All new hubbers!
Instead of coming on here and asking people to critique your hubs you really are better off looking at other people's hubs and following their leads.
You see there are great people here who are great hubbers. There are also a lot of great hubs explaining how to write a good hub.
If you are doing it just to get comments then don't.
All you need to do is write good hubs, be active and then some very popular hubbers will look at you and you will get the comments.
If you are hubbing for money then you would do better reading other hubs on monetizing and SEO then begging for comments.
Hubbers are friends but will make you no money. Its the traffic you drive to the hubs from out side sources that are going to make you the money.
This post isn't meant to be mean to the new hubbers because I am still a new hubber at only a month old. I too love the comments but my Hub friends are finding me.
Anyways that's enough for now. I think I feel a new hub coming on.
this hub is all about that...
would be glad to help
I've always thought it kind of phony attention seeking way when people ask for criticisms first thing as soon as they come in. When I came on here, I asked for NOTHING!
I went through most of the comments and as a newbie, it was helpful to read most of the forums and get the gist of the do's and dont's here.
Having an interest in the Seo and money making side of the web, it has been a learning curve so far and have found a great deal of useful info by searching and reading. It is fortunate that a site like hubpages is based on the sharing expertise mentality.So I thank you and those who post great content in their hubpages.
To end with,just writing about my interests in 10 short days and having no comments, I am pleased that I have had 40 view of 4 hubs and counting, that in itself is what i set out to achieve.Just 1 person a day reading what i have written. So I agree with you in that the search to have endless comments is unnecessary.
So thanks for the hubs guys.Keep it up.
Dale in South Africa
Well done Dale - you may only be a month old, but you have clearly learned a lot in that time!
I do think a lot of people misunderstand how to make a success of Hubbing - I can't think of any other explanation for the explosion of meaningless threads in the forums.
Dale, my dear, I agree with some of what you said, but not all. I was a new hubber very, very recently. I did read other folks' hubs at first, but had no good sense of what was considered 'good' and what wasn't. I'd never worked with 'capsules' and the like before. I'm used to having more control over my Adsense placement and look than I do here. Why would I want to spend time writing a bunch of hubs the wrong way, when all of you guys were here to tell me if I was even headed in the right direction?
I did ask for critique, I listened and I haven't asked again. And I see a lot of new folks doing the same. If I hadn't asked, I wouldn't have known that you need to split up your text into more capsules to inject more Adsense or things like that. There are some things here that are simply proprietary to HubPages. I've gotten advice from some of the best like Mark Knowles and others and it's been invaluable.
So chill out and help the newbies. But when you come across an obvious fraud, hit them with both barrels, all guns blazing, and I'll be right behind you.
I really have no problem helping the newbies but lets face it it's quite easy to tell the people who are really looking for help or the people who are just trying to pad their comments.
I am still a newbie but I will be the first to help those who are sincere.
I might even be opening a door here but a newbie is even welcome to send me an email asking for help. I warn you now though. If it is an email just trying to promote something you will be reported.
That's what has made me different the last couple of years. I have been all about helping people who are sincere and trust me I can spot someone trying to fool me a mile away.
I had a few people who were sincere help me on my way in business and I promised myself I would never forget that.
But I do know where you are coming from LOL
Good comments Dale. By watching how successful hubbers do it one can learn quickly. You are going to do well here in my view!
I agree with what you said but I also agree with Irohner. If you ask me, new hubbers who are not familiar with technology will definately come on here and ask for help with things that they could find in other hubs, or by doing some searching around.
I guess there are people who are writers first, technology buffs second. So seeing all of the tools can frighten some and send them asking for help.
Have you ever worked in IT before? If you have, then you'll know that people ask the most mundane stuff in the world but if it's the difference between asking here or not participating at all I'd prefer they ask. =P
But of course, people just trying to promote their shtuff is annoying. No doubt!
Absolutely right. Big difference in a question like "What is the best way to use capsules" as opposed to "Please look at my hub."
Being specific I think will help gain and build trust.
I definitely fall under the new hubber tag and have figured out the ins and outs of the unspoken rule about trying to get other hubbers to your site. By reading other hubs, when I first started writing, I understood that outside traffic is where you will get income, if at all.
When I first signed up, I was doing it mainly as a way to form a new income stream. Now, I am just enjoying writing articles and sharing them with fellow hubbers and have intertwined them with my other websites. It is fun seeing as how I am not an IT guy trying to build this network out on the internet to share feelings, ideas, and topics of discussions just for fun.
Oh...and Dale.....Can I email you....I have tons of questions......just kidding
someone told me my hubs were boring. They didn't mean it harshly, and they were right. I not only made them a fan, but started hunting around hubbers sites like Frog Dropping. I realized then, despite my internet understanding, I was boring the crap out of peole. Funny thing is I am the least boring person on the face of the Earth...my life, my job, everything is like an adreneline rush or being on crack trying to jump a train....lol
OK, but how do you identify a "great hubber"? Is a high rating always indicative of a great hubber?
Read some hubs and trust me you will identify them. of course score has a little to do with it but it goes a lot further than that.
people who are providing great information. people who are willing to help and so forth and so forth.
Dale, lol but I'm not a great hubber yet. Just look at people like , well I was going to name a few names here but I would feel like an a$$ for missing many others.
I believe that everyone has their own opinion about what is great and what is not. For example, if a Hub is full of words that I have to open the dictionary to find the meaning (haha), its not a great hub for me, it may be well written, but if I can't understand the verbiage used, than I loose interest fast.
I'm still a newbie and have had questions, I'll post a broad question or I'll do a search in that little white box up above, it usually pulls up everything I'm looking for!
Hmmm.... I think you guys are missing the point somewhat. Yes. Many folks are here to write great hubs. Many are here to write great hubs and make some pesos doing it. Many are here to try to make money without writing anything decent.
Take Nelle Hoxie. She's a great writer, very intelligent, a great diplomat and a fabulous sense of humour. But she is very much focused on making money.
I'm not quite so sure that a newbie would see or understand the differences.
Hi Dale. I'm one of the new hubbers who's 'guilty' in terms of asking comments for my hubs. I decided to ask for help when I saw that it was kind of overwhelming to see all those stuff you have to 'click' when you first write a hub. Other than that this is my first time in a writing community where anything and everything goes so I really needed some help. I don't regret asking for help because I got really good advices from there. Maybe next time I can return the compliment to another new hubber (although at 2 weeks, I'm still a 'baby' in hubpages).
Thanks for this forum and the thread, I've picked up a few advices again. More power to you! Cheers!
I certainly don't want new hubbers to not ask. All I do is suggest you have a look around first and then ask for specifics. I guess this is more meant for people who are just looking for comments.
I will try and be more specific in my hub.
Cheers and welcome to HubPages. I love it here and so will you.
Well done Mr. Dale. As you know it takes 2-3 weeks to start getting your hub ratings etc.
I couldn't help but notice when you first posted your photo that you seem to be displaying a small trout? As a Kiwi who is used to seeing our kiwi trout in the 10 - 18 lb range, I was wondering if you are holding your trout to show that you could do with a good days fishing??
In all actuality that is an average size walleye. 10 to 18 pounds average that would be fun. But everyday, if I had it my way would be a fishing day.
Walleye is so tasty too practically at every fish fry around here
Good Advice! Comments are nice but asking for crits just for comments is pretty.. umm bla.
SEO-ing for visits, and be part of the community for comments, give and get. Awesome!
I would mainly suggest that new hubbers read the help pages, that is what they are there for. All of their questions can be answered there. I like to help new people and I do try but it gets annoying when you see the same questions again and again and again.
When I first started I read the guide they suggested we download and then read the FAQ. And...after that, when I had questions I asked other hubbers and learned from how they constructed their hubs. It's just as fast as posting a question and waiting for the answers.
Sections set aside (within the Forum) for
We could (if we wanted) even have user friendly stickers attached, and naughty hubbers getta lil sad face or 'a who me' face?
im just a new hubber, and im looking forward of having a lot of friends here, im and hoping also to learn more from them,, hope that we new hubbers were welcome here.....
I know you would have a hard time finding a place better than HubPages for so many things. Especially for a place that welcomes new Hubbers.
As long as you take the time to start figuring things out then you will do fine and easily be accepted.
Hey dale, think you could take a peak at my hubs and tell me what you think...
I agree, I did it. After I wrote my first hub, I asked for an honest opinion. But I had never written anything online other than a status on facebook. Wanted to make sure it didn't sound like I was a babbling idiot. But I didn't know any better at the time, and had no idea that was a way people try to boost their scores or whatever.
In turn, I like reading what comments people make about other peoples hubs. Since they write their hubs differently, I can take the comments on what they do and turn it into better hubs for me.
Just this newbs opinions, thanks for listening
by Vizey7 years ago
I went to the great Hubbers of 90+ and got told I was no good and evil.So I have come to this place to be washed and cleansed before I show my face in the great 'hubasphere' once more.Please come to my rescue I have...
by Marisa Wright3 years ago
I'd like to suggest we get rid of Hubber Score - and perhaps even Hub Scores. They:- are constantly misunderstood;- cause a lot of upset and grief in the forums; and- encourage newbie Hubbers to direct their...
by LongTimeMother3 years ago
I respect the work of many hubbers, but at the very top of my list is 'peeples'. I am a great fan of this extraordinary woman and when you go to her profile page you will see why. Peeples is now homeless. Follow this...
by Sabrina Yuquan Chen (陈玉泉)6 years ago
There are two newly discovered hubbers who have only posted raw translations by using online translating tool, what they did was merely copy and paste the results without doing any further modifications. From the...
by Aivaras3 years ago
I'm little bit confused. I wrote 7 articles, all of which are long and good quality contet, well illustrated, featured. Nevertheless in sum of all views in one month I got less than 200. Also only three people started...
by Lgali9 years ago
I like most is quicksand, he always productive comments on my all hubs
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.