Honolulu. I was in the courtyard and a stealth (yes - stealth!) full-sized black helicopter with no markings on the bottom came hovering slowly past at maybe 20 feet above the 4 story rooftop. On both sides of the whirly-bird were two long pylons extensions of about 20-35 long and on each end was a black ball that you would see covering a camera. So not only taking pictures - it was stereoscopic cameras.
If shoot down the drone there would be no way to tell if that is a gov't drone or your ex-spouse stalking you. Perhaps don't even need to shoot it down. Maybe all you need is a laser pointer or a radio-jammer directed at it and make it crash. Don't need a gun just a .. MIJI (Meaconing, Intrusion, Jamming, and Interference) which means “Spoofing a GPS receiver on a UAV ....forcing it into an automatic landing mode after it lost its bearings. " - /drones-vulnerable-to-terrorist-hijacking - Yes military signals are encrypted - but a hacker-geek using a Radio jammer wouldn't need to decrypt - it would be a denial-of-service attack (DoS). Decrypting it is only if want to reverse -engineer it.
"The encrypted P code for military users is transmitted on both the L1 and L2 frequency. If the Iranians could jam the encrypted military code on the L1 and L2 frequencies then the drone’s GPS receiver might reach out to use the less secure code to get directions. " - http://phys.org/news/2011-12-rq-drone-a … anian.html
But the drones are more dangerous because "drones that will fly over the US will rely on civilian GPS, which is not encrypted and wide open to infiltration." I could be the mad Kascinski - and crash that sucker into the White House - or a commercial passenger plane over NYC without even being the on board the plane as the suicidal hijacker!
The technology is there, outlawing won't change a thing, it's a brave new world. The only time you would be able to have privacy on your own land is during a thunderstorm, sandstorm, or solar flare storm.
I remember when GPS was encrypted. It was in 1979 - and caused us to be grounded on a sandbar just inside a GA inlet during a storm at night, with surf pounding in at us. Thanks to a Brunswick towboat we were saved before the boat (40' sail) broke up
I don't know, BUT - my guess would be 'no' - I don't own air rights over my property (I don't think) so while it is over my property, it is technically not ON my property. Harks to the old question of "do you own your view"? The 'no' answer to that has been upheld in many courts.
The question may become very important as 'big brother' is increasing surveillance - and it's not murder, so what would the charge and/or the defense be?
if it is hovering over my house it may just have an accident. like whooops my drone just went crazy you must have interfered with my controls
by My Esoteric 2 years ago
For those who follow me, Left or Right, and know my advocating sensible gun safety regulations, you will probably be surprised at the position I take on this; although it is consistent with my personal philosophy.In Oct 2015, a Kentucky judge dismissed charges against William Meredith for taking a...
by Dreamlin 5 years ago
Can a NY licensed lawyer provide legal services (buy/sell) to a NJ real property without NJ License?Can a New York licensed lawyer provide legal services to a New Jersey Real Property (buy/sell) without obtaining a New Jersey License? A lawyer only has NY License admits he helped a NJ resident...
by Reality Bytes 6 years ago
Sat Apr 14, 2012 8:59AM GMTAt least 35 people have been killed and dozens of others wounded in a missile attack by two US assassination drones in southern Somalia, Press TV reports.The casualties come after an unmanned aircraft fired several missiles at al-Shabab training bases located between the...
by Simon Cook 5 years ago
I, like many, am amazed that the US would have Drones over the US and will not specifically say they will never be used on American Citizens in the US. The whole problem being that there should be 'due-course', trials etc - "innocent before proven guilty' always comes to mind.However it has...
by John Coviello 2 years ago
Do You Think a Neighbor Flying a Drone Over Your Property is an Invasion of Privacy?
by Marlene Bertrand 21 months ago
Do American citizens give up their civil rights when they join the military?My husband told me that when he joined the military, they told him he was the property of the United States. That got me to wondering if that meant he lost his civil rights while he was serving in the military.
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|