jump to last post 1-12 of 12 discussions (21 posts)

Are humans superior to animals?

  1. Jennifer Madison profile image89
    Jennifer Madisonposted 5 years ago

    Are humans superior to animals?

  2. MickS profile image72
    MickSposted 5 years ago

    Humans are animals.

  3. Sage in a Cage profile image81
    Sage in a Cageposted 5 years ago

    Well technically humans are animals but...

    It depends on your definition of 'superior'. We have highly evolved civilisations and the most advanced form of self-awareness in the animal kingdom. On the other hand, despite our apparent superiority, we conduct wars against our own kind and destroy our own environment for future generations.

    1. Jennifer Madison profile image89
      Jennifer Madisonposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      I totally agree with you. And like you said, we should use our intelligence and self-awareness more wisely.

    2. Melissa A Smith profile image98
      Melissa A Smithposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      I disagree that intelligence is synonymous with being peaceful and conflict-less.

    3. Sage in a Cage profile image81
      Sage in a Cageposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      Melissa, I never mentioned intelligence, a psychological concept, in my answer. I was merely pointing out that the term 'superior' means different things to different people so it's a difficult question to answer.

    4. Melissa A Smith profile image98
      Melissa A Smithposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      I agreed with the first part of your answer, but when you said "despite our apparent superiority, we conduct wars against our own kind", that was what I disagreed with. But too bad people can't take alternate opinions and voted your answer down.

    5. Sage in a Cage profile image81
      Sage in a Cageposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      I thrive on debate. I just didn't understand what you were referring to. As for the down voting, fire ahead. I won't down vote you as I respect your opinion.

  4. Lucky Cats profile image79
    Lucky Catsposted 5 years ago

    The question is far too simplistic.  There are many ways in which we, humans, are perhaps, more developed intellectually while, instinctually; animals have it all over the human species.  There are so many categories in which such a comparison might be able to be made however, we must be weary of projecting our own "idea" of what "superiority" is and how it is defined and applied.  Strength?  Refined; heightened "senses," agility, ability to survive in nature, or city, or any type of environment...all hold unique and distinct characteristics thus contributing to the idea of how a species survives; exists and how this might be perceived as "superior" or "inferior."  Ability to communicate?  Again, subjective.  the question must be refined however, in doing so, it is impossible to be completely unbiased and clinical; emperical as , in all things studied, we cannot help but interject our own definitions, descriptions and interpretations of behaviors of our and other species.  There are thousands of types of animals; in as many environments as there are many races, and locals of humans on this planet.....So I cannot conclude, with any amount of certainty; that there is an absolute superior or inferior species as compared one to the other.

  5. tiagoz profile image58
    tiagozposted 5 years ago

    Not in every way but in many ways, yes we are superior.

    1. Jennifer Madison profile image89
      Jennifer Madisonposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      In which way do you think the human race is superior?

    2. tiagoz profile image58
      tiagozposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      Regarding the ability to gain knowledge, we are superior. But for instance elephants are superior to us with regards to memory: they remember things for much longer than humans. Giraffes only sleep for 5 minutes a day. In that sense they are superior

    3. Ivana Mladenova profile image55
      Ivana Mladenovaposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      For how long elephants can remember? For life? They don't live longer than 70 years..my grandmother is 75 years old and she remembers clearly her childhood

  6. Seeker7 profile image96
    Seeker7posted 5 years ago

    In theory we are suppose to be more intelligent - in reality, there are thousands of examples that show animals are more intelligent than some folks! But I do agree with Kathy (Lucky Cats), that the answer is more complex. Animals on a physical and sensory level are frequently more superior to us, but our intelligence and adaptability gives us superiority in different, but crucial ways.

    My own feelings overall though, is that although we are suppose to be 'superior', that does not and should not mean that we can treat animals anyway we like. Higher intelligence does not give us a 'superior' right to abuse animals or anything else in nature.

  7. We Save Cats profile image60
    We Save Catsposted 5 years ago

    there are many good answers here, I agree with LC who has presented a very lucid and intelligent consideration of it.  it is very interesting that there are down votes on LC's comment as well as S in a C.  quite thought provoking, emphasis on provoking.

  8. yoginijoy profile image71
    yoginijoyposted 5 years ago

    Definitely not, all sentient beings are on the same quest: to realize our potential.

  9. glorgeousmom profile image81
    glorgeousmomposted 5 years ago

    As a Christian, i will base my answer according to the foundation of my faith - the Word of God which is the Scriptures/Holy Bible. Yes, humans are superior to animals for God willed it and made it so in the beginning, as what is written in the book of Genesis,Chapter 1, verse 26.
    (Genesis 1:26 - Good News Bible): 'Then God said, "And now let us make human beings; they will be like us and resemble us. They will have power over the fish, the birds, and all animals, domestic and wild, large and small."
    To say that animals are superior to humans is an insult to our Creator, who created us according to his image and likeness (Genesis 1:27).

  10. JamesGrantSmith profile image60
    JamesGrantSmithposted 4 years ago

    Well we share allot of similar character traits, but i would say we probably are, on the basis we own them, they don't own us, at least in this universe.

  11. Emanate Presence profile image76
    Emanate Presenceposted 4 years ago

    The diversity of perspectives presented makes interesting reading. Rather than add to the same, and since there is no definitive answer, I ask in response, what would be the most useful way of looking at this question, for the future of humanity and the earth?

    A worldview of Man's superiority in general has had devastating consequences for the planet and its inhabitants. Domination of one race over another, one species over another, does this feel advanced or whole?

    When looked at another way, that we are all made of the same matter, and are inter-connected with each other -- woven together in the fabric of our essence, none is superior to another.

    In strength, speed, size, etc. yes of course there are species which are superior. Those may be fun facts, but to me they are superficial for measuring superiority.

    What matters is how we look at ourselves and our relation to each other, to the earth and all living beings. What perspective would bring out the qualities we choose?

  12. Levertis Steele profile image85
    Levertis Steeleposted 4 years ago

    Overall, human beings are superior to animals, but the growing weaknesses of humans beings are enough to make us wonder.

    Animals are cleaner. They do not litter the land or pollute the water and air.
    Animals do not do drugs.
    Animals are not alcoholics.
    Animals do not use tobacco.
    Animals eat what they were designed to eat.
    Animals do not destroy the rain forests.
    Animals do not usually wage unnecessary wars or cage human beings.

    Animals are superior to human beings in some ways, but they do not brush their teeth! They do not use deodorant! Many of them have multiple sex partners and probably do not know the fathers of their "children." They do not like condoms. These faults would land them on Jerry Springer and Steve Wilkos--I'm not sure of Steve's last name.

    Now, that I think about it more, maybe animals and human beings are equal.

    1. Ivana Mladenova profile image55
      Ivana Mladenovaposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      I brush my dogs teeth and she seems to like it

 
working