Oh thank goodness, this means you'll never have to upgrade a computer of phone ever again!
So how are we puppets again? Assuming there is no free will and it is all there (I tend to agree with all there only in the sense that 'it' is already there) how are we puppets? Is there a puppeteer?
I agree with Emile.
Of my own free will I doth post this.
Your genes were programmed so that you would react this way given this exact stimuli.
She did actually make a choice, just the same choice she would have made everything all things being the same.
The Universe. Or God. Whatever you want to call it.
Genetics are programmed for survival my nature. Survival of the fittest does not me the most psychologically balanced.
So "nature" has intelligence, or does this sort of programming, (that of genes), not require any?
Are you dissin' my psychological state?
Well, I've been thinkin' about the idea that I was programmed to respond as I did.
But what I can tell you is this---------I was wooed. I used the free will that God gave me, but He wooed me toward the way I live and think today. After all, when someone Loves you so much that He lays down His life for you, and especially when that person is the most powerful and awesome Being ever in existence, it makes it really appealing to respond to Him favorably.
The Word said that if Jesus was crucified, He would draw all men (all mankind) to Him. I am no exception. The only thing that sets me apart is that I'm one of those who desired to Love Him also and respond to His wooing. That's still free will. So....I wouldn't call it being programmed. I call it being under His grace. I love Him because He first Loved me.
Nope, it's not necessarily in my genes. Unless ya wanna count the "genes" received as I became born-again! Then, yes, I became a "new creature" in Christ. hahaaa perhaps a form of volunteer "cloning"..!!! hhhaaa joke.
Or, you love him because that's a relationship you need. The mind is an amazing thing and can create a simulation in your mind that it thinks it's true to help you survive. This loving relationship only exists in your mind. Some may need this relationship, some may have been talking into this relationship and some like me may not need this relationship so, when I realized I don't need it at 12 or 13 it went away. There is no doubt that if I were to play my life over again and if everything happened exactly as it did precisely, I'd have made the same decisions as would you.
So, what are we all now? Psychologists?
I'm not saying I understand the whole wooed defense (I couldn't help laughing while reading it, so I obviously don't understand it); but come on. How do you know she loves him because it is a relationship she needs? How do you know she has created a simulation in her mind that makes her think she needs this to help her survive?
Bully for you that, at 12-13 your perceived needs went away. Although that whole line is a little murky in itself. What needs? Either way, maybe (just maybe) your reality isn't hers? Or anyone elses? Your perceived bolt for independence may, or may not, be played out by someone else living in your shoes. Or, are you saying that you only make perfect decisions and everyone, given the same circumstances and information will make the same decisions? Do you have any research to back up such a bold claim?
Ever wonder why God is different for everyone? I just explained it in the forum Reasons to Believe. These are of course just my thoughts based on psychology.
I'm just trying to understand because it's fascinates me. I'm not claiming I'm perfect and make perfect decisions, I just said that in a sense free will is a necessary illusion. Yes we make the decision, but given the circumstances an individual will make that decision at that time, with all factors being the same, the same every time. I'm sure I'm not properly articulating this, but I'm trying anyway. I'm certainly not saying decisions are better for anyone else, they are just the best for me as yours are the best for you.
While I agree that only we can make decisions for ourselves, I wouldn't agree that we would always make the same decisions, given the same set of circumstances. Each moment in time is unique. Too many variables involved to make such a broad claim. Although, I suppose it could be argued that somewhere in the multiverse there would be a split of you who did.
What I mean is if we had to make the decision over again in the same time and the same circumstances we would make the same choices. If we could replay a decision without knowing what decision we made.
I knew that. I still say there is no guarantee. Although, many decisions would be the same; many decisions can easily go one way or the other. Some decisions are damned if you do, damned if you don't. You flip a coin. Some decisions rack your nerves because whichever way you go someone gets hurt.
Many decisions are a series of decisions. No one decision changes your life. Each choice made moves you further and further into a new direction. A variation in one will completely alter the end result.
There's nothing new
Under the sun
It's all been said
It's all been done
I cut my strings
So I'd be free
To find the puppeteer...was me...
Very interesting. I checked in out of curiousity and am very glad I did.
Free will is lacking at two critical points in your life - the time of your birth and the time of your death.
Not here to debate it is just an observation.
by Deepes Mind 8 years ago
On several hubs and forums, I see a lot of my fellow (to an extent) believers posting about how God give us the free will to do things our way, then on other hubs state that we must "Pray that God's will be done" in everything we do.. If we have to pray to God for his will to be done,...
by jonnycomelately 7 years ago
A personal choice between theism and natural evolutionary processesDo you think it helps to ditch the idea of a god dictating our lives and turn, instead, to the natural evolutionary process of selection and survival of the fittest?
by Joseph O Polanco 5 years ago
How do you prove something is morally right or wrong without using the Bible or appealing to God?
by Jennifer 8 years ago
I typed in the title of one of my hubs and I found that I rank...SECOND!!!! WAHOOOOOO!! For a hubber who is only five months old, I'd say that's pretty darn good. Then again, it's probably because I'm poking fun of myself in that one, which is okay. I have fun doing that. Seriously, though, I...
by Arthur Fontes 10 years ago
What are your feelings towards the theories of Carl Jung? I recently finished a book about symbols. That is all I have read from him is he worth my Time?
by john.jackson 10 years ago
Do you think that some people just ask questions on this page to get noticed?I am not trying to be ironic, but I see the same people ask questions over and over again on the weirdest topics. Do you reckon this is curiousity or an attempt to be noticed by other hubbers? or any other explanations are...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|