Sexuality - is there really a choice?
Many people - often who have concerns with homosexuality - comment that "it's a choice".
So, if people are so sure - I'd like to know how they are so sure:
is this a choice you have personally made? To be straight? Because in order for homosexuality to be a choice, heterosexuality must also be a choice. I mean this in the most polite way - I'm curious, please enlighten me. I'll save my thoughts for later.
PLEASE NOTE: I will not put up with people coming here just to insult people by name-calling, from either side. Understood? Polite, thoughtful conversation only...
I am a heterosexual and I don't recall flipping a coin or having to make a choice. I was (naturally) attracted to women.
In order to answer this question, one must first define "sexuality." If we're looking at sexuality as a preference for either males or females (same or opposite gender), that means something entirely different than the lifestyle choice that is known as homosexuality or heterosexuality.
I personally don't believe that a person has a choice in whether they are attracted to the same gender, opposite gender, or both. I won't go so far as to say that it's "natural" or that the hand of God is on sexual preference, but I do believe that it is innate, something that provides for cultural needs in a society (modern or primitive).
Sexual *activity,* on the other hand, along with lifestyle, is something that is *chosen* by the person choosing to engage in an alternative lifestyle. I've known straight females who "decide" that they want to engage in a homosexual lifestyle -- their confession, not me putting something on them. I've known gay males who lived with their wives and children for decades because they made the choice to mainstream their lifestyle.
Lifestyle is a choice. Preference is not. That sums up my feelings on it.
Thanks for your answer. A question - are you saying that whilst the preference is not a choice, whether to act on it is? Do we take this to mean that if pref is SS then the choice people say is 'wrong' is acting on it? What do you make of this?
It is more "wrong" to live in a lie to yourself and to others than to be truthfully who you naturally are. Like living with a wolf in sheeps clothing - someday you will see the "sheep" naked, and at that moment the wolf will instinctually attack.
I think that is what is *meant* by homosexuality being wrong (acting on it) rather than the actual preference itself being wrong, but if you ask a number of people you're likely to get a number of different answers to the question.
Yes. There is a choice.
A homosexual can choose to live their life unhappy, unfullfilled, and unsatisfied to please the masses, stay in the "norm", and not rock boats
they can be true to themselves and to others by pursuing what naturally makes them happy.
As far as I can tell sexuality is instinctive and not something subject to choice. A human is either instinctively drawn towards the male or female or both, or not, as in the case of certain asexual humans, who just are not sexual in any way.
Once the instinct kicks in, then choice might come into play. For example, if I'm a hetero male and I find myself attracted to two girls, let's say twin sisters, I may choose to go out with sister A because she has certain cultural interests that I share and the relationship might go on from there.
Scientists may be able to tell us about the mechanics of sexuality - hormone C is excited by pheromone B which tells the brain to emit chemical XYZ and so on - and that's why young Bill is atttracted to young Ben -but the fundamental feelings are surely natural, and not intentionally brought on through willpower or use of the mind.
A woman I know went through most of her adult life as a hetereosexual, had 4 children with the same man in an orthodox marriage but when she reached the age of 40 fell in love with a younger female! She claims her gay tendencies were hidden by her very busy family life but when her children grew older she started to experience gay maturity! Instinctive, not something she thought up or consciously invited into her lifestyle.
In my religion, people are free to choose to be homosexuals. However, it is advisable and homosexuals are urged to live a chaste life. Homosexuals who stay celibate have actually a harder time and the burden is great but it will be worth it once this temporary life is over.
Granted, that is what you believe - but did YOU personally CHOOSE your sexual preference? Did you think "right, I will be straight, because it is good for God?". Do you recall this decision? Was your sexuality a choice - is what I am asking
I may have erred when I said that it is a choice. Here's what the church says about homosexuality:
Note this: "as a state beyond a person’s choice"
And I had leanings toward my own sex but I chose to be straight.
Thanks for clarifying. Each to their own - as long as you are happy. I question choice because religion says so but if people are happy that's all that matters to me - I didn't choose but I wouldn't change it if I could - I hope you feel the same 4 u
by Jacqui4 years ago
Choice and Sexuality - The choice is for whom?This is for the 'choicers' - those who believe it is a choice whom we are attracted to - is it merely the homosexual whom must have "chosen' this attraction - that...
by Jacqui2 years ago
What do you believe causes homosexuality?I'm curious as to what people believe in relation to the causes of homosexuality. Please let me know where you got this believe from - your parents, your own deductions, your...
by Kay Adams3 years ago
Can a Gay Man or Woman, convert back to Straight & never turn back?
by ladyweight3 months ago
Are people really born straight or gay?Do you believe that people are born gay or straight or does society have something to do with it?
by Firoz3 months ago
Do you think gay people choose to be gay? Do you think straight people choose to be straight?
by atheistchick5 years ago
Define Heterosexism to me, please
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.