If you just found out that someone you know on HubPages is 16 years old (for example), would you report it? Ignore it? Or what would you do?
Depended on whether they seemed mature or not.I reported a 14 year old once, because you could tell from his profile that he was ultra innocent.(homeschooled,thought it was a blog, told people to email him...) I feared that he might be predator bait and too innocent to realize it.
in my opinion age doesn't matter in hubpages as writing skills doe snot depend upon age. But below 18 should not view adult content in hubs like adult pictures that are used in hubs.I will not report if i found someone below 18 years.
Yes, I would report it. Experience shows that eventually, they get found out. Better they get caught early, than wait till they've put hours of effort into writing Hubs which are going to get unpublished.
Well, maybe this isn't what we're "supposed to do", but if the Hubs were of decent quality; I'd just think that it's up to HubPages staff to worry about who meets the minimum-age requirement. I guess I see the quality of the writing on the site as a "team effort" type of thing, but the administration of setting rules and making sure members follow them, as a HubPages staff/adm thing.
Then again, if the kid was on here acting like a little jerk and not really writing anything, if I were irked enough I might flag his profile. There has been a time or two when people have pretended to be kids and said stuff just to get people "all worried". Whether they are or not, if someone sees something that seems concerning, nothing wrong with flagging it.
I have no problem reporting any TOS violations I come across, and that includes underage site users.
Thanks Lisa and Relache, I'm not surprised to see differing opinions on this topic. It is very helpful for me to read.
I am not so sure I would report it- it just depends-I mean how would you find out, secondly the person may have a perfectly good explanation for saying what they did. Once found out the person should be given a chance to explain why and a chance to amend what they have done.
If Relache wanted to pretend(lie) to everyone on this site that she was 33 that is her concern not everyone else's. The only person she's really lied too is herself. Her writing is still the same in life you take everyone on face value, until proven otherwise.
If the site says 18 more older then we should respect that and report. If the site administrators want to make an exception that is their choice. I would report because to NOT do so would be wrong. It would mean that if there were a million people online in HP making those decisions then there would be a million decisions.We would be voting by consensus and so far have not seen that on HP:)
I had an under 18 contact me about adsense - of course it's 18+ to apply.
He had quality hubs that were better than many hubs by older people on the site.
My recommendation to him was to ask a parent to help him with the official details when applying for affiliates.
Usually however, I'd say that 18+ should mean 18+
I think i go through life learning more from kids than adults.
is there really any policy on hubpages that prevents a minor from joining this site? as far as i know, there isn't such a rule. however, if that is the rule, then i would report it to hubpages if i knew any hubber that was under the age limit.
personally, i think if hubpages really wants to keep underage minors from joining, they should have it a rule where they should require the first time user to verify their age via credit card. charges should NOT be charged on that card at all. NO, just be used to verify the person's age. Anyways, that would be one good way to verify a minor's age. however, i know many hubbers here enjoy the simplicity of hubpages, and how easy it is to publish and sign up. therefore, i doubt seriously many would agree with me, but that's just my suggestion on the whole situation.
The Terms of Service expressly say that a person must be 18 years or older to open a new account.
I'm 18, but don't have a credit card. If Hubpages were to have implemented that rule, it would've been an awful hassle to register. I might not even have bothered.
Yes, the rules state you must be over 18.
No, no, no please no! If HubPages had asked me for a credit card, I wouldn't have joined. Just think what I'd have missed out on!
A lot of people are hesitant about using their credit card online, so introducing such a requirement could discourage people from joining.
IAh,stevennix, I would never join a writer's site that wanted my credit card number to join.Never.
I was reading terms and stumbled onto this-
What's that supposed to mean ? Most of the hubbers have content targeted at children under the age of 13 like - dora the explorer dvd's, other animes and toys. Maybe i'm getting it out of the context but really got confused with that.
You raised the topic Website Examiner..would really enjoy your viewpoint on this.
Thanks for asking A la Carte. I found your response above very interesting.
First and foremost, I think it is wrong of people under the age of 18 to sign up. Most of them know perfectly well what they are doing; they are probably used to getting around age limits all the time. If they get reported, it is their own fault. Rules are there for a reason, and they ought to respect that. Also, other Hubbers have a right to feel comfortable that they are not interacting with (technically) children on a website reserved for adults.
Second, I think that any hubber who reports someone under 18 has the right to do so, and that without needing to feel a bad conscience.
Third, for me personally, it is a matter of extent. I would unconditionally report someone aged 15 or younger. If aged 16 or older, I would try to consider the person's maturity; not so much whether their articles are any good, more whether they seem to be able to take care of themselves on the site - without being lured in by someone harboring bad intentions, and without bothering others with stupidity.
I would definitely report it. By not doing so, you're just letting them know that breaking the rules is okay as long as they're not caught. Bad lesson IMHO. As adults, we're supposed to be role models.
Besides, if they don't respect the rules when they sign up, why would they bother respecting them once they're a member?
Marisa Wright and lrohner, I find your arguments persuasive and tough to beat. I appreciate everyone else's comments as well.
I seem to remember a 16 year old being nominated as a Hubnugget last month, so really, how strict is HP on TOS?
WE I like the way you put it , I agree with everything you have said and believe that, what is a violation is a violation... whether the person is smart or not.
I have reported the little girl who caused a lot of trouble on a weekend and will continue to do so if the need arises!
I would say to report it. They might not be able to prove the age of the person and that person stays anyway but at least you know that you did the right thing. I'm of age but I have found that there are a lot of shady people that contact me. Not just people from HubPages but from the Internet and they email me. I just ignore it but you just never know what can happen and what that person might do. If they are a legal adult and allowed to be here then it's all on them but if they are underage and you can at least attempt to protect them then I say do it. Better safe than sorry for the underage here. It has amazed me what people from the Internet do and I would hate to think they are saying things like that to 16 year old's because it is pretty bad.
Maturity can't be judged simply by someone's age, but the rule makes sense. Adults are legally responsible for themselves, no matter what; minors not so much. For that alone, I agree with the rule.
I would not necessarily report every minor I found out, though. It depends on the person. To me, it's not like bending an age limit rule on this particular website would immediately show kids that they are free to do whatever they want, as long as they're not caught. Not every minor works at such a basic level -.-' . Again, to me it depends on each one's maturity and reasons to be here.
I report them. There are hubs and things in the forums that minors just need to stay way from, and it is TOS. I would not want my grandchildren on here.
If you found out they were 16, HP will find out in short order. There is certainly content that the very young should not be exposed to, so i imagine I would forwarn them and then report.
Hubpages seem to have most things right, their TOS are not onerous and seem well thought out. Hubpages must also comply with laws about publishing etc that do not directly concern us using the facility.
If it against the TOS it should be reported - if Hubpages choose to ignore the report it is their business.
This is going to seem like real "bad attitude", and I understand, I suppose, the thinking that "we all should kick in" on the aim toward having members comply with TOS; but I go back to my thing that I think "kicking in" on the quality of writing that shows up here is one thing. Becoming police, babysitters, or self-appointed HubPages staff seems like another to me.
I don't know... I think if a kid signs up and gets reported by someone he had it coming. I don't think people are wrong for reporting if they feel like it either. I just can't worry about other people's kids. That's up to their parents. I still say worrying about someone not complying with the age thing is up to HubPages.
I've had kids (like 12-year-olds, no Hubbers, though) make comments on my Hubs; and I'm really, really, careful about what I say (because sometimes they ask about stuff that I wouldn't want my kid asking some stranger, even if a lot of it is fairly innocent (like whether a young kid should have a cell phone or not) ). So, I "worry" about other people's kids in that way on here. I don't know... Maybe I'm just new to having my own kids grown up and kind of enjoying not having to worry about kids right now. (Then, too, I'm not inclined toward wanting to be that "police-person" in a lot of situations in life.)
by Liz Elias3 years ago
If you report or flag a hub or question, is it anonymous, or does the person know who did the reporting or flagging?It would be a shame to have a retribution war started....
by Catherine Mostly2 years ago
First, apologies to Tori since it will SEEM like I'm picking on her HotD - I'm not. These featured hubs need to be touched by an editor if Hubpages is ever going to be taken seriously as a 'real' writing site.1. The...
by Mary Hyatt22 months ago
I thought it was against HP's policy for writers to use photos from those sites where the watermark is on the photo. I see lots of photos I'd like to use, but they would have a watermark.I just read a Hub where...
by Kangaroo_Jase6 years ago
I haven't been around much the last few weeks due to events (very positive) happening in my life.I come back to HP and find a few changes have occurred.I sense a significant shift, even may be a paradigm shift. If this...
by GeorgiaSmith5 years ago
I am 45 and have been away from the social scene for a while (online or off) with my divorce I have begun to wonder if there is an age limit to making new friends. My daughter suggested that I go online, but am I too...
by Simone Haruko Smith6 years ago
Hey everyone!Last Friday, Pia challenged the HubPages staff to bout of Hubbing - I have joined with her and we're going to publish one Hub every day for as long as we can!The unspoken challenge is to see who can go at...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.