It would be far more helpful and less cumbersome if, when a hub was selected for inclusion in one of the new HubPages network sites, instead of a list of suggested changes, specific areas needing attention were flagged right in the hub.
I received one such notice and the curator suggested I break up blocks of text. I checked and as I most times do, my hub WAS broken up into different sections, with a variety of different offerings. So, I had no way of knowing what particular section wasn't up to snuff.
She also suggested non-blurry photos. I checked and couldn't find which photo appeared blurred.
Oddly enough, I received the opposite feedback today. The editor didn't like my use of one-sentence paragraphs.
But readability scores, which Google apparently uses, encourage short paragraphs of one or two sentences.
I have also been told some of my pictures are blurry. But they are new ones I tried to update older hubs. And normally when an image is blurry, you can see it when your hub is in edit mode. I didn't get a message about the images in edit mode. I think it depends on what moderator you get.
The first hub I posted vaguely said it had "spammy elements", yet under the definitions I actually couldn't find where those elements were within my article. I have nothing else to go on. I do believe that, especially as a new hubber, it would be quite useful for Hubpages to implement these editorial comments into the articles themselves if at all possible.
Spammy elements ALWAYS means they have a problem with either a link or a product capsule. It means the link(s) or product(s) are not closely enough related to the main topic of the Hub.
It seems they use scripted responses, so without being specific, this is too vague in some cases.
I too find the suggest edits are vague. It is boiler plate. It would be much better if the edit suggestions were just a little more specific. I have to guess at what is wanted. I spent 3 hours redoing a hub yesterday--new pictures and total reformatting--and I'm not sure if what I did made things worse or better. (Admittedly, this one was unusual-it usually takes less than a hour to do the edits.)
Do you know if they did away with snipping? I found that was working very well, and eliminated guesswork.
It is annoying to be told that text needs to be broken into capsules when that has already been done, and to read that photos are blurry, when they aren't. Or to read a suggestion to shrink a photo that isn't as clear, when you have already done that.
They have probably not done away with "snipping." I had a hub snipped and moved just two days ago. I think if the changes desired are very minor, the Edit Pro will do it. If they want more extensive changes, you get the vague boilerplate.
by Catherine Giordano2 months ago
I submitted this hub to delishaby and got an email back saying some of the photos were blurry and my hub could not be moved until I fixed them. However, in edit mode, I don't get a blurry photo warning. They...
by Rahul Parashar13 months ago
I have had a few of my hubs moved to niche sites before. Not anymore, though. None of my hubs has been moved in last 2 months. Is it happening with everyone?
by Caren White2 weeks ago
I was under the impression that we could only submit one hub every two weeks for niche sites. I submitted a hub and an editor replied with changes that I needed to make before it could be moved. As I'm...
by Cholee Clay3 weeks ago
I have an article that an editor has made substantial changes too. Including adding a bio that they wrote themselves. I have not seen an edit this bad in quite some time on one of my articles, and I do not want to go...
by William F Torpey7 months ago
Re: My Hub https://hubpages.com/literature/The-Hou … -It-for-MeThis hub has been featured for a rather long time. It recently has been marked as Not Featured with a comment that it may have spammy elements....
by Brandon Lobo12 months ago
Hey everyone, I recently got a mail saying my recently published hub "How Do Magnets Work" is eligible to be moved to Owlcation and that I need to make some small changes before it could be moved:Keyword...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.