Should illegal aliens be given path to citizenship?
Some of them cross the border and others overstayed their visa. What is your opinion about this?
They should only be allowed citizenship if they go through the proper channels. Crossing the border in the middle of the night is not the proper channel.
As a practical matter, although I have no interest in rewarding people for breaking the law, it is impossible to deport all the illegals in the US. The problem is too far gone for that. I would prefer to see those who have committed additonal crimes aggressively deported. Any pathway needs to be in the back of the line behind those like my sister in-law who came here legally from Columbia. But I have no interest in granting anyone...anything...until we secure our southern border. We have a serious problem with violence from drug cartels spilling in to US towns. Additionally we have people sneak across the border to deliver a child and make them impossible to ever deport, while they drain an already drained social services system. Considering that most Mexicans are fleeing Mexico because of the povery and violent drug cartels, then you would hope they would understand the rationale for protecting our safety and soverigenty from what they themselves are fearful of. Once that is done, then we can talk about a practical way to make them all legal Americans.
The notion that we can't secure our own border is ridiculous. If we can secure the DMZ for 50 years, we can do the same with our southern borders if we wanted to. And if a similiar problem deveoped on the northern border, we could do the same as well. The only reason we don't is politicians want new voters to give away things to and ensure their political future.
In my opinion, no. Illegal aliens getting a ticket into this country is an insult to all the people who arduously came here legally, followed all the rules, and worked hard for it. They're the ones who deserve to be a citizen.
I think that it should be made easier to become a citizen, and that should encourage people to do it the right way. I agree with LandmarkWealth that there are way too many illegal immigrants to deport all of them. The best thing to do is to make tighter border security, and make it easier to become a citizen, thus forcing them to do it the right way.
I agree, only if they go through proper steps. Illegally, we lose money and jobs as a country. People fail to realize that these sort of things, as minor as they may seem to others, effect us as a country tremendously. The only way things can get easier, is if as a country we get better. More people should look at the whole picture and not just one thing.
What is never discussed, when it comes to illegals, is the inordinate amount of burden placed on social services (medicaid, SS, food stamps, etc). They pay no taxes (contrary to their apologists) and are largely illiterate. The majority have little to no education. So, any low-skilled jobs that Americans had ordinarily done would be gone. I refuse to accept that illegals only do jobs Americans won't do. It is nonsense (Hormel Company in Nebraska is one example as Americans lined around the company after ICE arrested numerous illegals). They should not be given a path to citizenship. It is an insult to the people who waited for years and did things the right way. I also do not accept you can't deport 12 million illegals. Take away the jobs magnet, the free social services and they will leave.
We can not take care of the indigent of the world. We can't even take care of ourselves any longer.
Personally, i don't believe we should reward illegals. They have already shown a disregard for our laws by being in this country illegally. I think they should be deported. However, realistically, we will never have the logistics to locate and deport them all. I think giving them a path to legalization (note, different from citizenship) that involves a long term work visa, along with paying fines is the way to go. That way they are registered and documented and we know who they are and where they are. I just completed a hub over this issue for those looking for a much longer answer to our immigration problems.
Forget about the path and just give them citizenship. When we stop treating them as invaders we will find that they are a valuable contribution to the country. If we want to deport people, I say we start with bigots and racists.
I don't like the idea of deportation. They do improve small business, because they work for so cheap, but they still should be forced to do it the right way. That's how I see it, you can check out my first comment, to see my opinion on the matter.
Tell that the farmers families and border patrol's families who have lost their lives to this epidemic of illegal aliens crossing the border with drugs. I'm sure they want to be contributing members of society. Oh wait, they already are, drugs.
And we need to deport fools and traitors right along with these illegals for being blind as bats. Illegals take advantage, they see something free and they go for it. I would rather focus on the 23 million unmeployed Americans and LEGAL residents.
Its not that they don't contribute, its the fact they have shown a complete disregard to our laws by coming over illegally. Also, a lot of them do not want citizenship, they just want to earn money so they can send it back home.
They aren't involved in as much criminal activity as you might think. The amount of illegal Mexican immigrants that there are in this country is almost unfathomable. You see them all the time working for landscapers, renovators, contractors, etc.
We just went through the greatest recession since the great depression and you want to deport your fellow Americans because they cannot find a job? What about disabled veterans who need all of these entitlements to live?
They seem to think that coming illegally is the fastest and easiest way to come over. We need to make it easier to become a citizen, and harder to come over illegally. No matter what action we take, we can't deport them all. It doesn't make sense.
Deport bigots and racist...Interesting thought, how will we measure that? Since 95% of Blacks voted for Obama, a far higher percentage than whites voting for Romney, shall we conclude racial predjudice was a factor? How easy it is to scream racism
It is very easy for people to vote for someone of their own race. What takes some character, is to do what a lot of the white people did, in voting for Obama. Sure, that might not have been a good decision, with what he has done in office.
The point is clearly that such suggestions of determing who is racist is arbitrary and facist like. I see such a voting skew as clearly racially biased with such a statistical skew. While he may not. Making his thought upsurd in a free nation.
I was being intentionally prickish to make the point that deporting human beings is just plain mean. I wouldn't deport anyone. As for violence, that's a separate issue: drugs. Could solve overnight with legalization.
Yes, you can solve a lot of the drug problem by being stricter on it. You can't deport people. Not only is it mean, but we're not a third world country, we're America, and supposed to be a role model for the world.
There is nothing mean about deporting people who intentionally violate the law. It is just simply not practical to do it. There will never be the man power to pull it off without instituting a total policed state.
In terms of morality and law-breaking, I'll take a person crossing the border to provide for their family over someone who smacks their spouse occasionally or drives while intoxicated. Even so, I see no reason to treat anyone like cattle.
I don't disagree...But without a border that is enforced we have only chaos and a lack of sovereignty. There is then no point to maintain a separate nation. Not to mention the potential for terrorist to use the lack of border security against us.
Deporting someone is not mean It a punishment for breaking the law. Just like throwing other criminals in jail is not mean, it a punishment. It doesn't make sense to use our money to provide for the illegals by putting them in jail, so we deport them
The problem is neither is economically feasible. We can secure the border to stop the unregulated influx in the future. But we can't round up millions of people. There just isn't the man power.
It depends on what planet they're from, how well they're dressed (Orion residents have star-studded belts), do they have a fancy space ship that can do all kinds of entertaining aeronautics, and do they have some beautiful beads of unusual gems for bribing the right officials?
by Mikel G Roberts 6 years ago
My opinion is no, we should not.The problems of failed or "third world" countries have resulted in millions of people fleeing those countries to steal the better life the people of other non third world countries have. The United States is one of those countries. We have allowed these...
by MikeNV 10 years ago
$10 Billion per month to spend in Afghanistan per month "fighting terrorists". How many people know the cost of a Gallon of fuel to the military in Afghanistan is $13 per Gallon?30,000 AMERICAN TROOPS on the South Korea/North Korea Border.And the OBAMA ADMINISTRATION REFUSES to...
by Eric Dierker 7 years ago
I cannot find a group that supports illegal immigration. Yet we cannot stop it. Now that is pathetic. So we must conclude that without saying it, some - many in America support it and do what they can to stop control of it. It would seem that this should be a target for midterm elections. Who does...
by G. Diane Nelson Trotter 5 years ago
Some people say President Obama told illegal aliens they can vote. It is reported that 3,000,000 did just that in California. What about Arizona? What about Florida? How can that happen? The Governor of North Carolina is suspicious about the vote that took him out of...
by Kathryn L Hill 3 years ago
Trump mentioned that border control and the building of a wall is a crucial matter.Yes, he is right.It is a matter of justice. The nation does not owe the citizens of other countries ANYTHING. On the contrary it owes it's citizens EVERYTHING. And illegals are TAKING everything:Resources, tax money,...
by tobey100 11 years ago
Yesterday the President of Mexico addressed a joint session of Congress and took the opportunity to not only point the finger of blame at America for Mexico's current out of control drug wars but to castigate the sovereign State of Arizona for its audacity to enforce Federal Immigration Law at the...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|