If you see someone on the side of the road begging for money, or food, do you help them?
It seems with the economy being were it is today, that I have been seeing more and more people with signs begging for money and food. However, times are tight. Do you have the ability to spare some extra cash or food? And do you trust that giving them this will be helpful or that they will just abuse your help?
I give them a protein bar or some change that I have. My parents feed the homeless every saturday, but I've never liked that idea much.
Trust your instinct, most of the time you can tell whether or whether not this beggar is a phony. You should definitely help anyone you can within your budget, money comes and money goes. Charity isn't just a nice thing to do, it's a obligation of the more fortunate to help the less fortunate, the world needs balance and compassion so, yes I think you shall help out.
I have ambivalent feelings. I know many homeless have their spot where they have a sign. Many times I have seen these folks in a grocery store buying cigarettes and beer. Giving them something to eat is the best idea.
Generally not. Often, they are smoking cigarettes, which are $9.00 a pack in Washington state. Other times, I see persons much younger than myself who don't show any obvious physical disabilities. Some people seem to have hit on this as a way of life and aren't looking for a real job. I do feel sympathetic when I see a middle aged to older woman standing out in the pouring rain and am more inclined to give some cash. But, in general, I do not.
I have no problem helping someone out when they have the need and I have the means. However, handing money and food over to people on the street really just gets them through today in order to repeat the same thing the next day. I prefer to give money to and/or support services which try to help the homeless change tomorrow. That doesn't mean don't help them today, but there has to be a balance to change the long-term outcomes.
I also don't mind at all if they buy cigarettes or alcohol. Sometimes softening the mind is the more critical need to get by than are any caloric requirements of the body. If what they need is to be numb, than so be it.
I absolutely agree with you. I too give when and what I can and I attach no strings to my small donations. It is not up to me to decide what someone else 'needs' to make it through their day.
I agree with you because being out there has got to be tough and harsh way to live. Sometimes it is rut and hard to get out of that rut.
I'm careful with things like that. As sad as it is, many of those people will likely use any money they are given to buy drugs or alcohol. I'll never give them money, but sometimes if I'm going out to dinner and I walk out with leftovers in a box, I'll give them to a homeless person. I'm more quick to buy things that they actually need and give those to them instead of trusting them to buy whatever else they need.
Our family helps prepare food for distribution at the homeless shelters. When I see a panhandler at a freeway offramp, I will usually give a bottled water.
I stopped and offered to have one of them work for me for the week to help him get on his feet. I was told that he makes $150-$500 per day and couldn't afford to take a cut in pay. Since then our county has made it a crime to panhandle, there are many programs available to the needy if they really want help.
You have told the truth. There are jobs out there; however, these jobs may not be what the person wants but it is a JOB nevertheless.
Thats a crying shame that it has to be like that. Sometimes you need that little extra with gas prices sky rocketing. I would much rather give my money to them instead to a program that does not work.
I will give food, or take them to the store to get food. I will never give them money. I think one of the best things to do for a person sometimes is to talk to them. I like to take them with me to a store to get food, the ones who are in need will come. Many won't and they are not after food. Then I can have a conversation with them and tell them about some resources I know of.
Giving a penny or two to the beggars is not a solution for their livelihood. It would be nice if we advice them to work and earn for themselves. If the beggar is physically normal, he can put himself into any work to live with a self respect.
I try to do what I can, especially if I feel lead to do so. When I lived in SoCal, you could tell pretty easily which ones were genuine and which ones weren't. I have had my experiences as a homeless individual, and I wrote about it in my hub "Homeless in a Resort Hotel".
There seems to be a camaraderie among the homeless, and if you get involved and communicate with them, you would be surprised at the stories they can tell you about how they got that way.
I believe we must know our own hearts in order to decide to give or not. Whether we will solve the person's problem for a long period time is not the matter, nor the state of their person or appearance. If we have something to give to help someone else, and we want to give it, we should. Do not complicate caring with social rights and wrongs, or analytical conclusions of the reality or depth of a person's needs. Sometimes just a smile can brighten a person's day, and if they use the money for something you don't agree with, that doesn't matter. What matters is that you did what your heart wanted, and you can go home and feel good about it.
It depends. Some people are genuine but there are many who are just lazy. I've stopped helping the regulars especially if they smoke and drink.
If you have the money to buy cigarettes and liquor then there's no point in helping you.
I do always empty my pockets for them (not my wallet). That would be, the change (in my pocket), anything from about 50 cents to 2 dollars usually. I generally do not have food in my car, yet if I do I would share some... I never judge them; yet I do tell them that this is from God, not me (then I repeat to myself, I am merely the instrument...).
Sometimes, sometimes not. I always go with my gut feelings to whether or not to do it. It is heartwrenching but a lot of times you just have to walk by because you get a creepy feeling or you do not have anything to give. I would give food far more often than money.
Yes, I would help the less unfortunate. You never know if you are entertaining Angels unaware. You don't know if they have small children in a hotel and possibly be broken down and will be on there way to home. You do not know if these people are holding signs because there is a multiple families paying rent somewhere. Anyway know one really knows for sure what the circumstances are with those that hold up signs asking for your help. Yes, I will help them because I know what it is like to be hungry.
If I have it at the moment yes I will give.. I have had people come up to me on the streets asking and I give. I know some people think they could be using it for smokes or drinking. But who am I to sit in judgement of what they do..if they used if for other than eating food than it's not up to me to judge them God will do that..only thing I am to do is give.
I have given money to people whom has asked, but it was my inner man telling me at the time to do it..I dont do it all the time, but hey we could be in that same situation one day...Also we have to use common sense here....everybody begging is not in need...I think that it is easy to detect...
I use to give any change I had at the time, but recently you see someone at every corner asking for money. So I no longer give but instead contribute to a charity like St. Jude or Special Olympics.
I would definitely offer them help I have no right to judge them if a person is asking for food the least I can do is offer them some.
If He's Is Wearing A Branded Watch And dresse Worth 50$
I may Not..!!
I believe nobody is entitled to be a beggar but for the economy.i will give the beggar depending on how useful it is to me and to the beggar .afterall no one knows whether the beggar will turn to b our helper someday
I agree with you that the economy is tough today. If I saw someone begging for food or money, I would be willing to spend five to ten dollars at the nearest dollar menu for them. I would not feel comfortable giving them money because I have seen to many loved ones addicted to things that cause them to have skewed judgement. I would be afraid I was enabling something harmful to them. But if I could show them a kind gesture and put warm food in their belly, I would gladly do it.
Nope. If they want food there are homeless shelters that I help pay to support, if they ask for money I don't give it to them. Food they can't use as money to buy drugs or alcohol.
No. While some people are genuinely homeless, others simply prefer to beg for money rather than work. Giving homeless people money actually isn't helping, anyway, it's just perpetuating the cycle.
by Luciendasky 12 years ago
With the recession going on, I have noticed several new cardboard signs asking for food, money or gas. How do you distinguish the real from the fake, and what should you do to help them?
by Eaglekiwi 13 years ago
See here's the thing.Begging for money even a dollar is not as common from where I come from ( yes occasionally) but its laughed at or openly scorned at so for whatever reason its just not common.I have lived in the USA for 5 months now ,and been approached so many times mostly young guys asking...
by LaDena Campbell 9 years ago
I saw the police shooing the homeless away from a shopping center where they were asking for money..Driving through a shopping center parking lot today, I noticed three or four people holding signs begging for money. A few minutes later I saw the police shooing them away. How do you feel about this?
by Diana Grant 10 years ago
Would you buy cigarettes or alcohol for someone dying of a smoke or alcohol-related disease?If someone is completely bed-ridden and immobilised, would you succumb to their desperate pleas to shop for cigarettes or booze, if they quite clearly have only days or weeks to live? Would you feel that it...
by dashingscorpio 6 years ago
Have you ever given a homeless person on the street any money?If the answer is yes: Is it something you frequently do or rarely ever do? If it's rarely can you remember what the circumstances were that caused you to make an "exception". If you have never given a homeless person a single...
by Mike Pugh 9 years ago
Would you help a person who was starving today?If you seen a homeless person on the ground would you help him or her up onto their feet, would you create a shelter if you had the money to do so for them, would you feed the hungry if you we're in a position to do so. Pondering questions, and if...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|