What would you have done if you were in Abraham's place & God commanded you to sacrifice your Son or Daughter?
Its called "The Binding of Isaac", a story from the Hebrew Bible. For those who are not familiar with the story, it goes like this:
God asks Abraham to sacrifice his son, Isaac, on Mount Moriah. Abraham sets out to obey God's command without questioning. After Isaac is bound to an altar, the angel of God stops Abraham at the last minute, saying that "now I know you fear God". At this point Abraham sees a ram caught in some nearby bushes and sacrifices the ram in Isaac's stead.
Now from a religious perspective, Abraham might be the ideal example of faith on God. But if we look at it from an ethical perspective, how does it appear to you? To me, I find Abraham a person who does not hesitate to butcher his own Son for being in the good book of a Higher power for his own benefit. Its the symbol of selfishness at its best. And what about the judgment of God? How was that ethical anyway? How can God (YHWH) support a man who agrees to kill another human? & how could a GOD can ask for human sacrifice from us? Forget Human, even animal sacrifice should be banned from our society! I always found YHWH to be a sadistic, brutal & unholy power, who has been claimed by many to be a loving God! But can anyone explain how is this being ethical & loving?
At first glance, it would appear to be a Bronze Age fable constructed for a purpose, the possible intention of which is to stir awe and reverence from the superstitious and gullible. However, used as a powerful tool for childhood indoctrination, it can draw fear and terror from any child who now believes their parents wouldn't hesitate to slit their throats at gods command, without questioning.
This fable is gleaned from Bronze Age thinking, the same thinking that gave us 'an eye for an eye' brand of justice, and from a time when superstitions were common place in light of rational explanations that we take for granted today.
We need not focus so much on Abraham as a self serving believer but instead focus on the overall message being delivered, that people would and should without question go the lengths of killing members of their family for the belief of a gods existence. Teaching to sacrifice your own children for the love of a god is a beautiful example of a morally and ethically bankrupt belief system.
Of course, they didn't have the current set of moral and ethical concepts we understand today when they wrote such stories.
Included amongst them, the stories of Noah, Moses and Lot, full of the same line of superstitious and violent Bronze Age thinking, all morally and ethically bankrupt by today's standards.
Since you seem to choose to try to be the judge of God Himself, saying you always found Him to be sadistic and unholy, I think your mind is closed to even trying to understand the answer to your question.
If I had today knowledge, I would have said, No to God, and would point out to him that he was a cruel God and I would rather have a loving God then a powerful vengeful God.
I suppose I wanted to say this, because today we would like to have a loving God, otherwise we would be better off without gods.
Once one deviate from Truth he can end almost anywhere........
This narrate is only your interpretation of the story....
Abraham is the well know an the Father of Faith...
Any with the understanding of faith will understand the true meaning of the story...
Since men do not like Truth they will believe a lie unto their own end.
Please do not pass judgment on something you do not yet understand otherwise you would inevitably be false.
It is better to exercise your intellect to understand rather than criticize.
I presume you understand the "Truth" very well just like Abraham did. And I guess, if an invisible mysterious voice tells you to kill me, you too will do so!
I believe what you are trying to term as 'Truth' is just a kind of Psychological Disorder. People with this type of disorders can be dangerous at times & needs to be kept under supervision...for the well being & security of our society.
I could be wrong? ...
It seems that Abraham was claiming absolute faint in God.
It would seem natural for that absoluteness be tested.
It is written (Something like) From those that little is given, little is expected in return.
To those that much is given, much is expected.
Every parent has TESTED their children,in one way or another, to some extent or another.
Employers test the loyalty of their employees ...
Husbands/wives test the loyalty of their spouses etc in some way or extent, whether this is done consciously or unconsciously.
It seems natural that Abraham would be tested, for all that he claimed and was as promised.
It is through testing that we grow. or not.
I think I got your point.
Parents testing their children: Dad telling son go Kill your brother & rape your Sister
Yeah its absolutely natural, Jeremy. Two Thumbs Up.
You can't be serious, Jerami.
We might test our childrens aptitude for cognitive learning skills or mental gymnastics.
But, we don't hold a knife to our children screaming out god wants us to slit their throats for his amusement.
Here you go reducing God to a mere human being again.
It would be fitting for a human to test their child, because, without the benefit of omniscience, that would be the only way to note progress in the child...
But...to say that an omniscient being needs to test anything is absolutely ABSURD!
getitrite wrote ..
Here you go reducing God to a mere human being again.
- - - - - - - - -
I don't know how else to describe something other than using terms that I am familiar with.
I don't think that you do either??
getitrite wrote ..to say that an omniscient being needs to test anything is absolutely ABSURD!
- - - - - - -
Why is it that Absurdity can only be seen in others ?? Hmm I wonder why that is ?
getitrite wrote ..
It would be fitting for a human to test their child, because, without the benefit of omniscience, that would be the only way to note progress in the child..
- - - - - - - - -
And posibly to encourage such progress and growth in that area.
I am glad that you agree.
That's no excuse. Your delusion has collapsed.
Meaningless and childish. Sorry. Where is your argument?
So is your imaginary God omniscient or not?
BTW, you only agree with yourself, which is right in line with the delusion.
Your replies to my post has no intellectual content what so ever, what is sad is that you didn't even attempt to say anything of substance,
You are just throwing insults. Day in and day out.
In each passing day, You are sounding more like an angry six year old.
Take two dose of self evaluation. and call me in the morning.
Your position, and steadfast adherence to it, in the face of overwhelming contradictions is the insult...you take us to be silly.
And just because you are angry that your childish delusion has collapsed, you stoop to calling someone childish. WOW!
Don't kill the messenger, just make some sense, and you and I, and all the others, who see your psychotic beliefs as the nonsense that they are, will exist peacefully.
And then some people take everything out of context.
This too can be understood as a mental disease.
I think Im gonna write a book. I will call it :
"Context & Interpretation" - the Duo that Saved the Holy Ass
Has anyone considered that most everyone thinks that most everyone else has a mental disorder?
Maybe everyone is right.
They only think the people who doesn't agree with them has the mental disorder. I don't think you have a mental disorder. I don't think they have a mental disorder. They just don't understand so they like to attack and insult people with different beliefs. Just smile and know that God said it would be this way.
Some of us believe that divine communication is done in the language acceptable and understandable in its context.
Abraham, if you believe this foundational myth is true, lived about 4000 years ago. As incredibly difficult as this can be to imagine this today, back then human sacrifice was a common way to express devotion to a deity. People did a lot of things we would find abhorrent today; no one acted in a way we would consider ethical today.
Would we do this today? No. We've moved beyond human sacrifice. We've moved beyond animal sacrifice, even. Most of our divine revelation, if you want to call it that, is from our own doing, through scientific inquiry. We are simply more advanced, less primitive than we were.
And, for the literalists who deny that progress and context are essential to religious thought, there is a clear prohibition in the Torah (Old Testament to Christians), in Deuteronomy 12:31.
Just something that comes to mind concerning sacrifice.
Ya always see in the movies that a virgin or inocent child was being sacrificed. These were guaranteed entrance into heaven.
Wouldn't be right sacrificing someone that they thought was going to hell not allowing them the chance for redemption.
After all if we beleive in heaven ?? what is death?
Abraham's battle was waged within. The darkness said "kill the child" The light said: "Don't kill the child" God was one with darkness, creating light, with which to see the truth of darkness.
That could be true. ??? don't know.
I try to be careful when speaking for what I think God said.
I usually just say that the bible said God said.
Concerning things that are written I feel free to say that It think it says such and such. And this is the way that I understand that.
I just don't want to say God said it unless I think he said it to me, personally.
And if I share that, I say, I think God said this to me.
But over all, I think that you might be right.
by Jeff Berndt6 years ago
Okay, most people know the story."1 And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham, and said unto him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, here I am. 2 And He said, Take now thy son, thine only son...
by Ron Hooft7 years ago
1. God told Moses to sacrifice the first born of humans and animals to him. 1The Lord said to Moses:2Consecrate to me all the firstborn; whatever is the first to open the womb among the Israelites, of human beings and...
by pisean2823115 years ago
God which Abraham is credited to have invented was involved in many mass murders like killing of human beings and all other species barring his favorite noah .God also killed his own son and is said to later do stunt of...
by Chris Mills5 years ago
Is sacrificial death a thing the biblical God CHOSE to require or is it innate to His CHARACTER?This question has to do with the sacrificial death for fogiveness of sins. Hebrew writings require animal sacrifices while...
by Tammy5 years ago
Is hoarding a mental disorder that is passed from generation to generation, or a learned trait?This is a debate in my family. Some believe that extreme frugal living/hoarder is a mental disorder that is passed from...
by Matthew Kirk5 years ago
This is a genuine question;I would like to know the mechanics of how a man being killed by a group of Romans washes away sins?I don't want to be preached to, I would like a 'rational' answer / explanation if one can be...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.