What a good question! I don't know. I know my morals are based on religious faith from when I was a child. Even though I'm not greatly religious today, I seem to retain my morals from my childhood religious faith. Either they became my core or I've been brainwashed. For those who don't have relligious faith to lean on, I guess they would have morals from a common sense of right vs. wrong or good vs. evil.
Hmm... Let's go with the Socratic Method and answer a question with a question...
Do you think that prosperity preachers, those that tell the poor, "Send me your money and you will be rewarded ten fold." are moral?
what i think is that morality or humanity are extracted from the religion.
in every religion there are nearly same moral values.
you can say that being moral is like practicing a part of religion.
When morality comes into play, the question, ultimately, must be where is the source of morality, or what are the guidelines that determine whether or not an action is moral?
religion is optional. it is up to you whether or not to believe! a moral life is totally possible!
Yes! Of course having no religion is a religion. I believe that the question is more what is your religion? You do not have to follow an organized religion or follow any sort of beliefs, but if you believe anything then you have a religion! Still if you do not agree with me and swear you have no religion I would not say you have no morals! It is just all in how you look at it!
I think the idea of morals is founded on religion, without it I am not sure what would tell us right from wrong, we'd be no different than animals. A hungry cat doesn't stop to think whether killing a bird is wrong.
Definitely. Maybe you are morally even more free since you have less to consider...
I have actually met people of no religion (athiest, agnostic, materialist, scientific, philosophical) and many, many religions -and, in each and every case, I have found both moral people, and also people who frequently do harm. Morality is about how we live our lives and care for all, not so much about our religious beliefs.
Yes - it goes without saying! Religion corrupts as much as any other social force. It's about faith and truth, not ceremony, incense, "blessed" wafers and praying in a certain direction.
Those things are absolutely meaningly and do NOTHING to prove God exists, or to bring you to belief and a closer relationship to Him.
Morality and ethics are about truth and fairness and love. You don't need religion to believe in, practice, or even die for, something or someone you value more than yourself, or for whom/what you believe it is a worthy price.
You don't need "God" to be "good".
I really don't know, but am going to look into it. I say this because even the great philosophers were influenced somehow, someway by religion if they didn't think up one to begin with.
Our principal in high school does not have a religion but he has a good moral conduct. For him, religion is a business so he doesn't have one but he believe in god.
we can gain knowledge through scientific research and looking at the natural world - what is real, what we can see and touch
this one life is all we know we have
our morality (our sense of right and wrong) comes from our human nature and culture
what is right is what promotes human welfare and fulfilment
we can and should create meaning and purpose in life
Many people hear this list and say "well, I guess I'm a Humanist". Maybe it's you as well. Most Humanists don't believe in God or belong to any religion, but call themselves Humanist because they share these values.
Sure, because a person chooses not to follow a particular religion that does not mean they will not have morals, they may actually be a good example of a moral character. In addition, just because a person claims to be religious that does not mean that they have morals.
Of course! I would hope one can make the decision that killing is wrong without someone, something or some book telling you so. We all have the ability to make our own decisions about what's right and wrong, and if we fail chances are there's a punishment for it. A reason civil society is in place.
Of course. Some of the nicest people in my life don't believe in God. They even use that fact to be the nicest person you'd ever meet. But the truth is that your works are not what gets you in heaven. But acceppting Jesus Christ as your Savior.
Morality and religion aren't really related. Religion is about following God's commandments. Being moral is about following a code of ethics. Following God's commandments doesn't necessarily mean following a code of ethics. Many religious practices have nothing to do with morality.
A person can live a morally good life without religion, but it is only a facade for a worldview that is rootless. Eventually, the relativism and humanism of their viewpoint will cause what they believe to decay, because if you believe that there are no absolutes everyone can create their own idea of morality.
I should say that by religion, I mean the Judeo-Christianity that has shaped western morals and culture. No matter if you think that you have been more shaped by your surroundings and influences, the basis for it has mostly come from that religious tradition.
It depends on people and what religion, some religion are have value that are not moral either, why do you think we got the old testiment and new testiment version of the bible? (Because the old testiment is fucked up)
Ofcourse No. although Moral relates to the distinction between good and bad which is affected by how you are raised up by your parents, but its directly affected by how much you are related to your religion. but depend again on the moral it self. some depends on your parents like honest but most related to relgion. for me if there is no relgion control my behavior I can cheat people kill do anything. at the end if I am not affriad that in next life I will be punished for doing so then I can do whatever I want without caring about others
These things are actually not concern with the religion but exactly the life is. So without religion i think there is no life.
What does having good morals have to do with religion? They are two separate things. Why couldn't a person live a life without religion, and have morals? I don't understand why you think that the two have to go hand in hand.
Absolutely! In fact I think it is easier to live a moral life without a religion than with one.
Morals are the deafening lines we subjectively divide in our mind to separate the differences of right and wrong, so technically--no matter the extent of one way or another extreme right or extreme left--all Earthlings possess some form of moral ideology. Religion is only a facet in the vast array of possibilities of what could determine ones moral state because it is a concept and concepts are moveable. The only reason we often relate morals with religion is because religion likes to set the lines of right and wrong for us and equate it to divine law for all men.
Morals are not founded on religion, family, culture, past experiences, or society... these are only building blocks in structuring our morals. Morals are founded in the individual who ultimately decides "this" is right or "this" is wrong.
It is all just relative to you, the individual.
yes off cause , just believe in one thing that is u. Believe in ur own self n that is more than all religions
Yes, definitely can. But he or she should have a proper good understanding of the world. If not, I think the religions play a great role.
If you can't understand things properly, do follow a religion. But if you can tolerate anything with your understanding, forget the religion have it your own way of living.
There are many good people without a religion. I have met some Marxists who care much on others than their own lives.
So I really value their way of living.
Of course you can. If you are a religious person then this can be used as a guide line to how you live your life, but there is a fine line between right and wrong so it's very possible to live a moral life without religion. In fact some non religious have higher morals than others!
In my opiniion to live a Moral Life without Religion is living life without a set of guided rules. The Moral life would be made up by dancing to your own music. Living life according to your own views of right and wrong....seems like trouble to me.
Yes, it is very possible. I know alot of people who don't belive in religion they just belive in right and wrong.
Ofcourse! In fact sometimes religion stops people from living entirely moral lives.
IN actual fact it depends on what morality actually is. Moral by social imposed laws or moral by human nature? How do we draw a line between which is which?
The fact that you have posted this question suggests that you are not interested in religion but interested in morality... so you are already have way there! Just keep living your life in a way that makes you feel good.
9/10 making people happy will make you feel happy.
I believe that the point of religion is service to a deity through fear/loyalty, but USUALLY only to better themselves for selfish reasons or to get to Heaven. However, a relationship with God is not religion; and because we were created by intelligent design, morality is one of the main reasons the existence of God is supported. In his book "Mere Christianity," C.S. Lewis has a whole chapter devoted to morality how it is impossible to live it if you truly believe there is no God.
Just my thoughts. I really would like to elaborate more, but that's the short answer. I apologize if it's hard to understand...these thoughts of mine can be kinda jumbled.
I think religion is man's manipulation of God's word. I am a spiritual person, and I do believe in God, but I do not profess to religious. Religion does not create morals, however God's Word does and can help.
I believe there are two ways to view religion.
One, as a belief in an actual Diety, and two, as a belief in a force, energy, or principle.
If we think beyond the confines of organized religion, then morality can be its own form of religion. With or without a sect with which to associate oneself, one is not limited to what he can achieve.
Religion is and always was for people who require outside guidance. Internal guidance and morality are the goal of religion, and if you can lead a moral and ethical life without religion, great! But of course I'm tempted to ask you what your conception of morality is.
I think the answer to that is yes. Religion is something people choose believe in and it doesn't necessarily give you morals. Morals are the way we conduct ourselves and you don't have to have a religion to know the right way to behave.
Like many here posting, I agree that you can live a moral life without religion. However, I think the deeper question is, would morality (general concepts of good and bad) exist if there never was religion in the first place?
People say that you adopt ethics and morals from your grandparents and parents, but even if your parents are agnostic or atheist, chances are somewhere up the family tree there was a religion or religious book/belief advocating certain morals. Such ideas (often not under the label of Christianity, Judaism, etc.) are passed down and accepted. There are of course be exceptions to this - especially in deeply rooted atheist communities. But in many cases of morality, religion probably did play its role.
You can have Christian or Buddhist values/ethics/morals without being a Christian or Buddhist.
I believe morality is a soul quest about honoring others. Religion seems to be a thread of dogma to sustain mankind into rigid rules and rob them of independent thinking. Though I don't believe religion started this way, it has become this way.
Morality is simple, also known as humanitarian. How can you breech any kind of universal order by being compassionate and honest. Such is the breath of life and if you have those basic principles then you are on your way to your own wonder.
morals can be developed by your own sense of right and wrong that you feel when looking at a situation. Despite their ability to stop, most people who do either right things or wrong things in life, know for certain the difference between the two even while doing them.
Yes, it is possible to live a moral life without religion because a person may choose to respect life and law while at the same time not affiliating themselves with any particular religion. People turn their backs on religion for many reasons- some were never raised to be religious, others have a general feeling of mistrust towards religious practices, institutions, or officials. While others may be going with whatever the popular sentiment in society seems to be or whatever is "cool" at the time which in our society seems to be ant-religious at the moment. Most religions ask for their constituents to practice good deeds. Religion is not the culprit. People who corrupt religion are the culprits. Once there are corrupt individuals who have tainted their religion, then others will begin to lose faith in religion and blame religion for the mistakes and wrongful actions of individuals who misinterpreted what their religion was stating or who simply were going against their own religion. Or in some cases, people makeup their own religion with thier own agendas which are actually not for the good of anyone at all. So, whether one chooses to be religious or not, it is important to strive to find out what is the meaning of life and what it means to be good and to do good. And what it means to be bad. Since we each interpret and perceive these aspects differently, it is difficult to say what is right or wrong. This is why it is so extremely important to respect people's lives no matter what they believe in or don't believe in. As for myself, I can outwardly say that I respect my Christian religion because it has taught me many wonderful lessons about love, God, and discipline all through my life. My experiences within my religion have brought me much joy to see people coming together organized to celebrate life and God. I am not a perfect person, neither is my religion, but that doesn't mean that I have to give up my religion or judge others for theirs.
There are many moral atheists, and many immoral religious believers. History is filled with immoral acts committed in the name of a god. People will often use religion as an excuse to do evil things. This does not mean religion itself is wrong, simply that being religious does not make someone moral.
Religion is not what defines a person morally. There are many "religious" people who are extremely corrupt and immoral. I follow Christ with all my heart, but I have known some non-Christians who were more moral than some of my fellow Christians!! There are many people with a "do good" philosophy without religion.
Of course, you don't necessarily have to have religion in order to treat people in the way you believe people should treat you. Respect for other people should be more than enough to live a moral life without religion.
I realize this hub was published some time ago, but I'd still like to answer. I don't think religion is necessary to living a moral life and being a moral person. There are so many other factors that go into forming an individual's perspectives. One can easily see that without any guidance, an individual can certainly stumble but I have also known folks who follow religion who do immoral things. Religion is to provide a guideline in life, but so do our family, our peers, our culture and our society. There is also the factor of the ability and willingness of an individual to learn from their mistakes, to feel empathy and to want to be a good person.
To have morals has nothing to do with religion. In all honesty at least in my opinion religion is an excuse for someone elses views to be expressed through you. I feel you should establish your own way of doing things and your own morals throughout your whole life. Take advantage of everything you have because life is beautiful so establish your own point of views and run with it its your life do with it what you choose as long as your happy.
Religion is something that we are just born with..and will stay wid us forever..values are different..there is always a gradual increase in whatever we learn..and we can decide what shud stay..and what shud go..
Yes one can live a "Moral Life" without religion simply follow the laws of society, but this would not guarantee you will go to heaven when you die and you will die.
Yes, as morals aren't the same as religion. I am not a religious person. But yet I don't go around driving drunk, or murdering people.
Morals and religion do not always go hand and hand. We learn so much from various things that affect our morals. I am presently taking a parenting class in which we are discussing morals and punishment. I was surprised at how many different variances came when it came down to family rules. Some people were similar in religious backgrounds while others were the complete polar opposite. When it came down to it, morals were based on what each couple believed not on their religion itself. As one person said, "Just because I am religious, doesn't mean I believe this or that."
What are you talking about, religion is the single most destructive thing in the world. All wars are somehow related to religion.
Having said that being spiritual is different. I dont believe in religion but I believe in something.
Morals are built in. Its hard wired in your head. If you choose not to listen to it then its your choice.
Its not what some one can impose and it shouldn't be...
Moral life isn't just about choosing what's good or bad. It is more than that. There's so many unsure condition in life. Sometimes, we need 'a bigger hand' to help us. Religion is like a basic way of life. To live a moral life in peace, anyone will definitely choose to be religious.
by Alina-Cristina 6 years ago
How would our world be like without religion?Would humans be able to find inside a moral compass to guide them towards good?
by paarsurrey 12 years ago
Scientific advancement without morals and spirituality to control from Word revealed from the Creator-God Allah YHWH could destroy humanityThat is the most danger posed to humanity. A man living in Hiroshima or Nagasaki; what benefit accrued to him from the scientific advancement uncontrolled by...
by Dwight Phoenix 7 years ago
Would the world be a better place without religion?A lot of persons always speak bad of religion and how it's just a flurry of confusion to turn races and nations against each other and how churches don't really help out at all.But suppose many people wishes came through and all of a sudden there...
by mariexotoni 6 years ago
I am an atheist surrounded by family and friends who practice Christianity.A lot of atheists say that the world would be a better place without religion.. I can understand why they say that. But, for some people- I feel like they need religion for their own sanity/happiness. It has been around for...
by LAURENS WRIGHT 10 years ago
Is there a right or wrong without religion ?Killing, stealing, cheating or dishonest acts are throughout the world. Without truth and justice, is there a right and wrong without a religion or supreme justice for a basis of thought? What has happened to the mentality of the people who...
by Thomas Byers 9 years ago
Would The World be A Better Place With Out Religion?I see all the fighting over Jesus and religion and I often wonder if the world wouldn't be a better place with out religion. After all no one has ever proved that God exists have they? What do you think?
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|