How do we let HP know about Anti-religious verbal extremists writing toxic hubs?
There are a number of Hub authors writing specifically only Anti-religious extremist hubs. Technically this is "anti religious trolling". How can we ban them? Should there be a limit on the number of Anti-religious extremist hubs for any one individual? For example, if a person has ten hubs and 50% or more are anti-religious should this be the definition of trolling on HP?
America = Free Speech
Religion is not meaningful to everyone
Would you be saying the same if a writer wrote all Christian Hubs?
I am responding to the same theme on Q&A re religion. We need to get away from religion as solely "right wing USA Christian". All indigenous cultures' identities are part of their religion. To try to destroy them is cultural genocide.
You seem to have the same crusader type of answer for everyone who responds. If a person is against organized religion, then they are entitled to write about it in any way they choose as many times as they want to.
If you check HP rules this is not technically true if the hubs contain nothing but vilification. There are specific rules stopping anti religious or other trolling
So don't read them - are you afraid someone else's opinion might be read before yours?
I often don't read them unless I feel I can add logically to the debate. I'm not interested in contests about "who's on first " etc
Do you have samples or links to these hubs?
I have found the Christian Right to be quite extreme on HP. Not sure where you draw the line on creative expression.
We need to get away from stereotyping religion as "right wing USA". There are many positive examples of Indigenous religions, Buddhism, etc. Stereotyping is related to bigotry, hate speech and religious intolerance.
Very true, point taken. I used it as the most common example of extremist views here on HP. I have not seen examples of extreme Buddhism or Hinduism here. Just wanted to be clear.
Thanks. My point is valid when not being misrepresented by as usual a majority of online atheists as seen here. Let them extol atheism to their hearts content. Why constant anti religious hubbers are tolerated by HP is another question.
Maybe it's my ability to think laterally & see more than one point to topics. I've seen a plethora of bible quoting hubs that were in effect insulting atheists, also Buddhists and Hindus. I thought HP was taken over by a church at one point.
http://hubpages.com/religion-philosophy … -Hypocrisy
Here is my hub on atheism which Defends ethical atheism!
Yes I've seen unkind remarks about atheists (free speech ) but not continuous numerous repeated hub themes
You keep going on about these hubs but have not provided a link to anyone's bar your own. Link a hub or hubber that does what you think they're doing, and let us have a look - may even help by reporting it if it's violated TOS etc.
Maybe this is a way for people to read HER thread..,.,sounds hypocritical
It's certainly against hub rules to name individuals. We all know them anyway as individuals who focus on solely anti religious hubs. Do you just hit me with a flower?
Report them in the same way you would any other Hub that breaches TOS for Hubpages.
If it's merely that it goes against what you believe, and in countering your argument has annoyed you - then Hubpages will see that, and leave it.
If it's merely that they are posting "trolling' type hubs, then Hubpages would see this, and if it breaches TOS - they will remove.
I would say this for both sides of the equation - if it's designed to be nasty, personal insults etc - then I'd report it be it a Christian's hubs towards Atheists, or vice versa.
Difference makes the world go round. People are never going to agree, and we have to look at whether it's offending it us because we don't agree with it, or it's genuinely trying to be offensive. And, most people would admit that sometimes that distinction is a difficult one to make
You comment that you were following the theme of another question on Q+A - the question you are referring to is referring to a Hubber who has recently been banned from Q+A briefly for abusive comments, personal insults, and technically harassment. Most people couldn't care less what faith this hubber is - its their behaviour thats the problem.
But hey - interesting question. The meme is...silly, but isn't that the point?
I get all the religious hubs. There is not one hubber solely doing anti atheist hubs. On the reverse side there are dozens of solely anti religious hubbers! There needs to be a rule against solely anti religious hubbers.
Can we also get a rule against solely religious hubbers? This is supposed to be a community of writers, not of people who copy and past bible verses all the time.
It's not about that it's about specifically and persistent anti religious hubs. There are no persistently anti atheist hubbers only religious people writing religiously hubs about religion.
Ah, but is it merely because you disagree with them Oz, or are they actually offensive? Because if it's the first - u can't ban, if it's the 2nd - report. Surprised u haven't already if they are the 2nd, so I'm gathering they're the 1st.
Repeated online anti religious or other types of trolling are regularly banned or punished. That's common knowledge. I'm claiming there is one particular group which is injecting unecessary venom into the HP community as logical analysis shows.
The provide a link to the hubs or hubbers. Report them yourself. It's terribly simple. HP will delete if violates. If not deleted, not violating. if it's just because you disagree that its venomous they'll see that 2. Goes 4 religious hubs doing same
It's against hub rules to name names. The reason more hubs aren't deleted is another question ("fools walk where angels fear to tread"....proverb)
Then report - and it will be judged as to whether you just offended cause you disagree, or whether it's actually offensive and against TOS.
You shouldn't be focused on banning someone's writing because you disagree with it. How would you feel if the atheists were attempting to have religious writing banned?
I'm sure there are some who'd like to see religious writing banned, but banning writing about a belief system isn't going to happen on this website. What should be of concern to you, if you wish to be a good member of this website is ...bad writing. That's it, if the page is short, ugly, poorly written, obviously spam - THAT is the writing you should be concerned with getting off this website.
Hubpages can't limit freedom of speech. Just because you disagree with what someone is saying, doesn't mean they can't say it.
If us atheists tried to ban religious people from making what we deem "stupid" hubs, I bet you wouldn't be so happy, now would you?
It's not about "stupid" religious hubs and you know it. It's about persistent anti religious trolling hubs. Huge difference. Religious hubs are just about religion not persistent anti atheist hubs.
Oz, your attempts to label anti-theist hubs as "trolling" only reveal the hatred you have for them. You don't like the subject matter so you mislabel it in order to degrade it. You should really get a grip.
think about it: it's fine with hub rules if people extol the virtues of atheism; it's not fine to denigrate others as that's not simply extolling atheist virtues. It's against HP rules.
Writing against a belief system is not against HP rules.
http://hubpages.com/religion-philosophy … -Hypocrisy
Here is a link to my hub on atheism which Defends ethical atheism!
This is only my third Hub. Read my other two and get back to me.
I get what you're saying, but people are free to write about whatever they want on their hub page. Writing ten million hubs on the same topic is not trolling because it is your page. Just avoid them like the plague, as much as you love to hate them.
Yes we can write a million hubs on cakes or judo etc. Religious people generally sing the praises of their beliefs. If an atheist wrote a million hubs singing the praises of Atheism that's fine but they don't do that.
YES!! For once, something that me and Lolita can agree on!
http://hubpages.com/religion-philosophy … -Hypocrisy
For the record here is link to my hub on atheism Defending ethical atheism! Ethical atheism does not vilify religions it merely promotes atheism.
Atheism is the lack of a belief in god. In promoting atheism, you are telling people to NOT belive in god. Any reason we could possibly use, any fallacy we could point out, any way promote atheism would require some degree of religious vilification.
I don't think banning is the solution. I agree it's ridiculous, but you gotta realize that it's just their childish nature coming out in writing form. They feel the need to insult religion because...? They like to insult people for no reason? Don't let it wear down on you, it's just people seeking attention.
Best answer so far!
The battle invigorates me and I can add significantly to the debate. Constant anti religious hubs by a few are injecting enormous amounts of venom into HP.
If you don't like the venom, don't touch the snake! Just because it's on the website, doesn't mean that you need to read it!
I often don't but if I feel I can add to the debate I enter it. It's the good fight like Frodo against the Orcs: the perennial battle between right and wrong.
by Cheri Hutson3 years ago
I'm just wondering... I've only been on HubPages a few short weeks, but I've noticed from the Forums and the Religious section that it seems like the majority of people on here seem to be anti-Christian. I just recently...
by Aman Ullah Ghazi2 months ago
Need detailed and honest explaination.
by Patrick Bernauw9 years ago
For example: a Hub about Obama being the AntiChrist? (Cause his name rhymes with Osama!) Do we have to flag these Hubs? (And see the sick joke starting elsewhere all over again.) Are these Hubs also partly responsible...
by Dan W Miller2 years ago
Why are these trolling HubPages members with no hubs written even allowed to stay on the site?So many say rude comments and give know-it-all "advice" yet don't even have ONE hub written. Like this person...
by Thomas Swan5 years ago
Is hubpages in danger of being over-run by writers from India who can't write proper English? I went to a hubpages question yesterday, and half the answers were from Indian hubbers who didn't understand the question but...
by Grace Marguerite Williams5 years ago
Spiritualists In The United States - WE HAVE THE RIGHTS TO OUR BELIEFSPeople who believe in the non-traditional spiritualities and philosophies are oftentimes ostracized by the prevailing religious majority. ...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.