I am a Unitarian. My faith supports same sex marriages and wishes to perform these ceremonies within our church yet most states say this is illegal. If marriage is a religious right then these states are violating my religious rights by not allowing such services the same legal recognization as those done in... oh say... baptist churches.
Could someone explain to me how this isn't a violation of my constitutional rights?
We had a similar problem in Spain (and still do to a degree) as we (being a free church group) are not allowed to conduct a legal marriage ceremony for any of our members of any sex.
In Spain only the RCC can conduct legal church marriages, or the mayor of the town, or court official, church weddings are reserved for Catholics.
Of course what we all do is marry first into a legal marriage, to satisfy the state laws, and secondly 'in the eyes of God and in the sight of the congregation, make these vows'
The second marriage, the one in the eyes of God, is of course the REAL marriage, the other one, the secular one, is just apiece of paper to assist the tax authorities.
If your religions god blesses same sex marriages, I see no problem.
I believe it all has to do with who issues the marriage license. It’s like how some fanatical branches of Mormons allow men to have more than one wife, but, you know as well as I do, that’s illegal in all 50 states.
It's so good to see tolerant religions and religious people. Having said that the courts have established that the law takes precedence over religious mandate, so as a previous poster mentioned you cannot practice polygamous marriage either therefore there is no constitutional violation.
I personally belong to a church that does not sanction same sex marriage - but feel that just because it is not considered a sacrament in my church does not mean that it can be prevented legally. If same sex marriage were to be approved, I wouldn't expect my church to have to marry a same sex couple. They could simply be married in a civil court. Should they choose to have their marriage blessed by God, and their church is willing to do so, so be it. For me, the difference is between the words - marriage and union. I believe that marriage is truly a sacrament...a civil union is a union that has taken place outside of a church and hasn't been blessed by a spiritual leader. Go - get your civil union confirmed by the law - if you indeed want it to be a marriage - head to your church and let them bless it!
No skin off my nose either way.
Marriage is an individual right, regardless of what religion is practiced.
It violates your constitutional rights, by having a minority getting its non traditional lifestyle forced on the country because they are rich and politically powerful.
They are diluting the constitution.
Marriage is not a constitutional right, it is a state privilege that requires a license.
Constitutional rights cannot be varied by the states, and they cannot be restricted by a license.
Gay marriage is simply a preference that can be changed unlike skin color.
Actually... if marriage is a religious rite then it IS a constitutional right... and any state passing a law forbidding it is violating my faith's constitutional rights.
If a marriage is valid when performed by a Baptist Church than it should be valid performed by any church... including mine. Or... again it violates my constitution right to freedom of religion by making a law that grants priviledges to one religion but not another
Lastly... The government (neither state nor federal) may interfere with the operation of a church. They cannot say who my church may marry any more than it can say whom a church baptizes or who receives a bris....
Assuming that all three statements are legally sound... and they are at least argumentatively legally sound... then my state government is persecuting my faith by violating my federal constitutional rights.
This is not really a religious matter. Ignorant people who hate and fear anything that is not familiar always use religion to justify their bigotry.
Marriage is not a religious right. It is a legal right that has traditionally had religious aspects. However, the legal facets have superiority over the religious ones. For instance, your religion may grant you the right to have multiple spouses, but legally you can only have one.
Basically, the fallacy in your argument is that you seem to think that actions sanctioned by religion are granted preeminence over the law. That is simply not the case. Thus, you can't practice human sacrifice, honor killings, etc., just because they are allowed by your religion. Moreover, denying you the right to do those things doesn't deprive you of any constitutional rights. You have freedom to worship how you choose within the confines of the law.
*Nods* and the fallacy in your argument is that say... honor killings... are killings. No church anywhere is allowed to kill. It's universal and fair.
However churches are allowed to have weddings. Those weddings are legally recognized. To tell my church who they may or may not marry is placing limits on the decisions of my church... which is unconstitutional.
To be universal and fair then either all weddings performed by all churches need to be legally valid or none are.
by Felixedet2000 6 years ago
What do you think about the promotion of same sex marriage?The adoption of this pattern of marriage is also a source of concerns to various stake holders in the religious and political circles.What is you say in all this?
by mohamedhmm 9 years ago
I believe we are as human kind we should defend our human rights and our wellness from any harmful act such as same sex; so, let's come together to protect our human rights and keep our society safe for us and next generation; it's our responsibility to say "no" for same sex because it's...
by Andrew Spacey 2 years ago
Same sex marriage - Equality or Not for gay people?Ireland recently voted 68% to 32% by referendum to allow same sex marriage, the first country in the world to do so. Is this true democracy at work? How do you view the decision - is it good for a whole country to be given the chance to vote on...
by Specificity 9 years ago
I know we already have a same-sex marriage thread in Politics, but that one has already grown so large that I thought I would start something different here. Generally, my political leanings are Libertarian, which means that I think government should work to maximize liberty for all people by...
by Susan Reid 6 years ago
This morning seems to be full of good news for the more tolerant among us.Proposition 8, which banned same-sex marriages in California, has been overturned by a federal appeals panel. Next stop (perhaps) SCOTUS.For those who don't live in CA and didn't have the distinct "pleasure" of...
by Josak 5 years ago
The election last night proved that same sex marriage now has enough popular support to win elections it looks like all three states passed referendums on same sex marriage a significant milestone towards equality in our nation, as was the whole election, yet another way the GOP is going to have to...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|