Would you rather sit down and have a talk with Dawkins or the Pope? Why?
I would go with the Pope. It would be a very intense conversation that mostly involved me trying to convince the Pope that Catholicism is a bad thing.
Do we have to choose? I'd rather sit down and talk with both of them together actually. I could probably sit there and not say and word, and let them both thrash it all out. That would be fun. But I suppose that the Pope might feel that he was being ganged up on being in a room with two atheists, and that wouldn't be something that I'd want to happen. I'd like the Pope to feel comfortable, so that I could have a good chat with him about why I think his religion gets so many things wrong.
I used to be a Catholic - well, had a vaguely Catholic upbringing, in that I went to a Catholic church now and again, and I was told that I was a Catholic. Thankfully for me, I grew out of it
Love and peace to all!
Linda, you just described me perfectly. We have very much in common it seems!
I'm an atheist, but I pick the Pope. I know all of the answers to the questions I might ask Dawkins; I've read his books. Further, I have no interest in changing his mind on any topic. He promotes no evil, whereas I feel the Pope does. Maybe if he talked to me, he would be persuaded of this. Of course, this is unlikely, but stranger things have happened,
I would like to interrogate the pope. I would ask him, 'When you were the previous pope's enforcer - what was it, exactly, that you enforced?' (I know the answer to this question - a bit of googling should get you there)
I would also ask him to explain why he allows some catholics: filipinos for example, to believe that he speaks the word of god. This has led to situation where desperately poor people: that barely make a living crawling all over rubbish tips looking for scraps, have more and more children because the pope says that using contraception is a sin. Children are being born to families that live on the streets - they will grow up on the streets - and when some shopkeeper decides that the presence of these street urchins is bad for business he will shoot them and they will die on the streets.
Dawkins speaks for himself - both eloquently and eruditely - through his books and lectures. I would suggest that people read his stuff before attempting to engage him in converstion.
I'm inclined to think along the lines of Westman Todd Shaw. Closed minds in both instances, I'd say.
Of course, I have my own views, opinions which I like to believe are the truth (an ever-evolving one with me) but I'm pretty sure that whatever I come up with is really only a philsophy I can live with. It may be 'my truth,' but I know it's not the WHOLE Truth.
the pope only because then i could tell him how much damage his religion and his only personal stupidity does to this planet.
To choose between the two mentioned, it would be Dawkins ~ though one person I'd love to have a chat with is Leonard Cohen because he would be infinitely better company I would imagine.
by Ralph Schwartz2 years ago
Why is the Pope getting involved in US Politics by sparring with Donald Trump?Saying Trump isn't a Christian is a very decisive statement
by ngureco13 months ago
If You Were Made The Pope, The Most Immediate Change You Would Make Is To Allow Priests Get Married?
by New Understanding4 years ago
Do you think Pope Francis will bring people back to the Catholic faith?
by Rhys Baker5 years ago
Here is my point. All of the heads of the major branches of Christianity, as well as the heads of the other major religions all accept Evolution as the process by which the biodiversity we see before us came to be....
by r-o-y5 years ago
The bible states that the beast had two horns like a lamb, but a mouth that speak great blasphemy! On the surface it appears to be the Church of Christ, but on close inspection one see that this beast with horns like a...
by Maggie Bennett4 years ago
If you could Ask Pope Francis I anything today what would it be?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.