jump to last post 1-6 of 6 discussions (6 posts)

These three things cannot coexist logically: 1. God is omnipotent 2. God is bene

  1. thedragon319 profile image61
    thedragon319posted 8 years ago

    These three things cannot coexist logically:
    1. God is omnipotent
    2. God is benevolent
    3. Evil ex

    Either God is not all powerful or not all-loving, either way, why bother worshipping him if he's not?

  2. EdG. profile image60
    EdG.posted 8 years ago

    You might as well make like George Carlin and start worshiping Joe Pesci  cuz guess what? God doesn't really give a shit, assuming he's up there at all.

  3. Agdiom profile image59
    Agdiomposted 8 years ago

    The Epicurean Paradox: Winning Arguments for Atheists since c. 300 BCE.

  4. Mikel G Roberts profile image80
    Mikel G Robertsposted 8 years ago

    1. The supreme being by definition is omnipotent. The concept of the supreme being is marred by the ancient/modern churches definitions and descriptions of the supreme being. The being they describe doesn't make logical sense, because they are trying to make an all encompassing being with no bad side, or the ability to have a bad side. Which implies a being that is lacking.
    2. Tough love may sometimes be allowing hardships to befall people that need the hardships to learn and develop, or season. It doesn't mean that just because your Dad let you fall over and skin your knee while teaching you how to ride without training wheels, that your Dad, or God, is bad or that they chose to do evil to you. Being benevolent doesn't mean spoiling you.
    3. Evil exists because without evil goodness could not exist.
    4. You assume that worshipping earns you special treatment, it doesn't. The only thing you get from "worshipping" is the feeling of peace that usually accompanies the feeling of being connected with God, with someone/something greater than yourself.

  5. profile image47
    smattomposted 7 years ago

    MIkel - intelligent answer.

    I differ with second para, however.

    As an example, the Jews killed in Auschwitz suffered pretty tough love, was that all just to teach the rest of us something?

    What about mass murders which either take decades to be discovered, or, as I suspect, never get uncovered?

    As to the general philosophical debate, it naturally doesn't make sense using the terms mentioned. I'd personally say that good and evil are subjective entities and are concepts that have tracked the evolution of life in general. Perhaps they are too loaded as terms to be useful.

  6. Shahid Bukhari profile image60
    Shahid Bukhariposted 7 years ago

    A lot of things ... in fact, most of the things, that Exist, cannot ... or would rather not exist ... if existence, were equated with the logical !