Nicholas D. Kristof
Our Bannana Repurblic
In my reporting, I regularly travel to banana republics notorious for their inequality. In some of these plutocracies, the richest 1 percent of the population gobbles up 20 percent of the national pie.
But guess what? You no longer need to travel to distant and dangerous countries to observe such rapacious inequality. We now have it right here at home — and in the aftermath of Tuesday’s election, it may get worse.
The richest 1 percent of Americans now take home almost 24 percent of income, up from almost 9 percent in 1976. As Timothy Noah of Slate noted in an excellent series on inequality, the United States now arguably has a more unequal distribution of wealth than traditional banana republics like Nicaragua, Venezuela and Guyana.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/07/opini … ef=opinion
The NY Times lost credibility a long time ago. That is why they are on financial life support.
Yeah, you sing it brother.
The only people who make any sense today are Fox and Friends. I love that gang - they are so smart and funny and the way they bash the Democrats is beyond fair when you consider the damage that the pinko, commie atheists who run that party wreak upon us.
Murdoch should buy that rag and fire all them commies.
Can I join? I'm ready, I've already got my pants down.
Are you willing to be lobotomized?
We have an instructional video that can let you do this at home using a rented nail gun. Very inexpensive and very helpful when it is time for you to start passing on Tea Party email about Bama.
I did myself last week and can now watch Fox News without showing any emotion at all.
I miss smiling, though.
I find a bottle of whisky, a pile of Murdoch newspapers and a subliminal message "it's all true you know" is not quite as speedy but a little less painful than the nail gun and doesn't scare those good folk who live in fear of a terrorist attack.
My friend doubted the wisdom of my actions but a good slap soon convinced her she was dealing with a superior intellect.
A truthy dominant male is admirable!
My wife, not having much personality of her own anyway, was always willing to live in my shadow, but she was mouthier when we were liberals.
I'd have her bring me a beer right nowiuf we had any. Not because I want one, but just to burn the lesson in. I thought I saw a little flash of defiance in her eyes and need to deal with that right away. I know some folks in other threads I can ask for advice.
Well, for heavens sake man, send her out for some beer for you. Don't let her think you don't need her help, the little women need to feel important. If she hasn't got any money you can lend her some at a competitive rate of interest can't you?
I know. I often try to think of ways I can help the little people feel better about themselves. It is so little skin off my nose - a kind word, no matter how insincere, a paternal pat on the head, these are small things to me that can mean so much to them.
some advice from a submissive woman, let her wear shoes on special occasions. Just not too much or she will think she can make decisions on her own.
I don't take advice from woman, missy.
Now if you had an Eagle avatar, or were draped in a flag, or were standing in front of a giant Lucite cross, well, that might be different. But as it is, no.
Good Idea.People would actually start reading that catbox liner again.
We are a Banana Democracy not a republic, didn't you get the email from Bill O'Liely and the Newsmax Morons? The mob has the right to stay just as poor and as dumb as they desire.
Is it possible to go thru 16 years of education and still not have a clue? Of course it is, just do it like the do it in the south, Repeat the 8th grade 8 times and hope you at least learn to read a Hardee's drive thru menu the last time thru. I know that only adds up to 15 years of education but I assumed that everyone knew repeating 1st grade is mandatory down here. It takes 2 years to transform grunts into basic words.
MMm. I lived on Hardees for a whole month once.
What does that have to do with educating?
Besides, I resent your implication. I only spent eleven years in school and I slept through a lot of it.
Who knew that I was molding myself to be a Tea Party member? It just proves that there really is a Plan.
One is required to memorize the words on a Hardee's menu and not simply the numbers. Sometimes they change what comes on the #4 combo just to keep America on their toes. TRue story...In the 11th grade here in SC I signed up for an extra credit reading course due to my love of books. I was a little suprised to discover that this class was a last ditch effort to teach student how to read. That they had made it to the 11th grade with out this skill wasn't shocking to anyone. It took me a week to get transfered out of that class and in that time I learned how to balance a check book and do basic math. Homework was easy as most couldn't read or write so there was none. South Carolina routinely handed out high school diplomas for good behaivior in the 70's. They were training textile workers and they didn't want them to be too smart for their own good, dontcha know! It sure as hell worked as planned. (Last minute attempt to comment on the plan you hinted at)
If US is not a banana republic yet, it will soon be.
what is even more surprising to me is that people actually vote for them to have more. it's the strategy the right has used by saying it's for god, freedom and liberty. the people trust them and think that if it's for god then it must be right and they cut their own throats and ours too. it's crazy!
Well you see - us newly converted know that it will all end soon and I can see now why the sooner the better. I will, of course, be one of the chosen few who will get everything - so lets go bomb someone quickly, sell more arms around the world and polish up that nuclear trigger !!
But there is nothing we can do because taxing the rich would be so unfair, communistic, socialistic, obamaistic, atheistic and makes no sense whatsoever.
Why don't you just move to Cuba then ya damn hippie?
(I'm filling in for the church lady this morning)
and take "Hussein" with you!
No, no, I have converted. I now have seen the light I am a TEA PARTY man from now on. Furthermore, I have put my woman in her place and let her know who is in charge. I have joined an Evangelical church and love professional sports because that's what is really important.
I understand now that business should decide what I need because they must be smarter than I am - how would they have made their billions otherwise?
I love it, I do not have to think because Fox News tells me my opinions. I know I'll be able to get a job in my golden years if we can just destroy the Democrats, I am so looking forward to being a wage slave!
I hope you will join me, Ron. If we can convert just a few others, I think we can get them all to roll over - even the poor deluded man who started this by posting that vile, lying link.
Hey, I liked the Church Lady. She was a riot.
And as a business school classmate of mine said wrt classroom discussion of a proposal for regulating business or the economy: "That would be like throwing sand into the mechanism of a fine Rolex watch!!"
Oh, Ralph, you just don't get it.
For example, right this very moment, if Obama hadn't killed the Bush tax cuts ten years ago when he first took office, we wouldn't have high unemployment now because the filthy rich would be investing in our economy and making America strong.
It is failed socialist policies that created all of the evils we face now. Instead of trying to weasel out of Iraq, we should be using it as a base to attack Iran - that's how you get the economy moving in the right direction at almost no additional cost!
Health care? We need more profits for doctors and drug companies. If we double their profits, a small percentage can be put back into research - as long as you don't tax it away! Government bureaucrats shouldn't be making decisions about my health - I want private enterprise bureaucrats making those decisions because they will decide based on PROFITS, not some commie idea of what makes sense.
People like you are responsible, Ralph. Join me in my new found freedom from thought! Repent your ways!
For the ones who get it, sarcasm is the best way to put things into perspective
Pcunix that is a wonderful idea! (Invading Iran from Iraq.)
Think of the fuel and transportation savings! I thought it was a stroke of genius myself. I have decided to join a good fundamentalist church and change my ways too.
Everything will be wonderful now that government proposals are automatically blocked before you even have to worry about them.
I am moving to America to enjoy the good life you have coming with the help of the tea party.
What America needs is more guns, more churches and less money for the poor.
It's the American way!
WOW - PCUnix is the king !! I am completely converted in one thread - yes, I can see why you are also attracted Earnest. Why isn't there a white tea party for me to join right away !
Only in my home state. Here the fools voted Democratic. Well, I did too, but that was before my lobotomy. My wife voted Blue also, but I have asserted my Male Dominance and she promised to vote as I say next tine. Our kids are more of a problem - their husbands are not helping me convert them to sanity.
Where can I get an appropriate avatar? Now that I am lobotomized Tea Party, I want something that screams that to everyone. I'm thinking of an eagle draped in a flag with his claws crushing a liberal - do you know where I might find something like that? I want people to KNOW who I am!
Oh I think you already possess the appropriate avatar.
No, that's the old weak liberal me. It simply won't do for my new brain rearrangement.
That clown was all about equality, fairness, womens rights, gay rights and important government services. I now realize that admiring billionaires is what I should be doing, then, when my money runs out, I should crawl away and die as quietly as possible. It's what Big Business needs from me and I will do my part.
My only regret is that I realized all this so late in life. Is it possible to get box sets of Fox and Friends on DVD? I missed so much truthiness.
You should just watch my Alex Jones videos hub.
Being an ignorant former liberal, I have no idea who that is, but if you recommend it, I am all over it.
Gosh, some of the awful things I used to think about your opinions. I feel so ashamed. It's a good thing the threat of banning kept me from saying them because then they'd be on record forever and our now mutual enemies could use my own words to undermine what I hope will be a deep and lasting friendship.
I am going to go Friend you on Facebook right now! Are you on Twitter too?
I was so hoping that would be an Alex Jones video. I looked him up on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Jones_(radio_host) and he sounds wonderful!
Wait. Was that an Alex Jones video?
Are you sure? Because I read that Wikipedia article very carefully (well, I don't read as well as I used to - my brain takes longer to comprehensiate) and it sure sounds like it could be an Alex Jones video.
Or.. No.. Could it be you? Maybe around April 15th earlier this year?
It was a Thursday.
Back to the avatar. Now that we are so close, I don't want to use an Eagle. I'm thinking Statue of Liberty wearing a big old flag and a monstrous silver cross, stomping on a whole pile of liberals. I like the subtle symbolism, don't you?
i can't help but notice that no wingnuts even attempt to refute the facts of the op 24 percent of the national income goes to the top one percent by population.
Yeah. I hate it when these egg head liberals use mathematication to try to confuserate us.
I slept through all that dumb stuff too. What the heck is a percent anyway? Must be less than a penny, so 24 of them can't be much.
Remember, liars always figure something out.
Yeah, consider the source was that bleeding heart Kristof in the NYTimes who's always whining about 13-year-old being sold into prostitution by their starving parents.
First, as one of my new wing men pointed out, the NYT is a commie, liberal rag that they have to give away and even then nobody really reads it.
Second, concentration of wealth is good because it helps the rich create JOBS. We need them to have even more money if we want to maintain the high employment levels we have now.
Did you know that, on average, every bank employee who got a million dollar or more bonus last year employs 3.6 illegal aliens? That's the kind of feet on the ground stuff that makes our country strong.
Don't forget, relatively speaking, those are the "poor" rich folk. The ones with the real Money employ many more.
Hey!!!....Oh, never mind. I thought Banana Republic was a store in the mall.
It is. And that's why we need the rich to have more money so there can be more stores in the mall.
Maybe you can get a job. Maybe you will even get a discount!
Life is good when there are bananas!
I love the new way to contract "You are". It is so economical.
I have noticed that many conservatives are wasteful of "O"'s though. When one of us says 'Your loosing your mind", I feel lime the savings in the contraction have been negatorated by the extra O.
Just my opinion, and my lobotomy was done at home so that could be the reason.
She's a cutie. Did someone just say "Bamacare" to her? Is that why she is sticking her tongue out?
It is good to teach them young. I ruined my kids.. raised 'em as liberals. We regret that now. Wait - I forgot to tell my wife she did a bad job raising the kids. It was mostly her fault.
I really love the U.S, but whether liberals or republicans run it, it doesn't matter because its more of the same. People keep wanting change and can't find it with these 2 parties.
The buck does not stop at the rich
the rich spend their money they hire maids lawn guys and pool boys
they buy boats appliances furniture and what not .they build houses . they redistribute wealth and put people to work food on the table for family's.
But? But, isnt this what the rich do with their ill begotten gains?
No - Here's what you can do with ill-gotten gains.
After you got fired as CEO - I mean, resigned voluntarily - you move from California to Florida with your loot. Though you have no experience with politics or Florida, you spend 70 million dollars to buy the governor's mansion - I mean, blanket the airwaves with lies - I mean, run a spirited campaign.
So what happened in CA? Governor Rick Scott was CEO of Columbia/HCA, the company was hit with 1.7 BILLION in fines for Medicare fraud and 14 felony charges associated. That's right, the man claimed he 'took responsibility' for what happened at a company he ran who systematically bilked the federal government for millions and millions while he was at the helm.
And he's promised to run the state of Florida like he ran Columbia/HCA. And I believe him.
Doug, Doug, Doug.
One man's fraud is anothers creative descriptions. It's different in business - you do what needs to be done and pray for forgiveness later. Sure, people get hurt, but money makes them easy to forget,
The nice thing is that if you make enough money you can usually buy your way out of almost any accounting discrepancy.
Well, Rick Scott has decided to eliminate the midddleman (crooked politican) and go directly into the whoresale - I mean wholesale business of selling government.
Instead of the discrete 'For Sale - Lobbyists Inquire Within" Rick has ordered a neon sign for the front of the Governor's Mansion. 'FOR SALE - ALL OF FLORIDA - Special Discounts For Republicans and other Felons".
But more money would more effectively get to those who need it if it was directly given to them rather than be filtered through and handed down when the rich were done with it.
And do you really want your country to have an economy based on pool boys and linen maids?
How do you propose to hand out wealth that belongs to the one who created? Would that be to build a giant bureaucratic government that will absorb nearly 80% of every dollar collected in taxes before throwing crumbs at the maid and the pool boy. Or is it too much work to teach, preach, encourage personal, individual moral conduct? It is so much easier to compel whether by law(which always carries the threat of force) or by actual force property out of the hands of one man so it can be used as you would want it used.
It a treacherous course one chooses when one chooses to take what does not belong to them and then use it as they see fit. Where does the taking stop and how much force will be employed in the taking?
I'm assuming an existing system of taxation and the choice between assisting those at the bottom of the pile by direct tax cuts, or by tax cuts to those at the top of the pile and expecting them to trickle down and assist those at the bottom.
I'd then broaden out to ask how often the wealth posseccesed by somebody was actually created by them? Using Bill Gates again, for no other reason than an easily found name, how much of his wealth did he actually create and how much did he gather by taxing people?
Why would a government that absorbed 80% be any worse than anybody else absorbing 80% before it reached its target?
Not only that, but Billy Boy did it by the time honored methods of bullying resellers and restricting competitors, copying intellectual property and other "business as usual" tactics.
As our Dem governor candidate said, "We're tired of being trickled on." Unfortunately, he was defeated along with nearly all the other Dem candidates in Michigan.
You mean like that guy with a bleeding heart for the poor who's is building a 27-story billion dollar house on top of the slums of Mumbai?
You are quite wrong Ralph - you want to criticise that poor guy who is essential for hte economy of the Mumbai slums - building his house where everyone can look up to it is a glowing example to all those idle people to get off their rear end and work hard to all become millionaires like him. Then India will have millions and millions of millionaires and no more problems.
You have a point there, China Man. It will act as a beacon of hope to the rag pickers, giving them something to strive for. Just like those guys at Goldman Sachs and CitiGroup whose hard-earned success makes me get up earlier every morning. That's what made this country great. If it worked here, why not in Mumbai?
Absolutely, and when the whingeing Liberals get out of the way in areica then everyone can own big pieces of that wunnerful country. When everyone owns a big ranch like that nice Mr Bush then we can all be President and things will get better without that man (who isn't white you know) n that pure crystal white house that is a beacon of hope to all the worlds poor and oppressed. Then they can all get a big piece of America for themselves - Live the dream !
So if there is a forced redistribution of wealth what benefit will that be? We have witnessed the horror of forced redistribution all through the last century and into this one. So are we doomed either to become Nicaragua or are we doomed to become Zimbabwe or The Soviet Union? Not a cheerful prospect either way. As for some nebulous middle way, the economies of Western Europe have enjoyed their own little heaven in stagnation, debt, declining job creation to the point that they are on the verge of collapse or wrenching reform. So seems to me that we are either going to continue progress or decline into darkness - wow thanks for sending my mind in this direction on a lovely Sunday afternoon.
There has been no "forced distribution of wealth." The distribution has been going the other way, i.e., the rich have been getting vastly richer. The issue is how much of this distribution can the country stand without riots in the streets?
And what's wrong with riots in the streets? All those extra sales of rubber bullets and tear glass. Work for glaziers and builders. Road resurfacing, lots more customers for health care and pharmaceutics.
Good countrywide riots could be just the economic stimulus the US needs to sort its financial affairs.
The problem is not the 1% the problem is the remaining 99% too many of whom either do not or will not do what it takes to transform themselves into money making dynomoes. Maybe the 1% did inherant their wealth, but what they did was to make money work for them and create greater wealth - now why can't the other poeple take that cue and think of how to make what they have work for them and create a better life for them.
It is not that hard it is done every day.
I disagree. The problem is the gvt policies that favor the 1% over the 99%.
When a man making 3 mil a year pays less tax than a school teacher making $65,000...something is wrong, very wrong!
It's already wealth distribution. It all goes to the top!
maids and people that clean pools have full lives prosperous business and are important
"GOP: NO COMPROMISE ON BUSH TAX CUTS"
There is your answer. 60% of deficit will NOT be adressed by the THUGLICANS.
All that free money given to Uber rich people borrowed from China....oh well.
Baggers???? Will you protest?
Now let poor little ole me geuss where they WILL cut....any geusses?
You who voted them in have put Fascists back in power. IMHO
That darned fascist/socialist paradigm.
Of course the most famous fascists were the Social Democrats now weren't they?
"When Fascism comes to America, it will come carrying a cross, and wrapped in the flag."
Socialism+Gvt=better lives for all people
"America will never be Socialist, as Corporations don't give a crap about the lives of human beings."
It all starts with the younger generation.
The face of the rising Social democrats.
Video: Paul Lectures Bernanke -- U.S. Moving Towards Fascism
"History proves many things if you are interested in learning those lessons. Fascism took many years to complete it's grip in places like 1930s Italy. They brainwashed a majority over years of repeating lies and falsehoods. They gradually took over the media. It's all very tenacious and slow. But it's all very profitable to the very few who are powerful and rich."
by captain planet 8 years ago
What If you were superman?
by Susan Reid 6 years ago
A new poll finds that half of all Americans think the Republicans are purposefully sabotaging the economy to keep Obama from getting a second term.Which means a full 50% of Americans do not believe this.Be afraid. Be very afraid. Be especially if you find yourself facing a jury anytime...
by fishskinfreak2008 7 years ago
Web-site/URL: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100909/ap_ … _electionsUltimately, this is what causes people to lose their jobs and therefore HEALTHCARE, Obama's top domestic priority
by Doug Hughes 7 years ago
"..._Worst of all, this is a vision that says even though America can't afford to invest in education or clean energy; even though we can't afford to care for seniors and poor children, we can somehow afford more than $1 trillion in new tax breaks for the wealthy. Think about it. In the last...
by Josak 4 years ago
Having lost the national debate on social issues, abortion, same sex marriage etc. the right has turned to the economy as it's saviors claiming that they can run economies better. Let us examine this historically.As we can see the fact is that conservative governments provide fewer jobs, less...
by Amie Warren 7 years ago
I'm serious. If you didn't grow up in the south, you have no idea how dangerous the Tea Party is. If they keep gaining strength and take over this country, like the Religious Right almost did during the Reagan years, we are in real trouble. Be warned. They will try to revert us back to "the...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|