-Make a generalized statement about all Marines or Soldiers. What do you think all have in common in how they act or live? Do you think they are stupid or careless?
I truly salute them. For I was a poor military woman, scared as shit. I was on a naval ship and when I had to train for fire rescue, I was on the front line, that did me in. I couldn't take it, knowing I would have to go first and maybe die. I am a sad soul indeed. Or at least I use to be. We need our military, and if I were young again, maybe I would join up with the Army. But then again, I think I am needed else were in this battle of humane life.
Thank You for adding. I was looking for a bad generalization that I could argue. lol.
Most marines I ever met were what I call "dingy".
I certainly don't think they are stupid or careless. I see them as more strict and uptight...marine's anyway. But, of course knowing you, we know that is not true
I have nothing against soldiers in the least, if that is their chosen profession then good for them.
Thank You for posting. Lmao @ "I see them as more strict and uptight...marine's anyway. But, of course knowing you, we know that is not true " That one brightened my morning! TY
Very commendable comment, it's true sacrifice to fight for your country, even when you disagree with the leader or policies while you are in. Thank You.
Where are the people that are anti-military? No negative comments about military personnel?
You know, I don't think you will find many people who are anti-military. You will find a lot of people against the wars going on but that does not mean they are against the people who are sent into them.
I have seen some in a thread talking about disrespecting military members for being robots. It was a while back, I don't remember the thread or hub. It simply amazes me that anyone would criticize the backbone of their defense or freedom.
Good Answer , I agree.
I dont think soldiers or marines that behave like idiots would last very long either.
Marines are like McDonalds workers. They get taught the basics of the business. The program can be applied to any idiot.
Yes they are robots. They get given an order and they have to obey.
lol Here is the ignorance I was looking for. Do McDonalds workers risk their lives for others freedom? What is the most honerable job you have worked? Like your theory, your ignorance can be applied to any idiot. They obey all orders for the sacrifice they signed up for. The sacrifice of self for others. A sacrifice that you are apparently too ignorant and selfish to understand.
I wanted to add to this. Like the ignorance that produced his comment, his ignorance keeps him from understanding that the military is what gives him the freedom to make his ignorant remarks. He criticizes the very backbone of his free speech. How much intelligence is this?
In his defense, Darkside is not an American with the same rights we enjoy. He may have similar rights but they come from his own country not ours...plus you did ask for a generalized statement not a compliment.
I did ask for a generalization, not a disrespectful ignorant remark in comparing military with a robot or mcdonalds worker. He is clearly misinformed on sacrifice. I'm sure he has military in his country. I don't think they would appreciate being called robots. All military sacrifices individual freedom, not just the US military.
Thank You for taking his defense. He obviously didn't want to defend the comment himself.
Yea, I just like to keep things in perspective. You and I are ex-military and have a different perspective than others. Plus, sometimes we forget that even though we are typing this stuff from the safety of the US, a large part of this community is not from here. We must always respect their culture and remember we don't always have to draw a line and dare someone to cross it because no matter how hard you try, you will never convince everyone that your way of life is better than theirs.
I understand we all have different perspectives. I simply wanted to point out that Marines along with his military all have common ground in sacrificing self for others. I don't think someone should have to be in the military or in the US to understand this. I feel it should be common sense. I also wanted to show that most to all grouped generalizations are false. The negatives ones anyways. Thank You for adding your thoughts.
The deep end: you've gone off it.
So I'm ignorant, misinformed, selfish... did I just not make a generalization? You were after all, looking for an argument...
...and when a generalization is made you throw a little tantrum and start throwing personal insults.
Do me a favour and check out point number 10 on this page. My last position there was Quality Assurance.
I am still swimming.
If I was simply looking for arguements, why have you been the only one I disagreed with out of all the post's?
You first compare me to a mcdonalds worker and robot, then accuse me of firing the insults. Hypocritical.
Why would you make weapons and then criticize military as robots? You supported them. Were you not a robot also?
You really need to get over yourself. What do they say about being careful what you wish for because you might get it? Did you not say "I was looking for a bad generalization that I could argue."?
You were looking for a bad generalization. I gave it to you. And then you had to make a whole bunch of posts that were personal in nature.
Hypocritical on my part or idiotic on your part?
Maybe a little of both, but I am willing to admit my faults, I believe different of you.
I try to be as humble as possible. You make a comment that I need to get over myself. lol. Again, you accuse me of firing the insults.
My remarks was only personal to that specific comment.
When comparing a military member to a robot or mcdonalds worker, what does common sense say the result will be?
If I am an idiot for asking for the bad generalizations, should they just be left uncorrected? To be left uncorrected would be idiotic in my belief.
You miss the point. You are an idiot for asking for one, and then throwing a hissy fit because you got one.
I gave you one, and I already outlined how you made a personal attack, so don't cry now that a person is being insulting back.
Do I really believe what I said? No. But as far as analogies go, it does actually get off to a good start.
About 12 years ago I heard a man in a small business management course I was attending outline a similar analogy. He was talking about business systems. I've mentioned my previous experience. At the time I had a close friend in the army, a brother-inlaw in the army, to name just two, and the guy sitting next to me in the course used to be in the army. Neither I nor he got all riled up. We sat and listened.
I won't go into detail about what was explained or how it was explained, because it would, given your responses in this thread, most likely go over your head. Then again that might just be a generalization I've made about you.
lol... Marines and Soldiers are trained in leadership and discipline. Each new administration has an agenda and sets the mission for all branches of the military. They follow a rule of law that is set by the Uniform Code of Military Justice and swear an oath to uphold the Constitution and defend our country. Unlike a McDonalds worker, they have a sense of honor and duty and most take great pride in what they do. They don't only take orders the give orders. They have many opportunities to prosper in their career and gain valuable knowledge that can transition much more effectively to the civilian world.
Robots, hardly... they make realtime life or death decisions based on their training, experience and situation. If you think I'm wrong, go ask a Marine for a Big Mac and Fries, see what you get in return....
My appologies to Darkside, Thank You for posting this. You gave me the example I wanted of why I posted the thread. In all honesty, thanks for posting this. I appologize for any personal attacks.
Well marine, you got a response that you were looking for.LOL Yeah, I have an idiot son in Camp Legune. So be careful DS, hehe
lol We have heart and compassion also. Not only killing. But the heart/compassion is not trained.
I did not say you don't. But the essence of your job is to kill, slice it or dice it.
The essesne of the job is to defend and to do that sometimes people have to die.
Mine was, yes. But some are trained more to save lives while others are trained to take lives. Richard was trained more to save lives. So not all training is to kill. Maybe in basic. But after that, different training.
As the father of two members of the Military, one Army and one Air Force that have, between the two of them, served 7 combat tours of duty, the term killers is offensive.
These young men like thousands of others provide you a service you can never repay. They protect your life, your liberty, and even your right to post idiotic words.
Spout all you want, but from the first shot, fired in defense, over two hundred years ago they have protected you and your way of life. You may disagree with their use as a whole, but disagree with the civilian authority that directs them. That is completely another argument, one, at times, I might even agree with, but disrespect of the American Soldier will not be tolerated.
If you speak as an enemy and from fear, then good be afraid. Be very afraid.
Afraid of what? That they kill me? It just proves my point
Did you actually make a point? And my comment proves what? You’re afraid? You’re the Enemy? That you are such an anti-war Kool-aid drinker that you can’t think for yourself?
Typically liberal attack, if they can’t respond intelligently, ridicule.
Thanks for the giggles. I know it is hard, but take your time to read my hubs and forum posts, you may see then that your attack was - ummm - misguided, to say it politely
And yes, I made a point, that soldiers by definition kill. You can argue with this as much as you can, it won't change the facts.
Kill, yes when required, agreed. Do they not also liberate, rescue, feed, protect? A soldier by definition: is a person who serves in an Army or is engaged in military service.
They are Killers by your umm.. less than valued opinion Mr. Webster.
A very poor choice of a word as an overall portrayal of their vocation and character.
You are welcome for the lesson.
Perhaps you should apply more of your, Umm, self-evoked talents in your comments rather than require others to research and interpret your folio of manifestos to determine your meaning.
Now if you tell me that Army's purpose is anything else than defeating an enemy, or that there is a military way of defeating an enemy without killing its soldiers, I will laugh even more.
How about I tell you? From the mouth of a liberal, who lives with another liberal who is also a former well-decorated army officer (and yes, I am proud of him and his qualifications/achievements, thank you very much, that's why I'm with him). The military (at least the American army) serves in many peace keeping and humanitarian operations all over the world. In addition to his other 'qualifications,' and high educational level, he was a medic who once delivered a Cuban baby in the middle of a war zone, built a refugee camp, provided rice to the Sudanese.... Well, the list of achievements goes on and on.
I think you need Pest to explain to you what Army is all about. Sure thing, American army was created to deliver Cuban babies, Castro could not do this without American help. They just have those funny armored ambulances with guns, to repel mosquitoes, you know
I don't need to. Like I said, my source of information is very close at hand. I trust that source, and I'll take his word for what our military is and is not, for that matter...
This post is about generalizations, and those who think in generalizations is what it is attracting.
Did he tell you they don't have those funny ambulances they call tanks? Or attack helicopters? Or fighter jets? If you at your age still think the main purpose of Army is providing rice to Sudanese, you need urgent help with connecting back to reality.
I was attacking a generality. But I forget that those who think in such a manner are slightly immune, to say it politely, also, to subtlety.
So the conversation is fruitless...as usual.
Did you actually bother to check the title of the thread by chance? Or did you just came here to confront me, just for a sake of it?
And did you...honestly, OMG...think to ask why Marine would post such a thread?
See, it isn't even fun for me,
So, he posted this thread because you plead the 5th (whatever that means), and he is a cool man. Fine. What this has to do with you attacking my post without any ground for that?
MY BF is ex military, Misha, yeah? And it isn't fun with you because I really have no interest in fighting with you at all, but you seem to want to press the point recently, so there ya go! But, sigh, you do seem to want to lump yerself in there w/ TK...a lot..
And the 5th was about, well, I plead the 5th, .
We are on the verge of losing minimal life from ground combat with the introduction of the drone aircrafts which can be armed and flown with remote. This brings the question, how many lives will the drones take as we move closer and closer to the remote controlled wars.
Misha stop talking about the Marines' bodies jeez lmao Sorry couldn't resist
LOL You mean like killer body? I am not into this, but I definitely see your point
hehehe Sorry Misha but I had to...and EW I dated two Marines one turned out to be psycho...like stalker psycho and the other just wanted a screw body until he moved back to Texas to get back with his ex-wife...and who did he pick ME
I think the biggest misconception about the military is that it is full of thoughtless drones running around with loaded guns looking for a fight. It's just not true. The military has counterpart for nearly every career that is in the civilian world. As Marine stated, I was a combat medic trained to save lives and not just our own. Yes, my first mission was always to defend my country and yes I was trained to kill but in my entire career in the Army, I never shot my weapon at a live target and I did my fair share of saving a few lives.
And I'm just popping out so in case I don't come back and defend my generalisation, that'll be why. I'm foraging. Becuase my soldier ordered me to
lol Marine. The problem isn't so much what he does - rather it's what I don't.
Which is why I'm still here instead of following my sargents' order. Or as he likes to call them - a request.
From which he expects a favourable response. Or else
Not so sure if this is the same in other parts of the world, but here, I heard that the phrase "bring in the marines" means the soldiers can no longer handle the heat of the battle so they call in the marines to do the dirty job for them.
Also when I was going out with a marine, the common thing I always hear is that they have a girl in every place they go to. Wonder if that is really true?
The first one is true, the second one is false.
LOL, now your response sounds familiar. The guy I was going out with also said the SAME thing!
Seriously though, I admire the marines. They have the (extreme) training, the discipline and the unity not always found in the soldiers.
The first one is obviously false... The Marines go in first and the Army comes in to clean up.
The second one...well that's the Navy, they have a girl at every port.
I take offense to that comment about the Navy, Richard. Not every Navy man is a cheating idiot! And i hate when people talk about the military as a whole like that!
LoL crazdwriter, you'll have to ask your husband about inter-military humor. We all love and respect each other but we all have our humorous anecdotes about the other branches... I have a long line of Navy men in my family as well as Army and Marines but none of us were weak enough to join the Air Force...lol
Yes well when it comes to the spouses you should watch what you say...I take offense to it humor or not.
Air Force women are the bravest in the military!
Hmmmmm, actually soldiers go in first, then they call the Marines to fix things up, then when things are fixed, soldiers go in again for the clean up and to take the credit .
On the second one? Here, the mother company of marines is the navy so I guess like mother (navy), like daughter (marines)? Like generalizations go, this one obviously has some truth behind it but it doesn't apply to all cases, all the time.
I'm married to my wife. You take him. lol
My husband served in the first Gulf War. He is a wonderful man. The Army taught him a lot. The army helped him get his shi** together. He was injured in the war by a land mine, but I don't think he would have traded the experience of getting to serve our country for anything. I admire anyone who sets foot on foreign soil to risk his/her life for our country.
My husband is a Navy Corpsman working with the resevre Marines out here in Cali. He is very brave and I love him for doing what he does. Even when back when he was attatched to a ship and I had to live 6 months without him on an island far from family and friends. He is my strength and my one true love.
Military men and women make me proud. And the arrogant jack@$$es who put them down disgusts me. I am very proud of the military and am proud to be a part of it.
I don't think there are going to be any anti-military people in HubPages. Probably best to find them in another forum or ezine. I think they (anti-military ones) need their heads examined or most likely just schizophrenics ... I love the guys I write to n they feel the same for me so I have nothing bad to say about our military. Sorry.
I'm very happy you love them, but that doesn't mean that people who are anti-military are schyzo. You sound just as some people in the religion forum
Hey Marine , Were you a real marine ,and if so ,for how long .
I was just curious , and I mean no offence.
I am reminded of that song Freefallin ,thanks for your answer btw.
Have you written about your experiences ,be a good hub.
I was actually asking why Marine posted this thread, you thought.
Sorry, I did not say it clear enough.
No. I like double entendre. Occupational hazard, probably, and also explains what I mean with the 5th, lol, ...but that's all I'll say!
Anyway! Marine posted this because he's ex military and wanted to disprove any generalizations people have about soldiers...or something like that. He's good for things like this.
Marine himself answered my post a few pages ago, and I think we are on the same page with him on this. Still don't see any grounds for friendly fire
Anyway, I am off to bed, good night everybody.
Even though Misha's Post Is a bit lower I wanted to respond to you since you took up the mantle of battle with this <snipped personal attack> and to your BF... Thank him for me. My response to him is as follows:
Interestingly enough if he is off to bed, it would appear,given the time of a normal person's bed time, and the apparent time zone difference he is one of those ungrateful Europeans that have forgotten what American Blood provided for them by killing all those wonderful Nazi's that were so humane in their war fighting and extermination tactics. Do thing names of places like Omaha, Utah, Gold or Sword mean anything to you. You are beneath contempt. I usally do not respond to your ilk but your opinions disgust me and millions of other Americans. Your lack of shame has no depth.
Pretty much, to cancel out all negative generalizations to give the military the respect/honor they deserve for sacrificing personal freedom for others. Even when some they are sacrificing for are unappreciative. I would like to wake some up to understand the military they criticize is the core of why they have free speech to even write or read on hubpages.
Thank you for your comments and support. Much Appreciated.
A former marine, who served in combat (twice), could never become an anarchistic peace activist, who hasn't fought anything but unnecessary hunger in years.
Thank You for your time, Much Appreciated. I think we all fight unnecessary hunger in some way or another, whether we are still in or not.
I cannot thank the armed forces enough for what they do to protect our rights and freedom...thanks you all
Obviously having any kind of serious discussion with you is impossible. Teasing you does not seem like fun either, cause you are so predictable.
Being generally polite person, unlike you, I decided to say bye to you, though. Ciao.
Oh, and I reported your posts for personal attacks.
marine did you write that hub you were talking writing the other night?
Yep, I think so. lol I'm pretty sure I did.
LOL...you don't remember....it was all those unicorns, butterflies and daisy's I believe, that gave you short term memory lost......
I would like to add, I think it's perfectly alright to criticize government for their use of the military. I would be a fool to say the government never misuses the military.
I simply want to point out that when an individual enlists in the military, they sacrifice all freedom/individuality for their country/government. It is not that individuals fault if their government makes a foolish decision, the individual in the military has no choice but to follow the order. The individual sacrificed personal freedom to disagree with the government for the country and citizens. If someone wants to put blame on military for a foolish decision, the blame most often is found in the government.
Well I don't know any!!!
We don't get out much here. I'm not that sure about my point of view in regards to sailors; but obviously in Bumble Town there is a lot of support because the song on the top of our Hit Parade is one called: "In the Navy."
As far as Soldiers goes though we do have a group here who call themselves the Bumble Town Forestry Artillery Unit. They are pretty staunch and have the latest shangis that have a range of 5 miles, depending on the weight of the pinecones used for ammo. You might have heard of them; as they were featured in an article on modern warfare in Janes weaponry in 1992.
(it's on the same page as her recipes for pickled onions).
Glad I could Help
lmao, I have no clue of anything you are talking about. Pretty much all I caught was "In The Navy", fun song. Are you talking about a potato gun military? Thank You for adding what you added, why you added, I do not know, but it worked.
Well then...... I guess you answered your own question!
Perhaps some servicemen should consider:
That irrepective of how primative or misunderstood another country's defenses may seem...
You can Always get your butt kicked!! Even with a Pinecone.
The Art of War has proven this throughout the centuries, has it not?
You may understand.. if you take the time to read my latest hub.
You may find many relevant points within it also.
I was not promoting the wholesale use of potatoes... being of Irish heritage... Potatoes are sacred..
i always hesitate adding anything. these get so heated with people utilizing ad hominem ad nauseum. it seems no one debates. they immediately use their 'pens' as swords to eviscerate without any foundation of real knowledge other than the media and casual conversation with peers to draw from. they do not try to find out both sides them make an informed opinion.
my Marine was drafted out of high school. he went to the University of Vietnam. he served three tours rather than dodge the draft and abandon his country. for that he was called a killer. he killed but he was not a murderer nor did he ever in all the years i knew him use mind murder to win an argument. he was fair, honest, had a high moral compass, and more honor than i've ever known in a person. he was the kind of person others should aspire to be, like a lot of Marines and Air Force and Navy and Army i met over the years.
generalizations are dangerous. there are good attorneys and bad ones. good bankers and bad ones. good doctors and ones with God complexes. there are good soldiers and Marines and bad ones.
on the whole, our military men and women do their jobs with honor, great personal fear at times missing their families and wondering how they might die today, and yes, they follow orders. but not all do so blindly like robots. my husband was a Master Gunney but retired from the Corps as a Master Sargent because he showed a First Lieutenant how not to be too arrogant and almost shoot someone on the firing range. the General was glad my husband had intervened but there had to be that reprisal. my husband wasn't a robot. he didn't always kill. he rescued as well.
that's all i've got to say. and i will hesitate to return to see how my 2 cents has been scanned and twisted to mean something else. it saddens me to see that people are so ready to destroy something with an arrogance they shouldn't feel. only old warriors know what really happened out there. only their families can see the toll defending our country takes. and until Darkside, and whomever else from this country who believes this country's military is unnecessary and nothing but a lot of mindless killing machines, can safely take their families for picnics and hikes in say the lovely hills of Afghanistan with no worries other than ants and possible rain, i guess we will be seeing them honor their convictions by moving to another country. they should pick up a copy of "Man Without a Country" before they check out.
Thanks to you Marine and Pearldriver I instantly thought of the movie Down Periscope and now have the song 'In the Navy' stuck in my head lol thanks guys! lmao
which reminds me my godfather was in the Navy and he was in the submarines...how he did it i have no clue but I am sure proud of him and his wife who had to put up with him gone so much.
No way...I went into a sub once...the scorpion that is sitting next to the Queen Mary in Long beach, Cali. I couldn't do it...too close to each other and I tried to throw myself through the doors like how they have to sometimes and nearly ripped my arms out of their sockets lol
I don't like the idea of being in the middle of the ocean a few hundred feet under the water with torpedos chasing me. I have watched the movie "U-571" too many times. lol
lol yea that is a scary thought too. especially since outside is nothing but bone crushing WATER lol Oh graet thanks...now yu put those lovely thoughts in my head. lmao
lol no problem. Now imagine the subs. engine stops running in the ocean. Now the sub. sinks until it crushes in the depths of the ocean. Imagine that time waiting for the ocean to crush you and the sub. It would probably seem like an eternity. I definately prefer ground over water.
UGH Marine! you big meanie! thanks...now i'm gonna have nightmares of being trapped in a sub!
by Ruben Rivera7 years ago
I am in the Marines and I truly believe everyone has the right to serve their country in the Armed forces. The only issue I have the fact that the military mentality would make it very hard to start the process of...
by ngureco4 years ago
Which Military Force Is Superior - The Army, Air Force, Navy, or The Marine?
by johnb01278 years ago
On facebook, there is a group called 'soldiers are not heroes' and then there is another group 'petition to remove 'soldiers are not heroes' from facebook. This got me thinking....I support the troops. I...
by Kiz10 years ago
Since I was a young teen I've often read emails, articles and other messages retelling stories of inspiration and support toward the men and women of the American military. While so many people argue over things...
by Barbara5 years ago
What suggestions would you offer the military for managing their mental health issues?Returning soldiers have a high rate of suicide-- sometimes due to the amount of deployments they experience or traumatic stress...
by cooldad6 years ago
Should we feel sympathy for soldiers who willingly sign up for war and die in war?This is a serious question. Why should we feel sympathy for people who knowingly and willingly join the military to go to war and...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.